‘The concern here is cronyism’: Nick Brown’s former law firm attempted to influence income tax ballot language
WA Attorney General Nick Brown's former law firm attempted to influence the ballot language of the initiative to repeal the state's income tax, documents show.
WA AG Nick Brown's former law firm attempted to sway the outcome of the income tax initiative, documents show (Photo: Jason Redmond/AFP via Getty Images)
(Photo: Jason Redmond/AFP via Getty Images)
To paraphrase Shakespeare’s Hamlet, there’s something rotten in the state of Washington. Washington Attorney General Nick Brown’s former law firm, which is spearheading the campaign to defeat the initiative that would repeal Washington’s income tax, attempted to influence the AGO’s drafting of the ballot title and language for similar initiatives earlier this year.
“The concern here is cronyism. In what capacity was this law firm is acting?,” Citizens Action Defense Fund Executive Director Jackson Maynard told The Center Square.
Pacifica Law puts its thumb on the scale
In letters obtained by The Center Square, Pacifica partners Paul Lawerence and Kai Smith wrote on March 20 and April 6 “to provide input on the ballot titles and ballot measure summaries…for initiatives that would repeal the recently passed income tax on high income earners.”
The March 20 letter stated, “Washington is one of just nine states that do not tax income, and economists have consistently ranked the state’s tax system, which relies on sales and business taxes, as among the most regressive in the country.”
The Pacifica letters also encouraged the AGO to paint a picture of fiscal calamity should the income tax be rejected by the voters.
“The fiscal analysis of the final bill may identify additional categories of fiscal impact that warrant inclusion depending on their relative magnitude,” the March 20 letter reads. “As a result, your office may wish to consider whether other major programmatic or fiscal effects reflected in the final fiscal assessment should also be included in the title. We would be happy to provide additional input as those materials are finalized.”
Unions get in on the act too
Brown’s law firm wasn’t the only group attempting to stack the deck against the initiative.
On April 9, SEIU 775 Treasurer Adam Glickman emailed AGO Chief of Staff David Postman “thank you for the opportunity to provide input on the ballot titles and ballot measure summaries for Initiative Measures IL27-396 and IL27-939, both of which would eliminate, through repeal or amendment, the recently passed income tax on high income earners (“Millionaire’s Tax”), as well as prohibit income taxes more generally.”
SEIU is one of the largest donors to the campaign attempting to defeat the income tax repeal, which has been entirely funded by public sector unions. Glickman also said in the email, “Hey David – as I had noted, attached are the specific letters we have sent in with specific thoughts and suggestions around the recent initiatives related to SB 6346.”
Postman then forwarded that email to Washington Solicitor General Noah Purcell with the note, “FYI, in case you haven’t seen these.”
AGO says it’s no big deal
Pacifica and the AGO are downplaying these revelations as nothing more than standard practice.
“The AGO’s longstanding policy has been to accept input on ballot titles from anyone who wishes to submit it,” said AGO Deputy Communications Director Mike Faulk. “Over the years we have received input from many individuals and law firms that engage with the initiative process. While we do and will continue to accept input from anyone, we make the final decision about how best to write ballot title language and meet our statutory obligations.”
However, former Washington Attorney General Rob McKenna told The Center Square that the letters are “obviously highly irregular” and didn’t think they were “appropriate.” McKenna added that the “thank you for the opportunity” comment in the April 9 letter “suggest they were solicited.”
A tax that was corrupt from the start
Maynard says seeking the counsel of opponents of the initiative looks even more corrupt given that the proponents of it were never provided a chance to give their say.
“The AG office apparently reached out to this law firm to have them provide their opinion and yet didn’t afford the proponents of these initiatives the same opportunity to provide feedback,” said Maynard. “The Attorney General’s role in crafting ballot titles is not to engage in a campaign either for or against the ballot measure. It’s to accurately describe the content of the initiatives so that voter have the ability to know what the measure actually does. And if what they’re doing is trying to skew it based on their political preferences and the viewpoint of the attorney general as to whether he wants the measure to pass or fail – that is an abuse of power.”
The income tax has been roiled in scandal since its inception. Documents unearthed earlier this year revealed that State Senator Jamie Pedersen (D-Seattle), one of the architects of the tax, intended to use it as a means to challenge Washington Supreme Court precedent in the Culliton decision prohibiting a graduated income tax.
Legislators also conspired with the AGO when drafting the legislation in order to survive constitutional muster and circumvent the will of the voters, which Mckenna also blasted.
“Getting into the role of strategizing with a legislator on how to get around the Constitution just isn’t right,” he told The Center Square.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
2 Comments
It is called corruption. This AG is attempting to top the last one.
Appears someone is a problem, no surprises