Rantz: KING 5 invented another ICE scandal in a parking lot; it was a man getting into a different car
KING 5's Sharon Yoo turned a routine ICE detainee transfer in an Edmonds church lot into an outrage story without naming the detainee or asking ICE anything.
The Northwest ICE Processing Center in Tacoma is holding 919 people under a contract that allows 1,635. (Photo by Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images)
(Photo by Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images)
A handcuffed man was moved from one vehicle to another in an Edmonds church parking lot last Thursday morning. That is the whole event. KING 5’s anti-ICE and resistance reporter Sharon Yoo turned it into a story about federal agents menacing preschoolers, and she did it without telling readers one fact about the man in the handcuffs.
The July 31 piece relies on three sources selected by Yoo because they’re either feigning outrage or align with Yoo’s anti-ICE sentiment: a neighbor who watched from his window, the far-left pastor of the church, and the marketing manager of the church food bank. Not one of them knows who was detained or why. Neither, apparently, does Yoo.
The question the story never bothers to ask
The detainee is not named. His immigration status goes unmentioned. Any criminal history goes unmentioned. The story carries no ICE response and gives no sign Yoo asked for one. What readers get instead is atmosphere.
“There were two fellas in gaiters, olive drab gaiters, and they had a fella in their custody, I guess, and putting handcuffs on him,” neighbor David Little told KING 5.
That is the evidentiary foundation. Compare it to KING 5’s own Edmonds College reporting in June, which included the agency’s explanation that Fredy Cruz-Calderon overstayed a 2018 visa. Readers got a name, a country, a reason. Here they get olive drab.
The omission is convenient, because identity tends to wreck the framing. When ICE Seattle names its arrests, Washington keeps getting a fentanyl dealer tied to a teenager’s death and a registered sex offender, or a man with prior arrests for rape and domestic violence. An anonymous detainee stays a parable. A named one becomes a problem.
Nobody elected the Methodist church
Pastor Jeremy Smith supplies the moral verdict that Yoo was desperate to use. “It is a place of safety, and so to have that be violated is an affront to our values,” he said.
Smith is not a neutral observer, and KING 5 never says so. Edmonds United Methodist hosted an ICE Out for Good vigil march in January, part of the demonstrations that swept the Seattle area this year. Smith closes the piece by describing his congregation praying every Sunday for a community he says is being afflicted by this administration.
That is an activist organization issuing an activist statement. Churches are free to do politics. But a pressure group condemning the thing it already organizes against is not news; it is a press release with a steeple.
More moral preening
Then comes food bank marketing manager Kellie Lewis, who reports fewer visitors lately.
“We don’t know for sure,” she said. “We think that could be for fear of seeking assistance.” KING 5 printed the guess anyway.
Smith offers the closing line for Yoo. “Somebody loves that person,” he said. Probably true. Somebody may also love whoever that person hurt, if anyone did. Yoo cannot say. She never found out, and the story works better that way.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
7 Comments
Any wonder nobody gives a rats behind about NBC anymore?
So close to making up a story from whole cloth it would take a tailor to spot the difference.
Illustrative!