Seattle’s oldest toy store is gone after 49 years in Pioneer Square
Magic Mouse Toys, a Pioneer Square fixture since 1977, closed permanently with no explanation from its owners, as downtown Seattle keeps losing small retailers.
Magic Mouse Toys operated at 603 First Avenue in Pioneer Square from 1977 until its permanent closure. (Jason Rantz)
(Jason Rantz)
Magic Mouse Toys is gone after nearly 50 years in Pioneer Square, and the owners have not said a word about why. Paper now covers the windows at 603 First Avenue. A notice taped to the door says the store has closed for business permanently and thanks customers for shopping there for more than 40 years, according to KING 5. Nothing on the sign explains what happened.
The shop opened in 1977 and filled two floors and more than 6,000 square feet inside the historic Mutual Life Building at First Avenue and Yesler Way, selling toys, games, puzzles and candy. It billed itself as the oldest toy store in Washington. The company website was still live Saturday and still listed the store as open.
KING 5 reached co-owner Walter Powers at his home Saturday afternoon. He declined to say why the store shut down and said he would pass the questions along to his wife and co-owner, Pamela Powers, who had not responded as of that afternoon.
Customers found out from the paper on the windows
Shoppers walking through Pioneer Square Saturday were caught off guard. Vanessa Buneg, who lives in Seattle, said she had not been inside since she was about 13.
“When I was younger, we used to come over here all the time,” Buneg told KING 5.
Josh Totten of Vancouver, Washington, remembered it as a fixture.
“Yeah. I mean, it was always there when I was a kid,” Totten said. “My mom and dad used to go in there.”
Pioneer Square keeps losing storefronts
The Powerses owe nobody an explanation, and plenty of family businesses wind down after five decades for reasons that have nothing to do with City Hall or Olympia. What is harder to shrug off is how familiar this has become in the same few blocks.
Collins Pub closed for good on a Friday in July after 23 years on Second Avenue, with no announcement and no stated reason, weeks after the World Cup pushed enormous crowds through the neighborhood. Emerald City Guitars spent the morning of Seattle’s first World Cup match moving 13 portable toilets the city parked across its front door, because nobody at City Hall would do it. Business owners in Pioneer Square have spent years asking for police response, encampment removal and a functioning street outside their windows, and they mostly get told the numbers are improving.
Some of them are. Seattle went the entire month of June without a homicide, the first time since 1970, after the city flooded downtown with officers and cleared encampments for the tournament. Business owners here keep asking why it took a global audience to get that kind of effort.
Downtown’s recovery still has a hole in the middle
The Downtown Seattle Association counted more than 3.2 million visitors downtown in June, roughly 98% of what it saw before the pandemic, though that number was bolstered by the World Cup. Weekday worker traffic sits at about 64% of the 2019 figure, and that gap is the customer base a First Avenue retailer actually lives on.
The rest of the picture is worse. Downtown Seattle carries the worst office vacancy rate of any major market in the country at 37%. A survey by the local business group Intentionalist found only 12% of small business owners said they were bringing in enough to cover basic expenses, with several describing conditions worse than the height of COVID. Tourists buy a souvenir. Office workers buy a birthday gift on a Tuesday, and there are a third fewer of them than there used to be.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
1 Comments
If only someone could figure out what has changed.
Downtown Seattle used to be a destination. Now it is a place to avoid.
Maybe one of the homeless or drug addicts can give us some insight - they spend a lot of time down town, or at least that’s what I am told - I haven’t been downtown in years - it’s too dangerous.