ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Lawsuit says Highline told Christian student she could share opinions, not religious beliefs

A Christian student was told she had 'no choice' but to stay in a Highline assembly conflicting with her faith. Her father is now suing in federal court.

u.s. federal courthouse...

A federal lawsuit accuses Highline Public Schools of punishing a Christian student's religious expression while permitting secular and political speech. (Jason Rantz)

(Jason Rantz)

A Christian sixth grader at Sylvester Middle School was told she had “no choice” but to sit through a mandatory assembly celebrating messages that conflicted with her faith. Now her father is suing Highline Public Schools in federal court, and the complaint accuses the district of punishing one girl’s Christian expression for years while giving secular and political speech a green light.

The suit was filed July 8 in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington by the American Center for Law and Justice.

In February, Vice Principal Lori McEwen pulled the student out of math class and told her she could not hand out Christian gospel tracts, something she had done quietly between classes while always asking permission first, according to the lawsuit. Months later, on May 29, the entire student body was marched into an “Inclusion Assembly” with no advance notice to parents. The complaint says the second half was devoted to LGBTQ content, including a presentation covering seventy-two gender identities and slides instructing students on how to be an “ally.”

What the vice principal allegedly said

When the girl asked why she could not share her faith while classmates spoke freely, the lawsuit alleges McEwen “drew an explicit and constitutionally impermissible distinction: she told her that students may share opinions, but they may not share religious beliefs.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The girl pressed the point, noting classmates had recently been allowed to leave campus during school hours for an anti-ICE protest, according to the lawsuit.

“McEwen responded that these protests constituted permissible student opinion and expression, while simultaneously maintaining that her distribution of religious literature is not permitted,” according to the filing.

The ‘no choice’ moment

The complaint describes a girl who began crying during the assembly, told a teacher she was a Christian, and asked to be excused. Rather than let her leave, staff allegedly concealed her religious objection from organizers by claiming she needed the restroom, then ordered her back inside.

“Ms. Edwards then told her directly: ‘You have no choice because me and Ms. Holmes told the people in charge that you had to use the bathroom,'” the lawsuit alleges.

ADVERTISEMENT

The complaint says she re-entered under compulsion and spent the rest of the program in tears, eyes averted from the screen. Her parents were never told about the assembly or her distress, according to the filing. The case echoes other recent fights over Washington schools keeping identity decisions from families.

A promise the district broke

This is not the family’s first clash with Highline.

The complaint traces the dispute to 2022, when the same girl, then a second grader at North Hill Elementary, had her backpack searched for religious materials and was sent to the principal’s office more than ten times for talking about her faith at recess. The district settled in writing, agreeing she could distribute materials “going forward, including religious materials.” The lawsuit says that promise did not last.

Washington schools and parental authority have collided often lately, from Olympia’s refusal to let families opt out of Pride curriculum to fights over gender ideology and biological sex in state classrooms.

ADVERTISEMENT

The suit raises free speech, free exercise, and parental rights claims and asks the court to bar the district from compelling attendance at religiously objectionable programming without notice and an opt-out. Highline has denied wrongdoing, once defending its earlier handling by saying students reported being scared by the girl’s talk of Satan and Hell, and it maintains assemblies are not mandatory, a claim the complaint disputes.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

4 Comments

W
William Keller 4 months ago

You are so right. This girl's riches lie in the Kingdom of Heaven.

B
Bill Julian 4 months ago

72 Genders?

S
Steven Justus 4 months ago

The demons have taken over our State and certainly our schools. How sad.
I can’t believe they are brainwashing our kids with this stuff.