ADVERTISEMENT

SEATTLE RED OPINION

Jim Walsh: Colleen Melody must recuse herself when income tax reaches WA’s high court

State Rep. Jim Walsh explains why WA Supreme Court Justice Colleen Melody should recuse herself from any case involving the income tax.

Attorney General Nick Brown, Justice Colleen Melody, and Governor Bob Ferguson...

Justice Colleen Melody at a formal event. Washington Republicans are calling for her recusal from the state income tax case, citing ties between her appointment and the AG's office that will argue the case. (Governor Bob Ferguson's Office/Facebook)

(Governor Bob Ferguson's Office/Facebook)

The Washington State Supreme Court should function as an independent branch of state government. The judges who serve on the Court are charged by the Constitution to act as a check on the actions of the executive and legislative branches and to assure balance in government and law. In recent years, the State Supreme Court has not lived up to those duties. Specifically, it has subordinated itself to the executive branch—effectively becoming a “rubber stamp” to governors’ whims. This must change.

How did this happen? Here in our Washington, the people elect judges (unlike at the federal level, where judges are appointed to lifetime positions by the president). Our State Constitution codifies election of judges in order to prevent them from being unduly influenced by politicians. It’s a good idea.

However, a common—and bad—practice has emerged, in which state judges retire during their final elected term and the governor appoints temporary replacements. The temporary replacements then run at the next election as incumbent judges.

Colleen Melody’s left-wing past

Colleen Melody, a temporary State Supreme Court Justice appointed recently by Gov. Bob Ferguson, is up for election this year. She faces two challengers in the August primary. Melody’s appointment and candidacy offer clear examples of how the state’s judicial branch has subordinated itself to the executive branch.

Melody’s resume reflects a left-wing lean. After law school, she clerked for a federal appeals court judge and then spent some years working for the U.S. Department of Justice in D.C. But the bulk of her career has been spent working for the State Attorney General’s Office here in Washington. She’s received recognition from various left-wing organizations, including the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR).

Ferguson appointed Melody to the State Supreme Court just a few months ago, in November 2025. State Solicitor General (roughly speaking, the second-in-command at the State AG’s office) Noah Purcell supported Melody’s appointment with what he called his “strongest possible recommendation.” In a letter to the governor, Purcell went on to write: “I am confident that she will make profound contributions to the law, the Court and the community.”

Purcell’s letter may have been a formality, as the governor knows Melody well. In 2015, Ferguson promoted Melody to run the State AG’s Civil Rights Division. She saw the Division’s growth to 35 lawyers, investigators and professional staff. And Ferguson has always measured “success” by how many lawyers and bureaucrats the state government hires.

Melody’s time in AGO raises concerns about her impartiality

In September 2025, while she was still working in the State AG’s office, Melody met with State Sen. Jamie Pedersen—the prime legislative sponsor of the Senate Bill 6346, the controversial state income tax scheme. The State AG’s office claims the meeting was to discuss other matters but it still raises the question of whether Melody will consider the controversial tax scheme fairly and without bias.

The entire network of connections among Melody, Pedersen, Purcell and Ferguson raises questions.

Those questions include why Purcell coordinated so closely with Pedersen on the drafting and structure of Senate Bill 6346. That close coordination was not necessarily illegal—but it was unusual. Purcell recommended (some say drafted) multiple sections of the bill, most notably the “necessity clause” that acted like an emergency clause in prohibiting a people’s referendum to overturn the scheme.

Purcell’s recommendation of Melody for appointment to the State Supreme Court, which took place at roughly the same time that he was coordinating with Pedersen on the state income tax scheme, was also unusual. Again, there’s nothing illegal about writing a recommendation for a political ally. But the timing of the recommendation draws a clear connection between Melody and Purcell’s work on the state income tax bill.

Melody should recuse herself from any income tax lawsuit

The Ferguson-Pedersen state income tax scheme is being challenged in state court right now, in a lawsuit filed by former State AG Rob McKenna and others. That lawsuit has not reached the State Supreme Court yet—but will likely reach it soon after this November’s general election.

Purcell could be the one defending the Ferguson-Pedersen tax in court before Melody, whom he recommended. Purcell also advised legislative Democrats on how to draft the tax scheme. At the very least, the optics will damage trust in the independence of the State Supreme Court.

The best and clearest way to remedy this damage is for Melody to announce right now—as she faces Washington voters for the first time—that she will recuse herself from any case involving the Ferguson-Pedersen state income tax scheme.

There’s no way to force a state judge to recuse himself or herself from ruling on a case. Each judge decides whether or not to do so. State law and the state’s Code of Judicial Conduct (CJC) set the standards for how Washington judges must act—including when they should recuse themselves from a case.

It’s a judges duty to remain apolitical

The CJC is made up of a series of rules and comments designed to help apply the rules. The rules relevant Melody’s situation appear the first sections of the CJC. Here are key excerpts:

“A judge shall perform the duties of judicial office, including administrative duties, without bias or prejudice. A judge shall not, in the performance of judicial duties, by words or conduct manifest bias or prejudice…. A judge who manifests bias or prejudice in a proceeding impairs the fairness of the proceeding and brings the judiciary into disrepute.”

“A judge shall not permit family, social, political, financial, or other interests relationships to influence the judge’s judicial conduct or judgment.”

First-time candidate Colleen Melody needs to make it clear to Washington voters that she will not permit her “political…relationships” to bring “the judiciary into disrepute.”

Melody needs to announce clearly and publicly now, ahead of this year’s election, that she will recuse herself from any lawsuit or court action involving the Ferguson-Pedersen state income tax scheme.

Jim Walsh is a Republican state representative from Aberdeen who serves as chairman of the Washington State Republican Party, where he has focused on rebuilding party infrastructure, candidate recruitment, and grassroots engagement.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

1 Comments

D
Doug Spittler 4 months ago

If fiscal conservatives actually take the time out of their busy day to mail in their ballots, with just a smidgen of luck, Ms. Melody won't have any influence on the "millionaire tax" bill, period.