Spokane sheriff shuts down Flock Safety cameras, citing SB 6002 criminal risk to deputies
Spokane County Sheriff John Nowels deactivated his Flock Safety network, citing SB 6002's vague language and gross misdemeanor risk for deputies.
The Lynnwood City Council is considering 24/7 school zone speed cameras months after canceling its Flock Safety contract. (Photo courtesy of Redmond Police Department)
(Photo courtesy of Redmond Police Department)
Spokane County Sheriff John Nowels has shut down his department’s Flock Safety camera network, a crime-fighting tool that helped solve hundreds of cases over three years, citing dangerously vague new state legislation that puts his deputies at risk of criminal prosecution for simply doing their jobs.
The decision came roughly a week after Pierce County Sheriff Keith Swank made the same call for similar reasons. Both moves stem from newly passed state legislation that Nowels says was written with so little precision that law enforcement cannot operate the systems without risking a gross misdemeanor charge.
Nowels said the move was not made lightly.
Why Spokane County shut down its Flock Safety camera network
Nowels said the cameras had been transformative for public safety in Spokane County since their deployment three years ago. Stolen vehicle recoveries dropped by double digits year over year. Detectives were able to identify and locate suspects faster. Hundreds of cases were closed.
“In the three years that we have had Flock cameras and some of our other camera platforms deployed, it has had a tremendous effect on public safety,” Nowels said. “The number of cases it’s solved has been in the six or seven hundreds over the last three years. It’s been a game changer for law enforcement. And I did not take the decision to turn off those cameras very lightly, because it has been so impactful to our community.”
The problem, according to Nowels, is not the core requirements buried in the legislation but the imprecise language surrounding all law enforcement technology use and the criminal penalty attached to any violation.
“The legislature didn’t listen to us about some of the language and how it impacts how we use all technology, not just license plate readers,” Nowels said. “Some of the language is so vague in it without clear guidelines, and when they attach a penalty of violation of a gross misdemeanor, cops and the people who work in law enforcement were rule followers. They don’t want to do anything that could be construed as violating the law.”
How Democrats’ SB 6002 priorities sidelined public safety
Nowels was blunt about what drove the legislation. Democrats crafted the bill to limit the use of automated license plate reader technology out of concern it could be used to track immigrant communities or, as Nowels noted with some frustration, to monitor women visiting abortion clinics. Neither use case reflected how Spokane County was actually deploying the system.
“They are penning legislation based off of emotions,” Nowels said. “I would love to go back to 15 years ago in the legislature, where legislators were concerned about creating legislation that makes sense and makes the system work better, instead of just hamstringing the police, protecting criminals and protecting illegal immigration.”
Nowels said he had repeatedly asked lawmakers to sit down with law enforcement before finalizing the bill so the language could be shaped around how the technology is actually used.
“I really wish the people who created this legislation would have sat down with us a year ago and let us walk them through exactly how we use the system,” he said. “They could have made a law that was a lot easier to navigate, but they chose not to.”
His office is now working with vendors to find a path to redeployment that cannot be construed as violating the law’s intent.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
0 Comments