ADVERTISEMENT

TAXES

Wall Street Journal pummels Washington Democrats and Supreme Court on income tax

The Wall Street Journal editorial board blasted both the Democrats the left-wing Washington Supreme Court for its ruling in an income tax referendum.

a newspaper stand with the Wall Street Journal...

The Wall Street Journal editorial board was not happy with the Washington Supreme Court ruling barring a referendum on the income tax. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)

(Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)

The Wall Street Journal editorial board wrote a scathing editorial this week after the Washington State Supreme Court gave a green light to the Democrats’ scheme to pretend their income tax was an emergency and should not be subject to a voter referendum.

They quote the Justices arguing that the income tax, which first hits 9.9% of income earned over one million dollars, is “necessary for the… support of the state government” and that it represents “comprehensive system of taxation… with the clear purpose of raising revenue.”

But to the editorial board, the argument made little sense.

“Yes, raising revenue is what most taxes do, but protecting the Legislature’s prerogatives doesn’t square with the state constitution’s ban on progressive taxes on intangible property, which includes income. Nor is it easy to accept the income tax as an urgent revenue matter when it isn’t imposed until 2028,” the editorial board wrote.

Ruling was a gut punch

After the ruling this week, Brian Heywood, founder of Let’s Go Washington, told the Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM the decision was a gut punch, but said the more alarming part is what it signals about the court itself.

“When they wrote the Constitution originally, these people who really went out of their way to prevent taxes on the citizens, who reserved the power to the citizens, they somehow gave a free pass to the legislature so that they can pass any tax they want and they can stop it from being a referendum, stop a vote on it,” Heywood said. “That is sort of a breathtaking interpretation.”

ADVERTISEMENT

What’s worse is that, according to leaked video from a meeting, one Democrat state lawmaker indicated they’re still moving forward with an income tax for non-millionaires.

“We are now going to have more people paying their fair share at the amount they should, right? So you won’t have the highest-earning Washingtonians paying less than the lowest-earning Washingtonians,” Rep. April Berg (D-Everett) said in the leaked Zoom meeting obtained by Future 42. “Now, can I say it makes it perfect? No, but this is the next incremental step in tax justice. If you remember, we went from capital gains, now we’re at income tax. So we’re getting there, all right.”

What happened to the ‘will of the people’?

What’s as objectionable to the Wall Street Journal editorial board is that both Washington Democrats and the progressive Justices ignored the clear will of the people. Washingtonians have rejected income taxes nearly one dozen times.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Lawmakers know income taxes are unpopular, so they also tried to head off taxpayer options when they wrote the legislation,” the editorial board wrote, citing emails from income tax sponsor Sen. Jamie Pedersen (D-Seattle) soliciting advice from the Solicitor General on how they can write the bill to overturn a nearly 100-year precedent that prevented the income tax in the first place.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board concluded with a bit of hope.

The importance of precedent

In their ruling this week saying the income tax isn’t subject to a referendum, the Justices cited respecting precedent. Will they be consistent?

“If the Supreme Court is consistent in following precedent, it will rule that the new income tax is unconstitutional. But we’re more likely to get taxation without voter representation,” the editorial board said.

Heywood made that same point on The Jason Rantz Show.

ADVERTISEMENT

“In order for them to be consistent when the income tax comes before the Supreme Court, I sure hope that they adhere to the same principled stance that they’re taking right now on the referendum,” he said. “You can’t have it both ways. You can’t say, ‘hey, on the referendum, precedent, precedent’ but on the income tax, let’s blow everything up and start all over.”

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

3 Comments

E
Evan Lattimore 7 months ago
“Lawmakers know income taxes are unpopular, so they also tried to head off taxpayer options when they wrote the legislation,” the editorial board wrote

If Jamie Pedersen had any know how, he wouldn't have to use underhanded tactics to save the Democrats from their predicament in the first place.

D
Doug Spittler 7 months ago

WA voters may not have access to a referendum, but they do have access to an effective solution if they'll use it. It's called an "election."

"It doesn't matter what rights you have under the Constitution of the United States, if the government can punish you for exercising those rights. And it doesn't matter what limits the Constitution puts on government officials' power, if they can exceed those limits without any adverse consequences. In other words, the Constitution cannot protect you, if you don't protect the Constitution with your votes against anyone who violates it. Those government officials who want more power are not going to stop unless they get stopped. As long as millions of Americans vote on the basis of who gives them free stuff, look for their freedom -- and all our freedom -- to be eroded away, bit by bit. Our children and grandchildren may yet come to see the Constitution as just some quaint words from the past that people once took seriously." Thomas Sowell

C
Clockwork Wyrm 7 months ago

Consistency doesn't matter to the court because equity! Who cares about the law, justice, precedent, the Constitution, or the will of the people. Those in power are our betters and they will tell us what's good for us.