Rantz: Edmonds banned Flock cameras, then went 24/7 on the ones that pay in obvious cash grab
Edmonds banned Flock, then went 24/7 on speed cams. Hypocrites who need the money, not the safety. The fine schedule proves the whole thing is about revenue.
The Edmonds City Council voted 5-2 to run school zone speed cameras 24 hours a day, seven days a week. (Photo courtesy of SDOT/Flickr)
(Photo courtesy of SDOT/Flickr)
The city of Edmonds offered a very off-Broadway performance when it warned residents that Flock cameras pointed at cars were a threat to their civil liberties. But look at what happened last week. The city council voted to point cameras at cars 24 hours a day, seven days a week. The only thing that changed is that these cameras make the city money.
The council voted 5-2 last week to run school zone speed cameras around the clock near Chase Lake Elementary, Westgate Elementary, Scriber Lake High School and Edmonds-Woodway High School. Those cameras currently run about 90 minutes a day, split between morning drop-off and afternoon pickup. Under the new ordinance, drivers going 7 mph or more over the limit get a $144 ticket after school hours, and a $290 ticket during them. City officials estimate the change will bring in roughly $1 million.
Three months ago this same city government decided license plate readers were too invasive for Edmonds. Now it wants a camera watching that same road at 3 a.m. on a Saturday in July.
Edmonds killed the cameras that caught criminals
In May, Edmonds canceled its Flock Safety contract and became the third Snohomish County city to rip out its automated license plate readers (ALPRs), citing privacy concerns and a report that the FBI wanted warrantless access to a nationwide plate reader network.
“Not only here in Edmonds but across the country, (Flock cameras) have been very effective,” Mayor Mike Rosen told the council in May. “When there are Amber Alerts, they have found missing children. They’ve helped find murder suspects, they’ve helped in human trafficking, they’ve helped in stolen cars, and they do it in remarkable speed and across jurisdictions. However, they also come with their own controversies.”
Then he shut all 19 of them off anyway, cameras paid for entirely by a $131,880 state auto theft prevention grant.
That is the Edmonds standard now. Cameras that find missing kids and stolen cars are creeping surveillance. Cameras that mail $144 tickets to people driving home from work are a public safety necessity. The city held that privacy principle (which is contrived) right up until somebody put a revenue opportunity in front of the council.
The fine schedule gives the whole thing away
If Edmonds believed its own safety argument, the fines would be identical at every hour of every day. A kid hit at 4 p.m. on a Tuesday and a pedestrian hit at 2 a.m. on a Friday are equally dead. Instead the council priced the off-hours ticket at $144 and the school-hours ticket at $290, which means it is weighing traffic volume rather than lives.
The deterrence claim falls apart just as fast.
Nobody rearranges their driving habits over $144. Set the fine at $1,000 and watch how quickly Edmonds drivers find the brake pedal at midnight. No council will ever do that, because a penalty steep enough to stop the behavior collects nothing, and collecting is the entire point. Tacoma ran the same play when it raised its traffic camera fines and called it road safety.
The city pitched the money itself
A two-week study this summer found roughly 6,400 drivers would have been ticketed for going at least 7 mph over the limit had the cameras been running all day and night. That is 6,400 billable drivers sitting uncollected in two weeks at four intersections.
Drivers get a monthlong grace period of warning letters before the real tickets start.
Edmonds switched off the cameras that catch car thieves and switched on the ones that bill commuters. Council members can call that protecting children if it helps them get away with a cash grab. Anyone rolling past a dark, empty elementary school at 1 a.m. with a flashbulb popping behind them will know exactly what it is.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
2 Comments
To be clear, it is not about volume for the ticket fine difference. ANY school zone ticket costs more than a "normal" speeding ticket. If you are speeding in a school zone the fine is increased as opposed to if you are in the same spot during non-school zone hours. Edmonds would not be the only city falling into this current scheme with cameras ... Look around
easy enough - boycott edmonds