Washington’s top-ranked college let students interrogate Republican group about Trump, then denied their club by unanimous vote
FIRE says Whitman College let its student senate deny the campus Republican Club recognition over politics. The college has until Sept. 14 to answer.
FIRE is demanding Whitman College reverse its student senate's unanimous refusal to recognize the campus Republican Club. (FIRE)
(FIRE)
A national civil liberties group is demanding that Whitman College overturn its student government’s unanimous refusal to recognize a campus Republican club, saying the private Walla Walla school let elected student officials punish conservative students for holding the “wrong” politics.
The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) sent a letter Monday to Whitman President Sarah Bolton over the March 8 vote by the Associated Students of Whitman College Senate (ASWC) against the Whitman Republican Club’s affiliation application. Affiliation carries funding, institutional backing, and access to campus resources that ASWC already hands to openly ideological groups, including Planned Parenthood Generation Action and the Climate Justice Coalition.
FIRE obtained the senate minutes from that meeting and they do not read like a review of paperwork.
Student senators demanded a loyalty test
Before the vote, senators grilled Republican Club representatives about the national party platform and about President Donald Trump rather than about the club’s constitution or its compliance with ASWC rules.
“On the 2024 [R]epublican party platform subsection 18, what is your club’s take? Will you call the [R]epublican party out for things like this?” one senator asked, according to the minutes quoted in the letter.
Another demanded the students account for the president. “President Trump has made life hard for all international students. When you don’t get affiliated, what is your plan?” that senator asked.
A third senator used a closing statement to tell the group to drop the Republican name altogether, the minutes show. “You can name yourselves whatever you want, but the language of your constitution is in direct contrast to our own constitution. I would suggest that you scrub the title and make a debate club.”
FIRE says Whitman made a promise it has to keep
The letter argues that the college cannot outsource its way around that guarantee by letting a student legislature decide which politics deserve funding.
“While some students may oppose the ideas of Whitman Republican Club, Whitman College may not refuse to recognize a student organization due to the group’s views, missions, or expression without transgressing its laudable commitment to protect students’ expressive rights,” FIRE wrote.
The letter warns that a recognition process governed by student sentiment eventually collapses for everyone, not only Republicans.
“If recognition became contingent upon groups engaging only in palatable expression to the most sensitive ASWC members, there would be few groups left for Whitman students to join, as virtually every viewpoint is offensive to someone,” the letter states. “And because the ASWC is an elected body, its exercise of unfettered discretion to determine group affiliation means that every group’s ability to organize and speak on campus is subjected to what amounts to a popularity contest based on the ideological and political preferences of the day.”
Whitman has until September 14 to respond
FIRE asked for a substantive response by the close of business on September 14, and it wants Bolton to intervene directly if the student senate discriminates again this fall when the club reapplies.
Whitman already carries a yellow light speech code rating from FIRE for policies vague enough to invite arbitrary enforcement. The 1,500-student college was named the top school in Washington in a 2024 WalletHub ranking, beating out UW and Gonzaga, and sits on an endowment of roughly $848 million.
Conservative students elsewhere in Washington have had better luck. A UW professor won a Ninth Circuit ruling last year after administrators retaliated against him over a parody land acknowledgment, a case FIRE also backed.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
5 Comments
I suspect if a democrat student club was being denied access that every other student group freely received, your position would be different.
Yes, Whitman College receives Federal Funding through student financial aid programs and Federal Grants.
Except that they receive federal grants with strings attached.