ADVERTISEMENT

SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Rantz: Cantwell and Hobbs blamed Trump for rejected WA ballots. The data starts in 2022

Cantwell and Hobbs blamed Trump for rejected Washington ballots. State data shows the problem started in 2022, and the drop box money skipped rural counties.

Ballot box...

A case out of Ocean Shores proves why every vote matters. (KIRO Radio)

(KIRO Radio)

In Yakima County, nine percent of the ballots voters returned by mail in the August primary were never counted. Sen. Maria Cantwell and Secretary of State Steve Hobbs held a press conference in Seattle last week to explain why, and the explanation they settled on was Donald Trump. But their claims are not actually supported by the data.

The two Democrats said late-postmark rejections jumped 32% statewide over the 2024 primary, with rates more than doubling in 19 counties. They blamed a Postal Service rule finalized in December that moved postmarking from local post offices to regional processing and distribution centers. Cantwell’s advisory tied it to the president’s alleged effort to suppress mail-in voting. Every Seattle station ran it more or less as delivered.

The rejection problem is real, and rural voters are getting the worst of it. What fell apart is the story built on top of it, which stopped making sense the moment anyone looked at the years before December. This is the same office that had no record of hundreds of undelivered King County ballots found next to a Renton dumpster earlier this year.

A map that looked familiar

State Rep. Josh Penner (R-Orting) published the county-level analysis first. The Orting Republican says the press conference followed inside 48 hours, with no credit.

“And if you look at the Secretary of State’s map, it looks shockingly like the map I produced. However, the fundamental issue is that in the August primary, 1 in 29 votes were tossed out in the state and quite a bit more in rural counties. In fact, in several precincts in rural counties, up to 30% of votes were tossed out,” Penner explained on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.

ADVERTISEMENT

The timeline is where the Democrats’ case comes apart.

“But they don’t look at the data going backwards, that this pattern is a multi-years-long pattern that started in at least 2022. And the large number of rejected ballots can be traced directly back to at least August of last year. And so right now, they’re just spinning in circles trying to find a reason to blame the Trump administration, when in Washington state, we create our own problems here, and our own problem is rejecting ballots,” Penner said.

The state’s own annual reports back him. Measured against ballots returned by mail, the too-late rate ran 1.64% in the 2022 primary, 1.94% in 2024 and 3.42% in 2026. It climbed 18% between 2022 and 2024, years before the December rule existed. Clallam County nearly quadrupled its rate inside that same window.

The 32% figure Hobbs already moved away from

When I pressed the Secretary of State’s office, communications staffer Helen Smith acknowledged that the 32% figure handed to reporters used a denominator that includes drop box ballots, which cannot be rejected for lateness. On the corrected calculation Hobbs now says is the right one, the increase is 76.6%. His office briefed every newsroom in Seattle with a number it disowned two days later.

ADVERTISEMENT

Most of that 76.6% is the denominator moving rather than voters losing votes. Mail returns fell 28.9% as people switched to drop boxes while rejections rose 25.6%. Fewer people mailing ballots appears to mechanically inflate the share of mailed ballots that fail.

The county data has its own holes. Ferry County reported zero late-postmark rejections across two straight elections after reporting 24 in 2022. Wahkiakum recorded fewer this year than in 2022. Skagit’s mail-return share bounced from 33% to 72% to 29% in four years. Counties swinging that hard in both directions point to local process, not a uniform federal change.

Rural mail delivery actually improved

Rural delivery performance moved the opposite direction from the theory.

“Yeah, it’s certainly gotten worse in the last two years, not in the just last month. This has been a two-year process of getting worse. Interestingly, it cuts against the fact that because of some of the changes at the USPS in the last year, long haul mail and mail from rural districts has gotten more efficient and better. The timeliness of deliveries has actually improved,” Penner said.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Postal Service denies changing how ballots get postmarked. Hobbs’ office concedes a point Cantwell never has, arguing impact rather than intent. And the network consolidation underneath all of this rolled out under Joe Biden, when congressional Democrats were the ones filing the complaints. This is also the Secretary of State who left the country twice during the 2025 election cycle, including during ballot counting.

Twenty-one drop boxes, none of them where the crisis is

Smith also told me the state reimbursed counties for new drop boxes, eight in Jefferson County, four in Lincoln, eight in King and one in Whatcom. Twenty-one boxes. Zero in Yakima, Stevens, Okanogan, Mason, Franklin or Benton. Every county Hobbs named as a disaster zone got nothing, while Jefferson and Lincoln turned into two of the best performing counties in the state.

Penner had not heard it.

“Well, I think it’s certainly within the budget capacity of the state to implement immediately. I’d be happy to reach out to Secretary of State’s office and request they do so. It sounds to me like if there was a request made that they would do it, since they’re already talking about it at a press conference,” he said.

ADVERTISEMENT

He also noted that the counties bleeding votes include Democratic ones like Jefferson and Whatcom, and that the worst numbers cluster in competitive districts.

What to do with your ballot

No legislative fix is coming before next June, which means voters are on their own in November, when the income tax repeal and a stack of local measures are on the ballot. King County elections officials were already telling voters to skip the mailbox during the August primary.

Penner wants voters watching their own ballot go into a box, and he thinks the quiet nature of this is why nobody has rioted over it yet.

“If you walked into a voting booth, and they told you right there on the wall, there’s a 5% chance that your vote’s not going to be counted today, no matter what you do in that voting booth, people would be out with pitchforks. But because it happens slowly and through the mail, and there’s 5,000 ad hoc solutions to every error, the problem happens quietly. People don’t notice it, and it happens over at least 17 days every voting cycle,” he said.

ADVERTISEMENT

Use a drop box. Watch it go in. Sign up for ballot tracking. And understand that the people warning you about disenfranchisement ignored the data that made their case weak.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

7 Comments

B
Big Dog 2 months ago

My comment was pretty tame, My Northwest is a Democrat front. Time to stop clicking on this site.

J
Jeff E 2 months ago

If there were only a simpler way... on election day...

B
Blaine G. 2 months ago

Seems that rural, conservative areas are losing the most votes.