Tech CEO asks why Seattle City Council votes are almost always unanimous, even after warnings
Keith McCall says Seattle councilmembers warn about the deficit and rising taxes, then approve them anyway, nearly always without one dissenting vote.
The Seattle City Council is proposing millions in amendments to Mayor Katie Wilson's budget.(Seattle Channel)
(Seattle Channel)
A Seattle-area tech executive is publicly asking why a City Council that keeps warning about the city’s finances almost never votes like it.
Keith McCall, CEO of geospatial data firm Omniris Group and founder of Bellevue-based Pollen Systems and Everyvine, put the question to his network in a LinkedIn post that has circulated among Puget Sound business leaders. Councilmembers warn about the structural deficit and the tax burden in committee, he argues, and then approve the taxes and the spending anyway, usually without a single no vote.
McCall singled out Public Safety Committee Chair Bob Kettle as a councilmember who has voiced those concerns. Kettle has done that repeatedly this year, including pushing back on Mayor Katie Wilson’s proposed transportation sales tax hike that would carry the city rate to 10.80%. But how does he vote on these issues?
Warnings in committee, yes votes on the dais
McCall wrote that the distance between the warnings and the roll call is what worries him.
“I’m becoming increasingly concerned by what appears to be a pattern in Seattle politics,” he wrote.
“That raises a reasonable question: if councilmembers represent different neighborhoods with different priorities, why do the final votes so often appear unanimous?” he added.
Kettle himself illustrated the point in July. The council unanimously approved back-to-back 9.5% Seattle City Light rate increases for 2027 and 2028, roughly $20 more a month once both take effect, and unanimously sent a doubled transit sales tax to the November ballot. Kettle voted yes on the rate hikes, then reminded colleagues that residents are already taking on higher sales taxes, property taxes, and now higher utility bills.
McCall asked whether councilmembers have grown secure enough in their seats that they no longer feel obligated to show constituents why they back or reject major policy decisions.
“Or are these votes simply the product of genuine consensus after thorough public debate?” he asked. “Democracy depends not only on the outcome of a vote, but on voters understanding the reasoning behind it.”
The Bellevue comparison
McCall pointed to Bellevue for a benchmark.
“The contrast with Bellevue is worth examining,” he wrote. “Bellevue recently reduced its property tax levy while Seattle property owners continue to face increasing tax burdens. Whether that’s the result of stronger fiscal management, different spending priorities, or other factors, taxpayers deserve a clear explanation.”
Bellevue’s council did not cut the levy outright. It voted 4-2 in November to take the 1% increase allowed under state law, with Jared Nieuwenhuis and Conrad Lee opposed, then certified a 2026 levy of $95,487,103 that came in nearly $6.9 million below the maximum the city could legally have collected, according to council agenda materials. Two members voting no on a 1% adjustment still produced more visible disagreement than Seattle generates on billion dollar items.
Nieuwenhuis has been sharper elsewhere, telling Seattle Red that Seattle’s JumpStart payroll tax sent jobs east to Bellevue while Wilson keeps calling the tax a success.
Spend better before taxing more
McCall’s fix starts with the order of operations at City Hall.
“Recent reporting has highlighted concerns about the cumulative effect of higher sales taxes, property taxes, and other revenue proposals,” he wrote. “The conversation should not begin with, ‘How do we raise more money?’ It should begin with, ‘How do we spend the money we already have more effectively?'”
Wilson’s economic development director has floated new revenue streams beyond the JumpStart payroll tax without ruling out additional taxes, and the mayor has signaled interest in a city capital gains tax and a local income tax with the deficit projected near half a billion dollars.
“Healthy democracies are rarely unanimous. They thrive on thoughtful disagreement, open debate, and elected officials who explain not only why they voted ‘yes,’ but also why they voted ‘no.’ Seattle deserves that level of accountability,” McCall added.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
2 Comments
Communists in Lockstep... there ya go
“'That raises a reasonable question: if councilmembers represent different neighborhoods with different priorities, why do the final votes so often appear unanimous?' he (Keith McCall) added."
"No one will really understand politics until they understand that politicians are not trying to solve our problems. They are trying to solve their own problems—of which getting elected and re-elected are number one and number two. Whatever is number three is far behind." ~ Thomas Sowell
"Among the biggest lies of the welfare states on both sides of the Atlantic is the notion that the government can supply the people with things they want but cannot afford. Since the government gets its resources from the people, if the people as a whole cannot afford something, neither can the government." --economist Thomas Sowell