Rantz: Jamie Pedersen effectively tells skeptics of his income tax that they’re too dumb to understand
Pedersen blames income tax skeptics for lacking information, but his own emails reveal SB 6346 was engineered to overturn a 93-year-old constitutional precedent.
Watch: AG Brown Got CAUGHT — Now He's Lying About the Income Tax Emails | 9 mins
Jamie Pedersen has a theory about why Washingtonians across the political spectrum refuse to trust his unconstitutional income tax scheme. The problem, apparently, is that we’re too dumb to understand the issue.
When the Gee and Ursula Show gave the Senate Majority Leader a fair shot to address the growing distrust with his income tax this week, Pedersen’s answer was immediately revealing. Gee handed him about as generous a setup as any politician deserves. “I like what you’re selling,” Gee told Pedersen. “I don’t like how you guys are selling it.”
He told Pedersen he agrees with the idea of higher earners paying more, then asked what legal protection actually exists to stop a future legislature from dropping the income threshold from one million dollars to two hundred thousand or one hundred thousand. Gee noted that, “Over the last week, there’s a lot of people, I’m people, by the way, that are now kind of skeptical of everything going on centered around the millionaire’s tax.” He asked if Pederson understood why people are skeptical.
“I think, honestly, that that is just a matter of not having full information about what is going on,” Pedersen said.
The information is out there — and it makes Pedersen’s case worse
SeattleRed reported on the internal emails that stripped away the funding-for-schools framing. In an August 2025 message, Pedersen put it in writing, saying he would like to “force the Washington Supreme Court to reconsider its caselaw that considers income to be property.” That is the language of someone engineering a constitutional test case.
When Gee raised the email on air, Pedersen did not walk it back. He went further.
“We can’t do the millionaire’s tax,” Pedersen said. “This tax cannot stand if the Supreme Court upholds its 1933 decision. The 1933 decision from the state Supreme Court, called Culliton, was a five-to-four decision 93 years ago. So we must dismantle that. We must get the Supreme Court to change its mind.”
“We just have to say the thing that we hear over and over again is this is against the Constitution,” Ursula said. “Voters have voted against it repeatedly, repeatedly, and you are looking for any and every way that you can to force it to make this, with the hope that the state Supreme Court is going to rule in favor of giving this opening for a state income tax.”
Pedersen’s own words contradict his constitutional argument
What followed was worth the price of admission.
“I do not believe it is contrary to the Constitution,” Pedersen said. “I believe it is completely consistent with the Constitution as it’s written. I think that the 1933 Supreme Court in a five-to-four decision made a mistake. I am asking for the Supreme Court in 2026, 93 years later, to take a second look at that. I just think they were wrong 93 years ago.”
He managed to make obviously contradictory statements without pausing. The tax is completely consistent with the Constitution as written, and the entire legal enterprise depends on overturning a 93-year-old precedent before it can survive a court challenge. MyNorthwest, covering the same interview, noted Pedersen “recognized he’s asking the Supreme Court to take a second look at the 1933 ruling at the center of the debate.” That matches the email he sent himself.
The ‘pie crust promise’ that killed public trust in the income tax
Ursula brought up the other piece that has made trust close to impossible. In 2024, the legislature reaffirmed Washington’s long-standing position against an income tax, then Pedersen, on the record, dismissed that reaffirmation as a “pie crust promise, easily made, easily broken.” He made clear the statutory ban meant nothing because Democrats could amend it with a simple majority vote whenever they felt ready.
His answer when pressed on it this week was that it was “kind of an offhand statement in a conversation that lasted about an hour.”
An offhand statement? The primary architect of Washington’s first income tax would like the public to know that when he previewed Democratic tax commitments as disposable, he did not fully mean it. More than 60,000 people signed in opposition before a vote was cast, the largest response in state legislative history. Pedersen pushed the bill through with an emergency clause to block a public referendum anyway. When Ursula pressed him on why voters were not given a direct vote, he said the proper channel is an initiative to repeal it.
Pass a tax voters never approved, block the referendum mechanism, and then suggest that anyone unhappy about it organize a repeal campaign. That is the accountability structure he is offering?
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
6 Comments
"He [Pederson] made clear the statutory ban meant nothing because Democrats could amend it with a simple majority vote whenever they felt ready."
Yet another reason the legislature, and not just Pederson, cannot be trusted.
How can I tell that Pederson is a liar? His lips move.
Washington state government does not care about the people, constitution, or its legal residents. Tyrannical much?