Bellevue city councilmember says Seattle’s payroll tax sent the jobs east and he’s okay with that
Bellevue's Jared Nieuwenhuis tells Jason Rantz that Seattle's JumpStart payroll tax pushed jobs east while Mayor Wilson still calls the tax a success.You said: now write an article focused on the income tax concerns
Bellevue's Jared Nieuwenhuis tells Jason Rantz that Seattle's JumpStart payroll tax pushed jobs east while Mayor Wilson still calls the tax a success. (City of Bellevue/Facebook)
(City of Bellevue/Facebook)
Bellevue City Council member Jared Nieuwenhuis says Seattle handed his city a windfall through its own tax policy, and he expects that pattern to keep repeating as long as the JumpStart payroll tax stays on the books.
His reaction followed a new Downtown Seattle Association report that blames JumpStart for draining jobs and office value out of Seattle’s core. The analysis found downtown Seattle has shed roughly 30,000 jobs since 2020 while the taxable value of its office buildings fell 48%. Across Lake Washington, Bellevue, which has no comparable employer tax, added jobs, watched commercial values climb 7%, and absorbed about 15,000 Amazon employees as the company built out a second regional hub.
Asked to read the two cities side by side, Nieuwenhuis declined to treat the numbers as a victory lap and instead pointed to the policy choices behind them.
Bellevue says it never chased Seattle’s playbook
“I don’t really view this report as necessarily tearing Seattle down, but I do see it as really understanding how different policy choices really shape economic outcomes. I firmly believe that the health of the entire region matters, and Seattle success and Bellevue success are interconnected in a number of different ways. I really just hope that not only electeds but residents understand that it’s important to keep track of these important decisions and that they have real, real-world consequences, positive or negative, and we’re seeing that now,” Nieuwenhuis said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.
But he did reject the idea that Bellevue built its low-tax posture as a direct counter to Seattle.
“Bellevue would have kept this approach regardless of Seattle’s decision. We have followed the playbook that has really kept us and our economy very healthy, so keeping taxes stable and predictable when we can, reducing taxes, having a very pro-business council, welcoming businesses into our city, and doing what we can to ensure that they’re successful,” he added.
Employers fed up with Seattle
Pressed on whether the companies choosing Bellevue are genuinely picking the city or simply running from Seattle, Nieuwenhuis said it works both ways. The distinction matters because about 70% of JumpStart’s revenue comes from just 10 large employers, most of them tech firms with the means to relocate.
“It could possibly be a mix of that. I think they see a better environment overall for their business to grow, and I’ve talked to employers that have had it with the environment and are concerned about what’s next. What’s the next thing I’m going to have to deal with as I continue to grow my business? So I definitely have heard that from employers, and it just goes into their mix of things that they’re concerned about, and they want to put their company in the best position to grow and be successful, and if that place is Bellevue, we’re going to welcome them with open arms,” he told Rantz.
Wilson calls it a success. Bellevue isn’t buying it.
Mayor Katie Wilson, who helped design JumpStart before her election, has defended the tax as a success that stabilized the city budget. Nieuwenhuis was unconvinced, especially with Seattle’s office vacancy rate now the worst in the nation.
“I guess I would first have to ask, how do you define success in this context. I think the revenue that this tax brought in did help in terms of their overall balancing of their budgets short term, but obviously I think the data speaks to itself that long term this is having detrimental impacts on their economy going forward. So it’s hard for me to see this being construed in any way as a success at this point,” he argued.
For Bellevue, the verdict is already settled. The jobs crossed the lake, the towers across the water keep climbing in value, and the only city treating JumpStart as a win is the one losing the jobs.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
2 Comments
The people who voted for her are just not smart. This was foreseeable, so this was preventable.
The first step in problem solving is recognizing and defining the problem. The fact that Seattle politicians don't recognize there is a problem with businesses leaving Seattle and rich people leaving Washington means they won't progress down the path to remedying either issue. The public suffers because the issues aren't addressed. It begs the question, why don't politicians recognize these as problems? Do they want businesses to move jobs? Do they want job and business creators to leave? Or is it they can't admit they did something wrong? People can change their minds but if politicians choose not to, voters obviously should. Seattle voters' track record is poor at best. They haven't chosen to do what's right and they continue to reap the results of their poor decisions. Unfortunately, what happens in Seattle doesn't just stay there. If it did, we could just wait for the self-correction. But it doesn't. Bad policies from Seattle seem to trickle to the county and then the state. I hope Seattle gets their act together sooner rather than later. The longer it goes on, the worse the damage is. Remember the first rule of holes, when you find yourself in a hole, stop digging.