Washington raises voter challenge bar to murder-trial standard
A new Washington law sets the highest legal bar in America for challenging ineligible voter registrations, and it just took effect.
A new Washington law that took effect June 11 sets the highest legal bar in America for challenging a voter's registration. (TVW)
(TVW)
A new Washington law makes it dramatically harder to challenge a voter registration that a citizen believes is fraudulent, and it took effect this week.
Engrossed Substitute House Bill 1916, sponsored by Democratic Representatives Beth Doglio and Jessica Parshley, was signed by Gov. Bob Ferguson in March and became law on June 11. Backers say it stops frivolous challenges. In practice, it raises the burden on anyone trying to flag an ineligible voter to the highest standard that exists anywhere in American law.
The law rewrites how an ordinary citizen can question a registration. Most challenges come from a claim that the voter no longer lives at the address on file, and the new rules pile on requirements for proving it while stripping away the investigative tools challengers used to rely on. Conservatives have spent the past year pushing to clean ineligible names off the rolls. Washington Democrats just made it more difficult.
What the law changes
The biggest change is the evidence standard.
Under the old rules, a challenger had to prove a registration was improper by clear and convincing evidence. ESHB 1916 replaces it with something far more onerous. As the bill reads, “The challenger has the burden to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the challenged voter’s registration is improper,” according to ESHB 1916.
Beyond a reasonable doubt is the standard a prosecutor must meet to convict someone of murder. Washington Democrats now demand it from a private citizen who suspects a name on the rolls does not belong there. If that burden is not met, the challenge dies automatically.
“If the challenger fails to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the registration is improper, the challenge must be dismissed and any pending challenged ballot must be accepted as valid,” according to ESHB 1916. County auditors lost their discretion in the other direction too, since the law now requires them to toss any challenge that is not in proper form or that fails to meet the legal grounds, where before they were merely permitted to.
Fewer tools, more paperwork
The law also shrinks the evidence a challenger is allowed to gather.
Challenges based on a wrong address can no longer rest on searches of county property records, telephone directories, the statewide voter database, or another state’s registration database. Those were the practical ways a citizen could verify someone had moved or registered elsewhere. Now the certified letter sent to the voter has to use a form created by the secretary of state that spells out the reason for the challenge, and a separate form and affidavit must be filed for each voter, each one signed by hand in ink. An affidavit signed electronically gets rejected outright.
Only a registered voter from the same county, or the county prosecutor, can file a challenge at all. A hearing happens only when the auditor cannot independently confirm eligibility and finds probable cause that the voter is not qualified. Anything short of that gets dismissed without a hearing.
Penalties aimed at challengers
Knowingly submitting false information as part of a challenge is now false swearing, with a fine of up to $10,000. Knowingly filing a challenge without reasonable cause is a misdemeanor, and the law counts each baseless challenge as a separate offense.
Republicans have argued the state should verify citizenship before someone is registered. This law takes the state in the opposite direction, telling citizens that once a name is on the rolls, prying it off requires near-criminal proof and carries real legal risk. The state is not strengthening confidence in its elections. It is shielding the rolls from anyone who looks too closely.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
5 Comments
Do these so called "law makers" have to hit us over the head, too?
For us to wake up, while they prove on the daily that they could care less about, not only their constituents, who pay their salaries, but any semblance of
Truth: A dedication to honesty, transparency, and a commitment to fighting falsehoods and deceit.
Justice: The pursuit of fairness, the rule of law, and defending the vulnerable and oppressed against those who abuse their power.
The American Way: Rather than representing a specific nation's dominance, the phrase symbolizes the philosophical bedrock of American democratic values (such as "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness"). It is generally interpreted as an aspirational standard of kindness, empathy, and responsible citizenship.
They have gone SO far out of their lane - out of reality - drug us down so low, beyond recognition of the absolutely beautiful state we all call home! Pricing us out of our family homes, preventing/postponing retirement, even the worry of dying here, and getting screwed by their outrageous taxes - beyond the grave!!!
Leaving us with "gtfo" if we don't like it!
WHO do they think they are? WHY aren't they being held accountable? How do they have free reign to destroy everything good!?!? Why do we allow them to hold us hostage?!
It's like a LONG nightmare, that is so far fetched it coudn't possibly be true.... but we keep waking up and it's still here....and growing way beyond the monster in the closet!
This sooo sad. Our nation is being run by TREASONIST people, with no regard for all our forefathers' sacrifices. Unless American voters -the legal ones- get their priorities straight we have lost our freedom.
Ooh, T G, "truth," "justice," from politicians? Surely, you jest!
"The government consists of a gang of men exactly like you and me. They have, taking one with another, no special talent for the business of government; they have only a talent for getting and holding office. Their principal device to that end is to search out groups who pant and pine for something they can't get and to promise to give it to them. Nine times out of ten that promise is worth nothing. The tenth time is made good by looting A to satisfy B. In other words, government is a broker in pillage, and every election is sort of an advance auction sale of stolen goods." ~ H. L. Mencken