ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Another Trump win: Appeals court reverses ban on ICE’s use of tear gas in Portland

Immigration and Customs Enforcement wins big in front of a 9th Circuit panel on use of tear gas against violent activists.

Federal agents stand in tear gas clouds outside the Portland ICE facility during protests...

Federal agents stand amid tear gas outside the Portland ICE facility during protests over the Trump administration's immigration enforcement operations. (Photo by Mathieu Lewis-Rolland/Getty Images)

(Photo by Mathieu Lewis-Rolland/Getty Images)

A three-judge panel on the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals delivered a win for federal agents at Portland’s ICE facility on Monday.

In a 2-1 decision, the panel overturned restrictions a lower court had placed on agents in their use of non-lethal crowd dispersal tactics, such as the use of tear gas.

Majority affirms agents’ duty to enforce federal law

The two Trump-appointed judges in the majority, Eric Tung and Kenneth Lee, also ruled that residents living in a nearby apartment complex have no constitutional right “to be free of exposure to chemicals that were released when federal law enforcement officers used tear gas and other non-lethal devices to disperse the crowds.”

Tung and Lee added that “our Constitution is not a NIMBY charter. Our founding document does not address neighborhood grievances concerning unwanted smells and gas–no matter how unpleasant those may be.”

The majority stated that stripping officers of these vital tools would make them more hesitant to enforce federal law.

Biden appointee Judge Ana de Alba said in her dissent that federal agents had used excessive force.

“Moreover, the government’s argument is remarkable given the district court’s uncontested findings that federal officers’ large-scale deployment of chemical munitions was often deliberate and in situations where its use appeared disconnected from any law enforcement purpose,” she wrote.

Portland under siege

The plaintiffs that brought the two cases, Dickinson v. Trump and Reach Community Development, et al. v. United States Department of Homeland Security, et al accused agents of targeting protesters and journalists that posed no threat to them. They also allege that agents caused harm to residents who live nearby with their use of smoke and chemicals.

ADVERTISEMENT

Activists have been engaged in protests outside Portland’s ICE facility since last year and have turned violent at times. City leaders in Portland have sat idly by and allowed the chaos to unfold.

The federal government argued that the building was “under siege” and that these munitions “are a critical defensive law enforcement tool.”

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jackson Meyer Producer, The Jason Rantz Show

Born and raised in Issaquah, Jackson is a lifelong Washingtonian. He is an avid sports fan, particularly of baseball, which he played at the varsity level in High School. He worked at the Seattle-based conservative think tank Discovery Institute for… Read more

Comments

0 Comments