ADVERTISEMENT

POLITICS

Five Washington Supreme Court seats, three initiatives, one slate card

Jim Walsh says four GOP-backed Supreme Court candidates advanced, but three trail. His November plan is door-to-door slate cards.

washington state supreme court...

The Washington State Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that Initiative 2066, the voter-approved natural gas protection measure, is unconstitutional in its entirety. (Photo courtesy of Washington Supreme Court)

(Photo courtesy of Washington Supreme Court)

Five of the nine seats on the Washington State Supreme Court will be decided in November, and Washington State Republican Party Chairman Jim Walsh says all four candidates his party backed survived Tuesday’s primary.

Washington elects its justices, and the court almost never turns over this fast. Two seats are open because Justice Raquel Montoya-Lewis chose not to run again and Justice Charles Johnson hit the mandatory retirement age. Two more are held by justices Gov. Bob Ferguson appointed this year, Colleen Melody and Theo Angelis, both of whom face voters for the first time. Chief Justice Debra Stephens is the only previously elected member of the court on the ballot.

Walsh sees an opening in that turnover, and a plan for closing it that involves paper, doorbells, and very little technology.

Four candidates advanced, three of them trailing

“Five of the nine will be on the November ballot, and we’re very encouraged that four of the judge candidates that we backed, and some of them were in crowded primaries, Jason, as you know, made it through,” Walsh said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM. “They either won the primary, and remember, it’s still just a primary, or they came in second in the top two primary.”

He walked through why the fifth seat skipped the August ballot entirely.

“The fifth race that’ll be in November actually wasn’t on the primary ballot because only two judge candidates filed for that one, and in that case, in judge races, if there are just two candidates, they don’t do a primary; they go straight to November,” Walsh noted. “But in the four others, there were multiple candidate primaries, and some quite crowded. And we’re very encouraged that the judge candidates we like for the state supreme court, all four of them in the primary, are advancing to November.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Encouraging results

The results give Republicans one lead and three deficits.

Mason County Superior Court Judge David Stevens took about 36% in the open Position 3 race, ahead of King County Superior Court Judge Jaime Hawk at 33% and Court of Appeals Judge Mike Diaz at 31%, with the two left-leaning candidates splitting a combined 64% and roughly 19,000 votes separating second from third. Stevens has argued the current court rules by preferred outcomes rather than the constitution.

He did it while getting buried financially. Stevens reported raising about $40,000 to Hawk’s $218,000 and Diaz’s $275,000, according to Public Disclosure Commission filings, with roughly $50,000 in outside spending from Concerned Taxpayers of Washington State, a group funded in part by Let’s Go Washington founder Brian Heywood.

The other three finished behind. Retired Federal Way Municipal Court Judge Dave Larson drew 32.6% to Angelis at 34.2% in Position 5, a gap of under two points and the closest of the challenger races. Larson lost to Justice Sal Mungia in 2024 by about 20,000 votes out of nearly 3.3 million cast. Tax attorney Scott Edwards took 30% against Melody’s 51% in Position 1. Attorney Todd Bloom pulled 27% against Chief Justice Stephens at 55% in Position 7, according to the Washington State Standard. The fifth contest, Position 4, sends Court of Appeals Judge Ian Birk and King County Superior Court Judge Sean O’Donnell straight to the general.

ADVERTISEMENT

The slate card strategy

Rantz asked Walsh how the party connects a voter’s support for repealing the income tax to a judicial race most people skip. Walsh said the answer is not clever messaging.

“Well, it’s always a little bit harder to do that, and to some degree, that is the job of the candidates themselves, but we will be talking to people directly on the ground, door to door, face to face, and giving them the list,” he replied. “I mean, people are asking all the time, Jim, just give me the list. Give me the list of names. Give me the people.”

“So much of doing better in elections in November is just getting people familiar with the names of the candidates. So we will be doing more old-fashioned shoe leather canvassing work, where we’re giving people slate cards,” Walsh added. “So vote yes, yes, yes on the three initiatives, and then vote for Edwards and Stevens with a V, and Larson and Bloom for the state supreme court, and then for the local legislative candidates for John Braun for Congress, whoever else may be involved in that particular area.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The V matters. Voters marking Position 3 are choosing David Stevens, while voters in Position 7 are deciding whether to keep Debra Stephens. The two names sit on the same ballot.

“So we’re going to do more of an old-fashioned focus on building a slate, building a list, building a group of good votes that people can make if they want to fix all that’s broken in Washington,” Walsh added.

A lot on the line

The stakes go past the bench itself.

The court is expected to hear a constitutional challenge to Washington’s new 9.9% income tax after November, which is why Walsh has publicly called on Melody to recuse herself from those cases given her years working under Ferguson at the Attorney General’s Office. KIRO Newsradio noted in May that five seats on one ballot has drawn outside political money into races that used to run quietly.

An incumbent justice in Washington has not lost a re-election bid since 2010. Walsh is betting a piece of paper handed to a voter at the door changes that.

ADVERTISEMENT

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Comments

0 Comments