Rantz: Mayor Katie Wilson’s answer to Seattle’s housing collapse is a committee that reports in 2027
Seattle permit applications are down 60 percent. Mayor Katie Wilson's answer is a task force that reports back in September 2027.
Seattle's median home price fell to $891,500 in August as active inventory reached a 15-year high. (Photo: Julia Dallas, MyNorthwest)
(Photo: Julia Dallas, MyNorthwest)
Seattle building permit applications have fallen roughly 60 percent from a normal pre-pandemic year and they have dropped year over year in four of the last five years. Mayor Katie Wilson’s response? An advisory group that gets 12 months to explain to her what we already all know.
The Housing Production Task Force, the size of which we still don’t know but indications are that it will be bloated, will work through what her new executive order calls key issues. A status update goes to the mayor by February 15, 2027. Final recommendations come September 15, 2027. Those recommendations then shape a legislative agenda in 2028. In other words, a builder who wants to break ground this fall gets to sit through two Seattle winters while a committee writes a draft on how to make it easier?
The city says it needs 112,000 new housing units by 2044. It is not going to get them out of this long process, especially since the city can immediately implement helpful new policies.
The diagnosis is sitting in her own executive order
If you read the whereas clauses in her executive order, you’ll see that Wilson’s document states that the 2025 Comprehensive Plan found city-issued permits and requirements are tied to the public right-of-way, and water and utilities are a significant barrier to housing production, both affordable and market rate.
The city studied itself, named itself as the obstacle, put the finding into a comprehensive plan, and then stapled the finding to an order creating a task force to go find the obstacle. Uhm, okay?
The order also promises the task force will ground itself in existing housing needs and production data. Existing, as in we already have it. The King County Countywide Housing Needs Assessment came out in 2025. The Comprehensive Plan came out in 2025. The Countywide Planning Policies spell out the 112,000-unit target and the income breakdown under it. The permit numbers are published. The order itself cites the fact that 61 percent of Seattle’s rental stock is a studio or one bedroom, and that the share of Seattle’s population under 18 has slid to 14 percent, near the bottom for big American cities. Nobody on this task force is going to discover a new number unless the data continues to slide in the wrong direction because nothing is being done.
State lawmakers already did the homework Seattle wants to redo
The legislature spent the last three sessions dismantling the exact barriers Seattle wants to convene about. Middle housing legalization. Transit-oriented development. Permit review timelines. Limits on subjective design review.
Wilson’s order admits it. Buried in Section C, under work already underway, is a line about incorporating recent state law changes to advance middle housing and transit-oriented development and reform permitting. Lawmakers handed Seattle a to-do list, and City Hall answered by forming a group to discuss whether to start it.
I don’t even support all the proposals from urbanists pushing their housing agenda but can we at least let them fail already rather than prolong this painful and unnecessary process?
The committee is built to produce nothing
Look at the seats on the task force. Labor, affordable housing providers, community-driven organizations, and market rate developers. The order never says how many people, sets no minimum or maximum, names no appointment process, and gives no criteria for balancing the four groups. Wilson’s office can seat 12 or 60 and nobody can call it a violation.
Then count the mandates! Funding strategies for housing below 50 percent of area median income. Changes to the Mandatory Housing Affordability (MHA) program, which already collapsed once this summer when low-income developers rejected an 80 percent fee cut. The future of design review. A pipeline for people exiting homelessness. Homeownership and anti-displacement strategies. Preservation of existing affordable stock. Input on the 2028 state legislative agenda.
Seven assignments, four constituencies, with one consensus document. Three of those four seats represent interests that, whatever their merits, add cost and time to a construction project. The group that actually finances and builds housing at scale gets a quarter of the table and no guaranteed membership headcount. A room like that does not recommend deleting requirements. It recommends adding programs, and the draft comes back longer, more expensive, and unanimously supported.
What she could sign tomorrow instead
None of what can help takes a year to implement.
Put a hard time limit on every residential permit, department by department, and refund the applicant’s fee when the city blows the deadline. Publish a monthly scorecard showing how long each department took (SDCI, City Light, SPU, SDOT and Fire), by project, and by name. Set an enforceable deadline for utility connections rather than a stated intent to improve them. Exempt code-compliant projects from design review. Let developers pay MHA fees at certificate of occupancy rather than at permit issuance, so the money comes out of a finished building instead of a construction loan.
You don’t need a committee for any of this; you just need a mayor to act.
Remember, this is the same mayor who promised 500 shelter units before the World Cup and delivered 75, and who answered rising rents by proposing a ban on so-called junk fees that moves the same charges into base rent. But this task force will produce results?
Builders stopped filing applications because getting a project through Seattle takes too long, costs too much, and nobody can tell you in advance how long or how much. And this doesn’t even account for developers worried about the future of the city with crime, homelessness, and other cost-of-living concerns. Why is this so hard to understand?
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
6 Comments
Performative politics. A task force to create a study is what you do when you have no idea what to do, or you don't have the courage to make hard decisions. But if you have made it to your ,40s without ever having a job and still living off mommy and daddy, making hard decisions is not in your wheelhouse.
Jason you're making way too much sense here.
I'm afraid we're going to have to create a commission of indeterminate size to study your comments of indeterminate topics to identify and disclose indeterminate next steps and present findings at an indeterminate date.
Indeterminately yours,
Your readers.
Before she became mayor Katie Wilson lived off her parents and lost money running a non profit with a budget of roughly a million dollars, but sure let's have her plan for the coming decades of a major city, what could possibly go wrong?