ADVERTISEMENT

TAXES

You’re paying federal taxes today. Washington wants an income tax — and it’s already being sued.

Former AG Rob McKenna and ex-Justice Talmadge sued to block Gov. Ferguson's 9.9% income tax, calling it unconstitutional under 90 years of state precedent.

Activist holds an IRS Direct File free tax filing sign outside an Internal Revenue Service building...

Washington residents faced federal Tax Day deadlines April 14 as a bipartisan legal team filed suit in Klickitat County Superior Court challenging Gov. Bob Ferguson's new 9.9% state income tax as unconstitutional. (Photo by Tasos Katopodis/Getty Images for Economic Security Project)

(Photo by Tasos Katopodis/Getty Images for Economic Security Project)

Washington residents are paying their federal taxes today while their state government faces a lawsuit arguing it just passed one of its own illegally. The provision at issue is Article VII of the state constitution, commonly called the uniformity clause.

Former Attorney General Rob McKenna, a Republican, and former state Supreme Court Justice Phil Talmadge, a Democrat, filed suit last Thursday in Klickitat County Superior Court challenging Gov. Bob Ferguson’s “millionaires tax” as a direct violation of the Washington constitution and nearly a century of binding court precedent. The case was brought through the Citizen Action Defense Fund (CADF) and names plaintiffs from across the state, including farmers, small business owners, and a married couple from Chelan County who would be directly subject to the levy.

Separately, Brian Heywood’s Let’s Go Washington group is pursuing a ballot repeal for November 2026, collecting signatures on a parallel track. The Washington Supreme Court agreed to hear an emergency petition on the referendum question at its April 30 conference.

The constitutional case against SB 6346

Ferguson signed Senate Bill 6346 on March 30, making Washington the latest state to impose a personal income tax. The law hits household wage income above $1 million at a 9.9% rate and is projected to generate roughly $3 billion annually once collections begin in 2029. The state is already hiring more than 300 new government workers at an estimated administrative cost of $557 million to run the program.

The lawsuit’s core argument is simple. Under Washington’s constitution, income is property, and property must be taxed uniformly across all taxpayers at a rate no higher than 1%. A law that taxes one group’s income at 9.9% while leaving everyone else’s untouched fails both requirements. McKenna won a nearly identical fight over Seattle’s income tax years ago and sees no reason the outcome will differ.

ADVERTISEMENT

“For nearly a century, Washington courts have been clear: income is property, and property taxes must be uniform and limited,” McKenna told reporters. “This law disregards both the plain language of the constitution and decades of consistent Supreme Court precedent. We are confident the courts will strike it down.”

The 1933 ruling McKenna says settles it

The governing precedent is Culliton v. Chase, the 1933 Washington Supreme Court decision holding that income is property subject to the uniformity requirement. Washington voters have since rejected income tax proposals ten separate times. McKenna recounted how a similar challenge unfolded when Seattle attempted a comparable tax.

“The state tried to get the state government, the Attorney General Bob Ferguson tried to get the Supreme Court to grant direct review. They said no. So the case went to the court of appeals,” McKenna said. “Court of Appeals said the same thing, ‘Yep, it’s property. That’s what the law says; it’s binding precedent. We don’t get to change precedent.'”

ADVERTISEMENT

Talmadge, a Democrat who spent 16 years in the state Senate before his time on the bench, said the outcome is no close call.

“The Washington Supreme Court has repeatedly reaffirmed that graduated income taxes are unconstitutional,” Talmadge said. “This lawsuit ensures those protections are upheld.”

Ferguson is betting on the Supreme Court

Ferguson weighed in on McKenna’s involvement when asked about the expected challenge on the day he signed the bill.

“I’m very familiar with Rob McKenna,” Ferguson said, according to Fox 13. “As AG, he was opposite side of many cases we brought, and we never lost a case when Rob litigated the other side, so we feel confident that we’ll prevail against him yet again in this lawsuit.”

Attorney General Nick Brown will defend the law in court. Democrats are counting on a state Supreme Court willing to depart from Culliton and point to the capital gains tax ruling as evidence the court might move. Trial courts, however, are bound by existing precedent and will almost certainly rule the tax invalid. The real fight lands with the nine liberal justices.

ADVERTISEMENT

Voters keep getting cut out

CADF executive director Jackson Maynard framed the lawsuit as a question of who actually gets to decide.

“Since lawmakers and the Governor have chosen to ignore both the constitution and decades of settled case law, we will act,” Maynard said. “This lawsuit is about upholding the rule of law and ensuring that Washingtonians are not subjected to an unconstitutional tax scheme.”

Democrats blocked a referendum by inserting a necessity clause into the bill, preventing voters from weighing in the way they have done ten times over the past nine decades. As MyNorthwest reported, the lawsuit includes plaintiffs who argue the tax is already pushing businesses and investment out of the state. Luxury home listings in Washington jumped 65% in a single day after the bill passed, with realtors confirming clients specifically listed their properties because of the incoming tax.

ADVERTISEMENT

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

0 Comments