ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Vancouver police ordered to stop citing shoplifting and public drug use as Democrats designed

Vancouver police were ordered to stop citing shoplifting, public drug use and trespassing amid a public defender shortage. Officers say they can't search now.

a shoplifter bag...

Vancouver police officers were directed to stop issuing citations for shoplifting, public drug use and trespassing because the city does not have enough public defenders to handle the cases. (Photo by Leon Neal/Getty Images)

(Photo by Leon Neal/Getty Images)

Vancouver police officers have been ordered to stop writing citations for shoplifting, public drug use and trespassing, not because those crimes stopped mattering, but because the city cannot find enough public defenders to take the cases. This outcome was precisely what far-left activists wanted to happen.

Police Chief Troy Price laid out the change in an internal memo obtained by KATU News. Instead of issuing a citation on the spot, officers now refer the offense to the City Attorney’s Office and wait for that office to decide whether to charge. The affected offenses include second-degree criminal trespass, trespassing in city parks, third-degree theft covering most shoplifting, disorderly conduct, possession of a controlled substance, using a controlled substance in a public place, and unlawful marijuana possession by anyone under 21.

City officials point the finger at an unfunded state Supreme Court mandate that capped public defender caseloads. The Washington State Bar Association approved cutting maximum caseloads by roughly two-thirds before the high court took up the issue, and counties warned at the time that nobody had figured out how to pay for it. Nobody ever did. Vancouver is now the first sizable Washington city to respond by telling officers to stop enforcing whole categories of crime.

Officers say they can no longer search for the stolen property

Jeff Anaya, president of the Vancouver Police Officers Guild, told KATU the change strips away the legal footing officers need to actually investigate a theft. Without an arrest or a citation, there is no search.

“So, now we have to let the evidence go because we can’t go searching for it,” Anaya said.

He also questioned the direction the city is heading while it claims to care about public safety.

ADVERTISEMENT

“We believe we need more public safety,” Anaya said. “We need more officers to do that, but now we’re going the opposite direction saying, ‘hey, don’t actually arrest for certain crimes.'”

The city says it is protecting domestic violence cases

City Manager Lon Pluckhahn defended the policy by arguing that Vancouver is triaging, since courts assign public defenders on a first come, first served basis with no ranking by severity. He said 55 cases had already been dismissed this year for lack of defense counsel as of June 2.

“This included ten domestic violence cases involving charges such as assault, stalking, harassment, and order violations,” Pluckhahn wrote.

Kaisers countered that prosecutors already had a tool for exactly that problem, since the City Attorney’s Office can dismiss and refile charges later without hamstringing patrol officers.

ADVERTISEMENT

The underlying squeeze is not unique to Clark County. Spokane officials warned this spring they may need to triple their public defender office by 2036 to comply with the same standards, and King County’s defenders have been fighting over caseload language in their contract. Meanwhile, Washington Democrats stripped a public defense funding carveout out of the state operating budget and swapped it for sales tax exemptions, leaving counties to eat a constitutional obligation on their own.

Business owners have seen this movie already

Bryan Shull, owner of Trap Door Brewing, told KATU he expects the policy to advertise Vancouver to people looking for a place with no consequences.

“We’ve seen this playbook before in city after city, especially on the West Coast, where if there’s no repercussions for drug possession, for smoking illegal drugs in public, for shoplifting, we are going to become a destination for that kind of activity,” Shull said.

ADVERTISEMENT

He also warned that ignoring users tends to mean ignoring dealers.

“I think that if the police are going to be unresponsive to people who are doing the drugs, they’re gonna be unresponsive to people selling the drugs as well,” Shull said.

This is all by design

None of this is an accident. The activist public defenders who spent years lobbying the Washington Supreme Court for lower caseload caps knew exactly what would happen when the caps hit an underfunded system. You do not need to repeal a shoplifting statute if you can simply make it impossible to staff a shoplifting case. The law stays on the books, the crime stays legal in practice, and the people who engineered the outcome get to blame a budget.

Larry Jefferson, who ran the state Office of Public Defense, said out loud that rights were being violated because of how long it would take for some defendants to be truly represented. Fine. But the fix that got pushed was never more attorneys. It was fewer prosecutions. That was the point, and it has been the point since 2020, when abolitionists announced they wanted to stop charging low-level offenses and then went looking for a procedural back door once voters said no.

ADVERTISEMENT

Vancouver is just the city that admitted it in writing. Every other Washington city facing the same caps is doing quieter versions of the same triage right now. Washington Democrats stripped the funding that might have prevented it, then acted surprised. Cops get the liability, businesses get the theft, and the people who wrote the rules get to call it social justice.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

11 Comments

A
Andrew Cassidy 4 months ago

"In other news tonight, Crime has dropped by 70% in the Vancouver area. The Governor takes the credit due to his tough stance on crime"

J
Jason Pantz 4 months ago

And everything costs more than ever while quality of life for everyone paying for everything goes down.

E
Evan Lattimore 4 months ago

The shortsighted asinine ideology of progressives started primarily in Seattle, and like a plague is spreading all throughout Puget Sound and is now leaking into other areas of Western Washington. Clean up is going to be a mess, gonna need a lot of hazmat suits.