Washington ranchers face a $3.7M fine. The governor’s people are the judge, jury, and prosecutor.
Wade and Teresa King face a $267,540 Ecology fine and $3.7M bill over disputed wetlands. Pacific Legal Foundation demands a jury trial.
King Ranch, operated by Wade and Teresa King across Grant and Douglas counties, feeds more than 7,600 people annually. The family now faces a $267,540 penalty from the Washington Department of Ecology over disputed wetlands on land they own and lease. (King Family Ranch)
(King Family Ranch)
A Washington ranching family that has worked the same land since the 1950s is now fighting for the right to have their case heard by a jury rather than a panel of governor-appointed bureaucrats.
Wade and Teresa King, who operate King Ranch across Grant and Douglas counties in central Washington, face a $267,540 civil penalty from the Washington State Department of Ecology and estimated compliance costs of more than $3.7 million.
Ecology claims the Kings damaged alkali wetlands while performing stock-water maintenance on property they own and lease for cattle grazing. The Kings dispute both the wetlands designation and the agency’s authority to regulate the sites at issue. Pacific Legal Foundation filed a motion for summary judgment this week in Grant County Superior Court, with arguments set for May 21.
Ecology’s case: stock ponds, disputed wetlands, and a $3.7M bill
The dispute traces back to administrative orders Ecology issued beginning in February 2023, accusing the Kings of harming protected wetlands while digging and maintaining stock-water ponds. A restoration order followed in January 2025, pushing the total compliance bill north of $3.7 million according to the Kings’ own experts.
Oliver Dunford is the senior attorney at Pacific Legal Foundation handling the case.
“The Kings run a cattle ranch, and the Department of Ecology alleges that they harmed some wetlands while they were doing that,” Dunford explained on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM. “The alleged wetlands are on both the King’s property and on government-owned property that the Kings lease for the cattle ranching, and Ecology says that there are some alkali wetlands in the area, and therefore the areas that Ecology is interested in must also be these alkali wetlands that are allegedly protected by Washington law.”
How a $267,540 fine came out of thin air
On where the $267,540 penalty figure came from, Dunford had no flattering answer for the agency.
“No one challenges the fact that it’s going to be really expensive for the Kings. As for the fine, no idea,” he said. “The number seems to come out of thin air. It’s obviously not related to any cost that the government has come up with.”
Dunford also noted that Ecology launched its investigation based on aerial imagery online, not any on-site inspection of the Kings’ private property.
“Ecology looked at some Google Maps, said there were some alkali wetlands in that area, and therefore the sites of interest must also be alkali wetlands,” he said. “Since then, I believe people from Ecology have gone and looked at some of the sites on government-owned property. They have not looked at the King’s property.”
No judge, no jury, just the governor’s people
The Kings were not sent to court after Ecology issued its orders. They were funneled into the Pollution Control Hearings Board, an administrative tribunal whose three members are all appointed by the governor, Dunford said. Ecology is also run by a director appointed by the governor. There is no jury and there is no independent court.
“It’s what the Washington legislature allows. The Pollution Control Act allows Ecology to bring these kinds of claims before the Pollution Control Hearings Board, outside of a jury,” he said. “And the problem is it’s not an independent agency. The director of Ecology is appointed by the governor, and so are the three members of the PCHB. So this is completely within the executive branch, not before an independent court.”
The constitutional challenge: Article I, Section 21 and Jarkesy
Pacific Legal Foundation’s motion argues that arrangement violates the Washington Constitution.
Article I, Section 21 says the right of trial by jury shall remain inviolate. The filing also invokes the Seventh Amendment, citing the U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling in SEC v. Jarkesy, which held that defendants facing civil penalties are entitled to a jury trial even when the government would prefer otherwise.
“The state constitution says that the right of a trial by jury shall be inviolate, and we think that should be taken seriously,” Dunford said. “What the state contends are basically two arguments. One is that the legislature has decided otherwise, that what the Kings are presenting is a novel argument that will overturn decades of law that says that Ecology and other agencies can pursue these kinds of claims before an administrative tribunal.”
Washington farmers and ranchers are already getting squeezed on every side by the state regulatory environment, a story that keeps repeating itself in different forms. Seattle Red has been tracking the same pattern through cases like Thurston County’s proposed home energy mandate, where the state keeps finding ways to insert itself between owners and their own property before anyone has challenged it in an independent court.
What a win — or a loss — means for the Kings
A win at the trial level would halt the PCHB proceeding and force Ecology to pursue its case before an actual court with a jury.
“If we win, we would ask the court first of all to declare, we’re seeking what’s called a declaratory judgment,” Dunford said. “We want the court to declare that the procedures that Ecology is following now are unconstitutional because they deny the Kings the right to a jury, and we’re asking for an injunction. That is, we’re asking the court to enjoin Ecology from prosecuting the Kings in this tribunal, and at that point Ecology would have a decision to make. It does have authority under the law to bring this kind of claim in court.”
The state’s counter-argument, that channeling these disputes through administrative agencies is just efficient government and disrupting it now would be chaos, did not go over well.
“You could make the same argument with criminal law, that we could be a lot more efficient and easy if we just had the police department do all the criminal trials. Could have the police captain be the judge. You could have cops be the jury and be done with it,” Dunford said. “But there are constitutional protections in place because the government has so much power. We think that, especially based on the U.S. Supreme Court case in Jarkesy, the right to the jury trial has been eroded over time.”
Why an adverse PCHB ruling is nearly impossible to fully reverse
Losing carries consequences that go well beyond the hearing itself. Under current Washington law, the PCHB makes the factual findings during the administrative proceeding, and those findings travel with the case on appeal. Courts must largely defer to them.
“Even if the Kings appeal the board’s decision, it will never get a de novo review of the facts. It will always be deferred,” Dunford noted. “The Pollution Control Hearings Board itself makes the findings of fact, and when and if the Kings appeal that decision, then the courts have to treat those findings of fact as settled.”
Pacific Legal Foundation plans to seek expedited review from the Washington Supreme Court if the trial court rules against the Kings, and is prepared to take the case to the U.S. Supreme Court, arguing the Seventh Amendment’s jury trial right should apply against the states.
You can read the motion for summary judgment filed this week and support PLF’s ongoing work at pacificlegal.org.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
3 Comments
How can we help
Just more idealistic rhetoric by the looney left that are not about the law or science but about socialist redistribution of wealth ! Fine the contributing businesses to build more government staff! All of which are either local Democrats or are brought in from other blue states!
It happens all the time !
"So this is completely within the executive branch, not before an independent court.”
No Kings right Democrats? Unless you are referring to King Ranch.