ADVERTISEMENT

SEATTLE RED OPINION

Jim Walsh: Washington’s ballot laws are so loose that fraud can’t even be defined

Opinion: Washington's mail-ballot laws are so porous that fraud is nearly impossible to prove. A looming Supreme Court ruling could change that.

jim walsh...

Five of the nine seats on the Washington Supreme Court are on the November 3 ballot as the state's new income tax heads toward a constitutional challenge. (Jim Walsh)

(Jim Walsh)

Several weeks ago, California’s state primary election created controversies that got national attention, and have resonated here in Washington.

Like Washington, our neighbors to the south have a “jungle” primary, in which the top two vote-getters proceed to the general election regardless of what political party affiliation they claim. On primary election night, conservative candidates for California governor and Los Angeles mayor looked well-positioned to advance to their respective general elections this November. But post-Election Day ballot dumps trended heavily in favor of far-left candidates.

In the days and weeks that followed the primary, the conservatives fell behind and will not advance to the general election.

Why fraud is nearly impossible to prove here

People up and down the West Coast—and, really, all around the United States—have voiced skepticism about the California primary results. The severity of the shift in post-Election Day results seem statistically…unlikely. But the real controversy in California and here in Washington is that the respective state election laws are so loose, so poorly-drafted and rarely-enforced that fraud or abuse are virtually impossible to prove. So many bad and unsecure practices are entirely legal that wrongdoing is difficult even to define.

In California, mail-in ballots can be received up to seven days after Election Day and still be counted. Here in Washington, the law is worse: Mail-in ballots can be received up to 21 days after Election Day and be counted.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here in Washington, ballots are not monitored closely when they’re being mailed to voters or when they’re mailed back to county election offices. The state’s election laws include a “broken chain of custody,” which means no person or organization is clearly responsible for the ballots at each stage of delivery.

Hundreds of ballots found by a Renton dumpster

This lack of security came to fine point recently, when a Good Samaritan brought a box containing several hundred undelivered ballots to the State Republican Party headquarters. The WAGOP has been cooperating with United States Postal Inspectors and local police detectives investigating how these ballots ended up in box next to a dumpster in Renton. Although the story is shocking, the law enforcements agents have pointed out in frustration that Washington’s election laws are so porous it’s not clear whether any crime occurred in the failure to deliver the ballots.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here in Washington, we’ve grown accustomed to controversial election results.

Washington’s long record of contested results

Most notorious was the 2004 gubernatorial election, in which Dino Rossi was winning narrowly on Election Night, through counts and recounts—until hundreds of “missing ballots” were discovered weeks after the election and his opponent edged ahead.

Later, in 2019, Seattle City Council member Kshama Sawant was losing her bid for re-election on Election Night but enjoyed a statistically-unlikely post-Election Day surge that allowed her to squeak back into office.

Most recently, in 2024, the controversial State Senate election in the 18th Legislative District (Clark County) saw a shady outcome, based on out-of-district voters illegally supporting a bumbling far-left candidate.

How do we fix all of this poorly-written law and growing controversy?

How a Supreme Court case could fix it

There are various bills in Olympia and statewide initiatives that have been filed that would tighten up the porous election law. But the most immediate reform might come from a lawsuit that started in Mississippi and is now waiting for a ruling from the United States Supreme Court.

ADVERTISEMENT

That case is called Watson v. Republican National Committee, et al. and involves Mississippi’s policy of allowing mail-in ballots to be received up to 5 days after Election Day and still be counted. To simplify slightly, the multiple plaintiffs in the case argue that a federal law enacted in 1845, which defines “Election Day” as “the first Tuesday after the first Monday in November,” requires ballots to be received—not merely to be postmarked—by that date.

The U.S. Supreme Court has already heard oral arguments in the case and is scheduled to issue its opinion any day now. If, as expected, the Court rules that ballots must be received by election officials (in Washington, this means county election offices) by Election Day, things will change significantly—and for the better. The ballots received or “discovered” post-Election Day that decided the controversial 2004 Washington governor race, 2019 Seattle city council race or this year’s unlikely California primary results won’t be counted legally.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Seattle Times rushes to defend the status quo

Left-wing political activists here in Washington and their apologists in the legacy media are scared that this simple reform will make state elections more transparent and trustworthy. Knowing that a ruling in Watson is imminent, the Seattle Times recently rushed to publish a scurrilous opinion column that attacked election integrity advocates as “news.” The opinion column called questions raised by the recent California primary results “False voter fraud claims” and slandered any resulting discussion of election reform as “red meat for MAGA base.”

Of course, none of this is true.

Still, the weakest part of the weak effort was that, unable to find any reasonable person to attack common-sense reforms to Washington’s election processes and ballot security, the Seattle Times was reduced to relying heavily on quotes from…Chris Vance.

ADVERTISEMENT

Vance is a perennial losing candidate from the Pugetopolis suburbs, who recently tried to raise money for the stated purpose of attacking the WAGOP during his failed attempt to start a “third party.” Lately, he has told people that he plans to attack the Republican Party “from the inside.” This perennial loser, who bragged about voting for Kamala Harris for President in 2024, is not a serious person. The Seattle Times insults its dwindling base of readers by quoting him.

Then again, the Seattle Times doesn’t seem to care much about its readers. It’s more interested in currying favor with the far Left by peddling hysterical narratives intended to delegitimize any reform—including the expected U.S. Supreme Court ruling in the Watson case.

But truth doesn’t care about a struggling newspaper’s hysterics. Truth is on the side of common-sense election reform, which Washington needs. Badly.

ADVERTISEMENT

Jim Walsh is a Republican state representative from Aberdeen who serves as chairman of the Washington State Republican Party, where he has focused on rebuilding party infrastructure, candidate recruitment, and grassroots engagement.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

6 Comments

K
k keenan 5 months ago

Who else could take a great state like WA was, very successful business wise, people wanted to move here, low cost, low taxes and no incomce tax and high Government revenue and take ALL of those pluses and turn them ALL into losses? Democrats!! People of WA state, get your life priorities straight, stop with the "ideologies"!, vote for positive changes!!!

P
Paul H 5 months ago

"Ceaser's wife must not only be above suspicion, she must appear to be above suspicion."

Many immigrant voters (naturalized, so voting legally) repeatedly express a desire to vote in person. Many, due to their past experiences in totaliarian regimes. Same with African American communites. There is a tradition of going to the polls on election day. Even from the days when polling places were frequented by people wearing white sheets. They never begged for the safety of mail-in ballots.

M
Mark Mad 5 months ago

2004 was a shame. We had a real opportunity to change direction. Things went down the toilet real fast after that.