ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: KING 5 files another illegal immigration propaganda piece and calls it reporting

KING 5's Sharon Yoo covers Yakima ICE arrests with zero ICE comment, no criminal records, and unvetted advocacy data. This isn't journalism. It's open-borders PR.

an ICE badge around the neck of an agent...

KING 5's immigration reporter Sharon Yoo filed her latest Yakima immigration piece without a single comment from ICE, any criminal background details, or independent verification of the advocacy group's arrest numbers. (Photo by Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images)

(Photo by Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images)

KING 5 activist-journalist Sharon Yoo filed another illegal immigration report, this time from the Yakima Valley, and the template is so familiar by now I could recite it in my sleep. An advocacy organization provides the alarm. An unverified number circulates without any scrutiny. ICE gets no comment, nobody asks who was arrested or why, and KING 5 calls it hard hitting journalism. It’s embarrassing.

The piece, published Wednesday, leads with Danielle Surkatty of the Yakima Immigrant Response Network sorting through paperwork and counting files. Surkatty is the emotional lede and the sourcing, simultaneously. One advocacy organization representative flipping through documents she refuses to share with the audience, telling viewers that nearly 20 people were arrested in a single week. No names. No criminal histories. No immigration enforcement records. No context whatsoever about who these individuals were or what brought federal agents to their door in the first place. To Yoo, and the activists she amplifies, it does not matter if it’s a child molester or a janitor who is arrested. That any illegal immigrant is arrested is the outrage.

Surkatty also tells Yoo that arrests at the Yakima County Courthouse are happening; that people attending hearings are being taken into custody when they walk out. Yoo frames this as something sinister. Courthouses are lawful enforcement environments, and ICE has long targeted individuals with active removal orders in locations where they are expected to appear. That is not a new tactic and it is not a scandal. It is enforcement of existing law against people already identified by the immigration system.

Yoo’s story has no room for context, because context would undermine the narrative.

The data point KING 5 won’t interrogate

The piece cites a 190% increase in ICE activity in Eastern Washington compared to the same period last year, sourced from something called the Deportation Data Project. Yoo presents this figure as though it settles the argument. She does not explain what the Deportation Data Project is, who funds it, what methodology produced the number, or whether its data aligns with official ICE statistics. Readers are simply supposed to trust it and feel alarmed, because the number is large and the source sounds official enough to slip past without examination.

ADVERTISEMENT

This is a pattern The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM has covered repeatedly. Yoo’s previous coverage of SB 5855 treated a legally dubious Washington mask ban as a genuine check on federal authority, burying the fact that the law’s own supporters admitted it almost certainly could not withstand federal preemption. Before that, she turned a criminal illegal immigrant with a laundry list of violent offenses into a sympathetic victim, relying entirely on an open-borders advocacy group’s unverified medical claims without independent vetting.

Enforcement is always the villain. The enforcement target is always a victim. Advocacy groups are always credible. The formula never changes.

What you will not find in Yoo’s Yakima story is any response from ICE. No quote, no statement, nothing on background. For a piece built around the premise that ICE activity is surging in alarming ways, the absence of ICE’s own account of what is happening is a deliberate editorial choice. ICE’s own arrest disclosures, which this outlet has covered in detail, tend to include records like felony assault convictions, multiple prior deportations, drug trafficking charges, and sexual offenses against minors. Those details make the “community in fear” framing a lot harder to sell to a general audience, which is presumably why Yoo skips them entirely.

ADVERTISEMENT

Who are the people being arrested?

It is the question KING 5 rarely asks or answers, certainly not in this story and not in most of Yoo’s immigration coverage. The audience receives no information about the immigration histories of those taken into custody, whether removal orders were outstanding, whether any criminal records exist, or whether the individuals had been previously deported. KING 5 hands viewers an advocacy organization’s headcount and instructs them to be outraged.

This is not a disagreement about immigration policy. Reasonable people hold different views on enforcement levels and priorities. But a news organization covering enforcement with zero information about who is being enforced against, zero response from the agency conducting the enforcement, and zero independent verification of any claimed facts is not covering immigration. It is running open-borders advocacy content with a KING 5 logo.

ADVERTISEMENT

Same script, different package

Yoo’s beat has become a reliable megaphone for illegal immigrant advocacy while consistently burying or omitting the criminal records that would complicate the story. The beat was always constructed to produce a predetermined conclusion. Yakima is just the latest backdrop.

The people of the Yakima Valley deserve actual journalism about what is happening in their communities; they deserve to know who is being arrested and why, ICE’s account alongside advocates’ accounts, and data that comes with sourcing they can actually evaluate. KING 5 is not going to give them any of that. Not with Sharon Yoo on the beat.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

1 Comments

E
Evan Lattimore 6 months ago
That any illegal immigrant is arrested is the outrage.

Outrage for enforcing the law. Only in Seattle. And never mind that Obama deported people en masse, he's The Messiah, so...