‘It is a lie’: The school-funding con behind Washington’s income tax repeal disclosure
Washington's ballot disclosure claims repealing the income tax cuts school and healthcare funding. Ryan Frost and Brian Heywood explain why that's false.
A new DHM Research poll shows state-required ballot language sharply cuts support for Initiative 645, the income tax repeal. (Let's Go Washington/Facebook)
(Let's Go Washington/Facebook)
Washington’s official ballot disclosure for the income tax repeal now warns voters that Initiative 645 would slash funding for schools, colleges, and healthcare, a claim that falls apart when you read the tax it actually repeals.
The disclosure, signed July 23 by the Attorney General’s office, tells voters the repeal “would decrease funding for public K-12 education, higher education (including universities and community colleges), and human services (primarily healthcare).” There is one problem with that warning. The tax in question will not collect a single dollar for those programs anytime soon, and it earmarks almost none of the money for them at all.
Ryan Frost, director of budget and tax policy for the Washington Policy Center, called out the con in a post on X.
A tax that funds nothing until 2029
Frost’s point is simple enough that the state’s own lawyers should have caught it, instead of pushing it. The 9.9% income tax on household earnings above $1 million does not start producing revenue until 2029, which means it funds nothing today.
“Voters this November will be told that repealing the income tax would reduce funding for schools and healthcare. But how can repealing a tax that won’t generate a single dollar until 2029 reduce funding for programs that aren’t receiving any of that money today?” Frost wrote.
He then took apart the earmark myth. Aside from a sliver reserved for one child care account years from now, the money is not tied to schools or hospitals at all.
“The income tax earmarks nothing for K-12 education, higher education, or healthcare. Aside from a 5% allocation to the Fair Start for Kids Account beginning in 2029, the revenue goes into the unrestricted general fund, where future legislatures decide how it’s spent,” Frost noted.
“Washington’s Public Investment Impact Disclosure should describe what an initiative actually does, not imply that repealing a tax that won’t produce revenue until 2029 would reduce funding for today’s schools and healthcare,” he added.
Brian Heywood saw it coming
None of this surprised Let’s Go Washington founder Brian Heywood, who predicted the exact play weeks ago on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM. He warned that tax supporters were circulating push-poll language about K-12 cuts and that the state would try to slip it onto the ballot.
“They’ve only got like 18 words to put something in there. They like to throw in K through 12, but our initiative doesn’t do anything with K through 12 funding. So if they write K through 12, it is a lie, and we’ll challenge it. We’ll take them to court,” Heywood said.
He also flagged the timeline.
“The official wording doesn’t even get decided until July 23, and then we have a chance to appeal it,” he pointed out. The disclosure the Attorney General’s office produced carries that exact date, and it threw in the K-12 line anyway.
What voters are actually deciding
Initiative 645 repeals the 9.9% tax on income above $1 million, the levy Washington Democrats passed this spring and dressed up as a millionaires-only measure. Let’s Go Washington turned in more than 511,000 signatures to force the vote after Democrats blocked the faster referendum path with a necessity clause the state Supreme Court upheld. A yes vote in November kills the tax.
That is why the wording matters. The state gets a handful of words on the ballot itself, and it chose to spend them warning about cuts to funding that does not exist yet. The disclosure is not describing the initiative. It is campaigning against it.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
2 Comments
Frankly I think the most important point to make is that it takes a "yes" vote on initiative 645 to repeal this unconstitutional income tax.
Remember folks: vote YES on initiative 645 to repeal the state income tax!
Gosh I hope people don't fall for the lies or (propaganda) of the leaders of Wa state , when I comes time to vote . Please read this article or pass it on . Yes , to repeal.