ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: 483,000 people overstayed their visas last year, and Seattle media is furious ICE arrested one of them

KING 5 and the Seattle Times turned a Sea-Tac visa overstay arrest into an outrage story. Jason Rantz on the facts both Seattle newsrooms left out of it.

ICE agent...

Federal immigration agents are arresting travelers with expired visas at Seattle-Tacoma International Airport, and Seattle newsrooms are calling it an emergency. (Photo by Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images)

(Photo by Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images)

Amina Khalifa was arrested at Seattle-Tacoma International Airport on Aug. 10 by ICE agents waiting for her at the gate, and the reason is not a mystery. Her student visa expired. Federal agents enforced a statute that has been sitting on the books, largely unenforced, for years. Two Seattle newsrooms have now converted that into a civil rights emergency.

KING 5’s Sharon Yoo, our local resistance reporter who routinely treats any ICE enforcement as a controversy, published the first version on Aug. 24, built almost entirely on an interview with Khalifa’s immigration attorney. The Seattle Times followed with a longer piece adding two more immigration lawyers, all making the same argument, that arresting someone who is out of status is unjust because it used to not happen. Neither asks what changed and why.

The answer is in the Seattle Times story itself. The paper just does not seem to notice what it published.

The Seattle Times explains its own story and misses it

The Times reports that nearly 483,000 people overstayed their visas in fiscal year 2024 alone, citing the most recent DHS data available. It then reports that under previous administrations, immigrants with active immigration applications were not treated as unlawfully present and were not prioritized for deportation unless they committed a crime.

But that second sentence describes a policy preference, not federal law. Nothing in the Immigration and Nationality Act was amended to make an expired visa acceptable so long as you have filed something. The Biden administration decided not to pursue an entire category of people, and Seattle reporters have spent this week treating that decision as a constitutional right Donald Trump revoked.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Times even called these cases a kind of legal gray area. But there is no gray area in the statute. There was one in enforcement, which is a very different thing, and it existed because the last administration wanted it there.

Then comes the number meant to alarm you. The Trump administration set a target of 2,000 immigration arrests per day, double its rate from earlier this year, which Yoo hammers in her recent reports on enforcement. Weigh that against 483,000 overstays in one fiscal year. It only looks aggressive next to a baseline of near-total abandonment.

KING 5 gives you the attorney’s version and stops

Yoo’s story runs on one source with one interest. Attorney Olia Catala told KING 5 her client had filed everything and had work authorization.

“She has work authorization, she was doing everything right,” Catala said.

Catala is a defense attorney making a public case for a detained client and is under no obligation to volunteer anything that complicates it. A reporter is supposed to supply that part. Yoo instead notes that Homeland Security’s statement did not explain specifically why Khalifa was arrested, as though a federal agency owes a local television station a case file on demand. It’s worth wondering if Yoo learned about the visa overstay and edited it out of the story or she didn’t bother to ask because she is a partisan open-borders activist cosplaying as a reporter.

ADVERTISEMENT

The complaint is enforcement itself

Nothing in this coverage actually objects to how the arrests were carried out. The Times reports with visible unease that TSA now shares domestic passenger information with ICE, which cross-references it against immigration records. Two federal agencies comparing their own files is the most basic version of a government knowing what it already knows.

There is a genuine scandal buried in this reporting. A system with 1.4 million pending asylum claims and interview waits approaching a decade is a system that manufactures exactly the situation Khalifa is in. Fix the backlog and the gray area disappears.

That story would require naming who let the backlog metastasize, and it would not deliver a villain in a federal windbreaker. So Seattle gets the same framing KING 5 broadcasts nearly every week, where the arrest is the outrage and who got arrested is a detail nobody chases. The station already turned a detainee transfer in a church parking lot into agents menacing preschoolers. ICE Seattle, meanwhile, keeps publishing the names and rap sheets of the people it actually arrests, and those never make the evening broadcast.

ADVERTISEMENT

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

5 Comments

B
Blip Ferguson 3 months ago

round 'em up and ship 'em out

L
Lori D. Stach 3 months ago

Sharon Yoo, from the reporting here, appears to be a complete HACK "reporter" who, like is mentioned in this article, makes crap up by not doing a nano- seconds worth of research for the facts or truth!
I do NOT watch channels 5 or 7, bc of their slanted reporting and I rarely watch channel 4, except to see Theron Zons(sp) weather forecasts and his "Stranger than Fiction" stories!

K
k keenan 3 months ago

F the "Seattle media", they are nothing but communists who think they are important to the big picture which they are NOT! Who listens to or watches the local media anymore, all they do is pick and choose what "stories" they want to air, again, F the local communist media!