Another loss: Judge rejects Attorney General Nick Brown’s Medicaid work rules lawsuit
A federal judge refused to block Medicaid work requirements, handing WA AG Nick Brown another loss. Jim Walsh says the press releases only come for wins.
WA Attorney General Nick Brown's office is paying millions in private legal help to manage caseloads. (Screengrab: TVW)
(Screengrab: TVW)
A federal judge refused to halt the Trump administration’s new Medicaid work requirements, handing Washington Attorney General Nick Brown another courtroom loss in the anti-Trump litigation campaign that has defined his time in office.
U.S. District Judge Richard Stearns of Massachusetts denied the preliminary injunction sought by 25 Democratic-led states and the District of Columbia, leaving states on the hook for a Jan. 1 implementation deadline. The requirement comes from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, the tax and spending law President Donald Trump signed last summer, which tells states that expanded Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act to require adult enrollees to work, attend school or volunteer at least 80 hours a month to keep their coverage.
Brown’s office promoted the lawsuit when it was filed. The ruling against it received no such treatment.
Jim Walsh says Brown advertises the wins and buries the losses
State Rep. Jim Walsh, the Aberdeen Republican who chairs the Washington State Republican Party, flagged the decision on X and noted the silence coming out of the attorney general’s press shop.
“WA State AG Nick Brown loses ANOTHER Trump Derangement Syndrome lawsuit that he ‘co-leadered,'” Walsh posted. “No press release on this L. But I’m sure his taxpayer-funded PR staff will spin out some new TDS screed in a day or two. Well-written court ruling, though.”
Walsh has been one of the sharpest critics of how Brown’s office picks its fights, including his recent argument that a state Supreme Court justice should recuse herself from income tax litigation.
The judge said the states never showed real harm
Judge Stearns pointed out that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services has committed to reimbursing states for 90% of the cost of designing and running the new eligibility systems. He was not persuaded the remaining 10% amounted to the kind of injury that justifies emergency relief, and he reminded the plaintiffs that Congress wrote the Jan. 1 deadline, not the agency they sued.
“Because injunctive relief is the exception, not the rule, there is a certain point at which damages fail to justify the issuance of such an extraordinary measure,” Stearns wrote. “Plaintiffs have not shown that their damages rise above that minimal threshold here.”
The judge denied the request without prejudice, so the states can renew it later, and he indicated the underlying case raises real questions about how much authority Congress handed the Department of Health and Human Services. That is a long way from the sweeping win the coalition wanted before the notification deadline hits.
Nick Brown joined a suit he did not lead
The states sued CMS and HHS on June 29 over an interim final rule published earlier that month, arguing it narrowed the definition of who counts as medically frail and therefore exempt from the work rules. Brown’s own announcement of the case credited the attorneys general of California, Massachusetts and New Jersey as co-leads.
“Washington state is stronger when all people can get the care they need, and I’m committed to protecting Medicaid as a vital safety net,” Brown said when the coalition filed. His office said at the time that states must begin notifying Medicaid recipients about the changes by Aug. 31, a timeline Democrats called unworkable.
Washington’s Medicaid program, Apple Health, covers roughly 1.9 million residents, and the state has its own Medicaid billing problems to answer for. Brown has now filed or joined more than 60 legal actions against this administration, leading or co-leading about a third of them. The press releases keep coming for the filings. They tend to go quiet when a judge rules the other way.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
10 Comments
I would love to know how much TDS is costing taxpayers.
Yes, and that was implemented by Bill Clinton. That shows you how far left (socialism/communism) the Democrat party has become.
"....I’m committed to protecting Medicaid as a vital safety net,” Brown said. Nobody is taking it away, Nick. If you are able bodied enough to work, volunteer, or go to school, WHY WOULDN'T that be required? Why should it be free??