ADVERTISEMENT

POLITICS

‘This is a national security issue’: Seattle council unanimously bans data centers after federal warning the moratorium helps China

Seattle's council unanimously banned new data centers despite a federal energy official's warning that the moratorium hands China an edge in the AI race.

A commenter decries capitalism while pushing for a moratorium on AI data centers in Seattle...

The Seattle City Council voted unanimously Tuesday to impose an emergency moratorium on large data centers, brushing aside a federal energy official's warning that blocking the facilities raises national security and data sovereignty concerns. (Seattle Channel)

(Seattle Channel)

The Seattle City Council voted unanimously Tuesday to shut the door on large data centers, a decision a top Department of Energy official warned would do far more damage than chasing away jobs and tax revenue; it weakens America’s position in a technology race against China.

The council approved two measures. Council Bill 121214, sponsored by Councilmember Eddie Lin and Council President Joy Hollingsworth, imposes a temporary moratorium on new data center development while the city studies effects on the electrical grid, water use, utility rates, land use, employment, and public health. The ban covers facilities drawing more than 20 megavolt-amperes, roughly the demand of 16,000 homes, and can be extended another six months. Because the council designated it an emergency ordinance, it took effect immediately. A companion resolution from Councilmember Debora Juarez directs city departments to deliver reports and proposed legislation by January 2027.

The vote followed April reports that four companies had approached Seattle City Light about building five facilities with a combined demand of 369 megawatts, roughly a third of the city’s daily power load. The Trump administration’s energy leadership saw the moratorium push coming and told Seattle exactly what it would be giving up.

During the public comment period, scores of far-left activists with Socialist Alternative and other fringe groups declared data centers harm to environment and enrich billionaires, while upholding a capitalist economic system, which the activists say they oppose.

The national security warning Seattle ignored

Alex Fitzsimmons, the acting Undersecretary of Energy and Director of the Office of Cybersecurity, Energy Security, and Emergency Response, criticized the proposal in an interview on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM ahead of the vote.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Data centers house all of our private information that we use on a daily basis, and we want these facilities to be built in the United States and not in China and not in nations that don’t respect privacy rights,” Fitzsimmons said. “So this is a national security issue, it’s a privacy issue, and we want to build this technology. We want to build these data centers in the United States, so that we can continue to exercise sovereignty over our technology and our data. It’s a fundamental issue.”

Asked whether Seattle’s resistance would exist at all if a Democratic White House were leading the AI buildout, he pointed to the politics driving the opposition.

“I’m sure that politics plays a role in this, and some people are trying to exploit this issue for what they perceive to be short-term political gain,” Fitzsimmons argued. “I think that’s very misguided, because, as President Trump has made clear, we are in a race against China to win in AI and be competitive in this enormous industry of the future that’s going to fundamentally transform and improve our daily lives, in addition to bringing all sorts of national security benefits for the United States. So we need to be doing more of this now.”

ADVERTISEMENT

What the council heard instead

None of that came up Tuesday. The council acted after two hours of near-unanimous public testimony in favor of the pause, making Seattle the largest city in the country to freeze the facilities.

“We want a permanent, outright ban on AI data centers right now. These facilities poison communities. They drive up electricity costs, and all for what?” one resident told the council during public comment, per KOMO News.

Councilmember Alexis Mercedes Rinck backed the activists before the vote: “If we do not legislate or regulate this right, the people will bear the brunt.”

Washington Democrats already passed legislation this year targeting data centers with new tariffs and mandates, over Republican warnings that the investment would simply go to friendlier states. Seattle’s vote settles the question locally. The data has to live somewhere, and the council just guaranteed it won’t live here.

ADVERTISEMENT

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

3 Comments

F
Frank Sterle 5 months ago

The Chinese Communist Party government may be using our own Western corporate and oligarchic greed, as well as our domestically-destabilizing democratic freedoms, against us. The CCP knows that American and Canadian governance is heavily steered and may therefore be disadvantaged by domestic corporate/oligarchic interests, sometimes through the latter's economic intimidation.

We exist in a system that enables such big-money lobbyists to pull our (typically politically vulnerable) governments by the nose. For example, high-level elected officials can become crippled by implicit or explicit corporate/oligarchic threats to transfer and/or eliminate jobs and capital investment, thus economic stability, if lobbyist ‘requests’ are not met.

The lobbyists also write bills for our governing representatives to vote for and have implemented, supposedly to save the elected officials their own time writing them up. The practice may have become so systematic that those who are aware of it, including mainstream news-media political writers, don’t find reason to publicly discuss or write about it.

Meanwhile, the biggest of businesses (at least here in Canada) get unaccountably even bigger, defying the very spirit of government rules established to ensure healthy competition by limiting mass consolidation. Nations like China, on the other hand, are governed while essentially maintaining control over its own big-money and business sector thus market, which likely gives the government an overall foreign trade/relations edge over that of America and Canada.

F
Frank Sterle 5 months ago

Perhaps there’s something to be said for Beijing’s seemingly insatiable need for control, both in China and elected governance elsewhere.

For example, while watching the little amount of news feed allowed to leave China at the outset of the pandemic in late 2019, I was somewhat amused by TV images of some citizens being literally dragged — a few even invertedly by their legs — back into their residences to help contain viral transmission.

As the months passed and Covid-19 became a global pandemic, I couldn’t help but notice how China's strict handling of its own outbreak, while allowing little rights and freedoms to its people (and maybe even internal/external big business), likely enabled a relatively short duration of its initial crisis.

Still, many Chinese citizens have tasted and enjoyed samples of freedom's sweetness, either through trans-Pacific travel or Western images perhaps missed by China's internet censors. Potentially problematic for China's authoritarian government, those samples cannot be un-experienced.

My larger point: With greater democratic freedoms can come weaker national security, and vice versa. While I wouldn't exchange my (Western) freedom for such national security, it is still foolish to pretend a national-security sacrifice isn't being made in exchange.

C
Clockwork Wyrm 5 months ago

If the Fed wants datacenters so bad, let them build them on Federal property, like the Whitehouse lawn.
I'm a datacenter NIMBY, stick those energy guzzling, noisy monstrosities out in the boonies, far away from residential areas.