Washington Policy Center rips the Seattle Times for endorsing an income tax it admits lawmakers cannot be trusted to manage
Washington Policy Center's Ryan Frost says the Seattle Times spent months blasting Olympia's spending, then told voters to keep the income tax anyway.
Washington Policy Center budget director Ryan Frost says The Seattle Times editorial board spent all year blaming Washington Democrats for spending the state into a hole, but then turned around and told voters to keep the income tax because those same Democrats will never stop spending.
Frost blasted the contradiction in a column published Sunday, responding to the board’s endorsement urging a no vote on Initiative 645. The measure repeals the 9.9% tax on household income above $1 million while keeping the tax relief attached to the bill that created it. The board’s objection is that lawmakers would then have to pay for that relief without the new revenue, and it expects them to offer something worse.
Frost’s response is that a legislature nobody trusts to control itself makes for a strange reason to hand it more money.
The editorial board spent months saying the opposite
The Seattle Times editorial board has not been quiet about state spending.
In January it complained that no tax increase ever satisfies Democrats in Olympia. In February it demanded a rewrite of the tax code rather than a revenue grab. By March it was criticizing Governor Bob Ferguson for accepting the income tax without the sales and business tax cuts he had asked for, and in April it blamed overspending for the threat to Washington’s credit rating.
Editorial page editor Kate Riley had already conceded in June that readers were catching the disconnect between the board’s complaints and its endorsements.
“Ouch. That is true. Not proud of it,” Riley wrote at the time.
Frost points out that the board’s own warnings vanished the moment voters got a chance to act on them.
“In other words, we are supposed to accept paying an income tax because the Legislature might punish us with a worse tax if we repeal it,” Frost wrote.
Frost says the $1 million threshold is the real exposure
Washington’s two-year operating budget runs $80.2 billion. Frost argues that the honest question is what lawmakers are protecting instead of tax relief.
“If it believes other spending deserves priority over that relief, let it identify that spending and defend the choice,” Frost wrote. “People are tired of hearing excuses to raise taxes because setting priorities is hard.”
He also flags the part conservatives have warned about since the bill moved. The $1 million threshold comes from state law, not the constitution, which means a future legislature can move it. Senate Majority Leader Jamie Pedersen has said he supports a wider progressive income tax.
The survey number that did not make the endorsement
The board cited polling showing 61% support for taxing income above $1 million, including 54% among Republicans. Frost notes that the same DHM Research survey asked what happens when the threshold drops to $100,000, and support fell to 36%. That figure did not appear in the endorsement.
“Voters should have no patience for this hypocrisy,” Frost wrote.
Washington voters have rejected a state income tax every time it has reached the ballot since 1932, a streak that has held through eleven attempts. This November they get the chance again, with the state’s largest newspaper telling them to pass on it and public sector unions funding most of the opposition to repeal.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
4 Comments
"The American Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public's money." Alexis De Tocqueville
"It may easily be foreseen that almost all the able and ambitious members of a democratic community will labor without ceasing to extend the powers of government, because they all hope at some time or other to wield those powers. ... Centralization will be the natural government." —Alexis de Tocqueville
The Seattle Times is trash. It's nothing more than a communication arm of the Democrats.
maybe Frost should be governor