ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: The secret Washington court rule protecting jurors who admit they hate cops

Washington's GR 37 makes distrust of police a presumptively invalid reason to remove a juror. Judge Dave Stevens says the rule created favored groups.

a jury box...

Jury selection in Washington courtrooms changed in 2018 when the state Supreme Court adopted General Rule 37, which makes a juror's expressed distrust of law enforcement a presumptively invalid reason for removal. Judge Dave Stevens, running for the court's Position 3 seat, says the rule builds racial double standards into trials. (Photo by Bill Pugliano/Getty Images)

(Photo by Bill Pugliano/Getty Images)

The Washington State Supreme Court rewrote jury selection so that a potential juror’s stated distrust of police is a presumptively invalid reason to remove them from a case. Most Washingtonians have never heard of the rule. A sitting judge running for the high court says that is exactly how the justices like it.

The rule is General Rule 37, adopted by the court in 2018 as the first of its kind in the nation. It applies to civil and criminal trials and lists seven presumptively invalid reasons for striking a juror, including expressing a distrust of law enforcement or a belief that officers engage in racial profiling, whenever an objective observer could view race or ethnicity as a factor in the strike.

Mason County Superior Court Judge Dave Stevens, who is running for the court’s open Position 3 seat, says the rule shows how the justices reshape the justice system through administrative rulemaking that never faces a vote.

What the rule did to jury selection

Stevens handles jury selection constantly as a trial judge, and he described how the process worked before the court stepped in.

“So if a juror were to say, you know, ‘I can’t be fair to law enforcement. I think law enforcement officers are corrupt and they lie. I believe that they engage in racial profiling, and so I can’t be fair to law enforcement.’ Well, up until General Rule 37 that would get you kicked off a jury,” Stevens explained on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM. “You can’t be fair to one of the parties, the witnesses, and so you were biased and you got kicked off the jury.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Under the rule, he argues, that same admitted bias no longer disqualifies certain jurors.

“If they’re a racial minority, they can’t be kicked off a jury because of their bias. I mean, that is insane,” Stevens said. “See, that was the whole idea behind affirmative action. We’re going to discriminate against some people because we got a favored group.”

Religious jurors get no such protection

Stevens pointed out that courts routinely ask jurors whether religious or philosophical views would prevent them from judging another person, and those jurors enjoy no similar shield.

“So you say you have very strong religious views, but you can follow the law and you can judge someone. You can get kicked off a jury because of your religious beliefs, but you can’t be kicked off a jury if you’re a racial minority or an ethnic minority,” he argued. “So they have favored groups.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The stakes are obvious in any trial involving police testimony. A juror who walks in believing officers lie or racially profile is weighing that testimony before a single witness takes the stand.

“Then you’re saying you can’t be fair,” Stevens added. “Who wants somebody on a jury that says I cannot be fair.”

Rulemaking most voters never see

GR 37 is not an outlier. The same court weighed a bail rule overhaul that would make it nearly impossible to issue warrants for defendants who skip hearings, another policy change accomplished without a single vote in the legislature. As Stevens noted, the public hears about the big cases but rarely about the administrative rules quietly reshaping the criminal courts.

Voters have a rare chance to weigh in. Five of the court’s nine seats are on the ballot this year, and a majority of the current justices first reached the bench through appointment rather than election. Primary ballots are already in mailboxes or have been delivered ahead of the August 4 primary, where the top two candidates in each race advance to November.

ADVERTISEMENT

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

3 Comments

P
Pablo Abo 4 months ago

Vote every incumbent justice OUT!

S
Shawn m 4 months ago

Any judgment against any officer that was rendered by any jury including biased jurors (or judges) should immediately be vacated, with restitution when appropriate. Fer Pete's sake! Where are Washington state's checks and balances! I know, no need to answer: the branches of WA government comprise a virtually closed and unified circuit.

B
Big Dog 4 months ago

Where’s my comment? Censored by the trolls at KIRO!