Walrus and the Carpenter workers strike progressive Renee Erickson, as Reddit picks apart the why
Servers struck Renee Erickson's Walrus and the Carpenter over a 22% service fee. The Seattle Times skipped the why, so Reddit filled it in.
United Creatures of the Sea members picketed Renee Erickson's Walrus and the Carpenter on Thursday, while the restaurant stayed open with replacement staff. (Jason Rantz)
(Jason Rantz)
A union of hourly workers at The Walrus and the Carpenter, Renee Erickson’s flagship Ballard oyster bar, walked off the job Thursday and onto a picket line. The restaurant simply brought in replacement staff and stayed open. The Seattle Times reported the walkout but told readers almost nothing about why it happened.
The union calls itself United Creatures of the Sea, and it represents the hourly staff at the restaurant run by Erickson’s Sea Creatures group. Co-owner Chad Dale confirmed the oyster bar would operate right through the strike.
“They’re striking today, but we’re planning to open as normal,” Dale said.
The union says it has been ready to sign a contract for a while.
“Management has copies of proposals signaling agreement to all mandatory subjects of bargaining and we’re eagerly awaiting a response, but the workers could not tolerate one more day of stalling and bad-faith bargaining,” said Ford Nickel, the union’s secretary-treasurer.
None of that tells you what the fight is actually over. For that, you had to skip past the Times and read the r/SeattleWA thread.
What the Seattle Times left out
The walkout did not come out of nowhere. About two weeks earlier, The Stranger reported that union members held a strike authorization vote minutes before the doors opened, with 18 of 20 voting to greenlight a work stoppage and two not voting.
The union’s complaints are more than pay. In its statement to the Times, United Creatures of the Sea pointed to firings and to the shifting of union work and hours over to management as moves meant to weaken its bargaining position.
Money still plays a large role in the move. The restaurant’s own job postings confirm a $25 hourly base in what Sea Creatures calls a service charge and tip-pooled house, and the dispute centers on how that service charge gets divided. On Reddit, the complaint came down to the math.
“The restaurant charges a 22% service fee and discourages tipping. The service fee is mostly retained by the house so servers are not making much above minimum wage. Whether you agree with their pay or not, for anyone to have their wages slashed in half over night is crazy. Also they voted a union into action over a year ago and the company refuses to agree to any sort of contract,” wrote user Murky_Opening6174. The 22% figure is the commenter’s own, and the company has not confirmed the split.
Even Seattle’s Reddit isn’t buying it
Here is where it gets uncomfortable for the striking workers. r/SeattleWA is not a conservative space, yet much of the thread sided against the walkout. “Good, front of house is so entitled an overpaid compared to everyone else in restaurants,” wrote QuantityFine3286.
Another comment went further. “This is just about well-paid servers wanting to keep being paid directly by patrons as well as their employer. Everyone except for the servers has had it up to here with these demands after we raised the minimum wage to about the highest in the world. This is a pure cash grab with no ‘injustice’ to get upset about,” argued PetuniaFlowers.
It’s ironic for Erickson, a progressive favorite who adopted Seattle’s $15 minimum wage years early and embraced the service-charge model now at the center of the strike. The city killed the tip credit in 2025 and watched restaurants close while diners on that same Reddit vowed to stop tipping.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
5 Comments
I'm talking about Reddit in general.
"reddit/SeattleWA is not a conservative space" - Absolutely not true. There's two subReddits for the city of Seattle. Seattle and SeattleWA. SeattleWA is the conservative, MAGA, Republican one. Seattle is the liberal, socialist, Democratic one.
I mean, hilarious you say that. But there's two Seattle Reddits. Seattle and SeattleWA. SeattleWA is the conservative, MAGA, Republican one.