ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Banning rent software just means leasing agents will gouge you themselves

Bellingham wants to ban algorithmic rent software, but the real problem isn't the algorithm. Leasing agents will price high anyway, and $20/month savings won't fix affordability.

A leasing center in Seattle...

If you ban algorithmic rent software, don't assume prices will go down. (Jason Rantz)

(Jason Rantz)

Bellingham may ban algorithmic rent-fixing software. Rents in the city are averaging $2,275 a month, according to KING 5, which is 71% higher than 11 years ago and 14% above the national average. Seattle passed a similar ban last July. King County followed in September. No one claims, suddenly, that rent is now reasonable.

A Bellingham advocacy group called Community First Whatcom is gathering signatures to put Initiative 2601 on the November ballot, which would prohibit landlords from entering price-coordination agreements and ban paid algorithmic pricing services outright.

I get the frustration. I really do. I’ve watched rent on Seattle apartments I was tracking fluctuate daily, creep toward my ideal price range over two or three weeks, and then surge back up the moment it got close enough that I might actually pay it. It is infuriating.

Nobody wants to be the person defending software while people lose stable housing. But wanting to fix a problem is not the same as actually fixing it. And this particular fix has a flaw that’s hard to ignore.

What happens when the algorithm ban goes into effect

Every apartment complex lists its available units and current rents online. Right now, any leasing agent can open a browser, pull up a dozen competitors, see how many units they have open, and price accordingly. Banning formal algorithmic software does not eliminate that option. It just means a human being does the same job the algorithm was doing, only with less precision. That’s the problem.

ADVERTISEMENT

A leasing agent who eyeballs the competition and makes a gut call on pricing is not going to err low on rent. They will price high every time because no leasing agent wants to leave money on the table and nobody at a property management company gets in trouble for overpricing. The algorithm, for all the legitimate criticism of how platforms like RealPage specifically operated, at least carried the theoretical potential to be objective about supply and demand. A person pulling numbers off competitor websites has every incentive to round up.

The actual scandal with RealPage wasn’t really about algorithms in the abstract. It was that the company allegedly fed its model nonpublic data shared between competing landlords, the kind of coordination antitrust law exists to prevent. Washington’s attorney general sued RealPage over exactly that, and the feds ultimately reached a settlement requiring the company to stop using confidential landlord data. That remedy at least targeted the actual offense. A blanket ban on algorithmic pricing targets the technology instead.

ADVERTISEMENT

The math doesn’t move the needle

Even accepting the most optimistic projections for what these bans might accomplish, the savings to individual renters are unlikely to be much. Seattle renters are already paying some of the highest costs in the country, and those prices reflect factors that no software ban was able to prevent. Why is that? Property taxes get passed through to renters. Permitting costs, construction costs, and regulations keep new supply from entering the market. Washington’s cost of living has risen faster than any other state over the past decade, and the pricing software is not driving that.

If these bans produce real, measurable rent relief, my guess is the number comes in around $20 a month. I’ll take $20, I guess. But $20 a month will not save a renter who is currently sleeping in a closet.

Here’s why rent is high

Rents are high because there isn’t enough housing. Every city that has tried to regulate its way to affordability without substantially increasing supply has ended up in roughly the same place. The technology bans feel satisfying because there’s a villain; a faceless algorithm pushing prices up secretly. But eliminating the tool doesn’t eliminate the underlying pressure.

ADVERTISEMENT

Bellingham voters can ban algorithmic pricing software in November if they want. Seattle and King County already did. And property taxes will still push rents up, inventory will still be tight, and leasing agents will still price as high as they think they can get away with. Just without the algorithm to blame.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

1 Comments

M
Mark Mad 6 months ago

Why is it ok for airlines and other industries to use algorithms and not housing? I'm not arguing Realpage was ok. My home taxes have gone up an average of 10% a year since 2000. I believe commercial property is worse. Why is that not a problem? Government regulated insurance, utilities, etc? The hypocrisy of our representatives is far beyond ripe porta potty stench.