ADVERTISEMENT

LEGISLATURE

Spokane Sheriff John Nowels: Ferguson’s SB 5974 will ‘weaponize’ our office and ‘silence elected sheriffs’

Spokane Sheriff John Nowels is suing to block Senate Bill 5974, which lets a Ferguson-appointed board remove elected sheriffs without a public vote.

Spokane County Sheriff patrol vehicle with emergency lights activated outside a stone building...

A Spokane County Sheriff patrol vehicle. Sheriff John Nowels is one of four Eastern Washington sheriffs who filed suit to stop Senate Bill 5974 from taking effect April 30. (Spokane County Sheriff's Office)

(Spokane County Sheriff's Office)

Four Eastern Washington sheriffs are suing to block a new state law that hands an unelected, governor-appointed board the authority to strip elected sheriffs of their certification and remove them from office, with no judicial process and no public vote required.

Spokane County Sheriff John Nowels is one of the four plaintiffs, alongside the sheriffs of Pend Oreille, Stevens, and Ferry counties. He told The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM that the bill’s harmless-sounding title is a deliberate misdirection.

“In true legislative fashion, at least in the state of Washington, they give a bill a title, making it sound like something everybody would want,” Nowels said. “But at the end of the day, this legislation doesn’t do anything more than eliminate a voter’s voice for what I believe is one of the most important elected officials in the county representing local citizens.”

Senate Bill 5974, signed by Gov. Bob Ferguson, creates a five-person board appointed entirely by the governor and grants it the power to decertify a peace officer and automatically vacate their elected office. The law is set to take effect April 30, with a hearing on the challenge scheduled for April 16. The plaintiffs are pushing for an injunction to prevent the law from going into effect while the case moves through the courts.

The real reason behind Senate Bill 5974: removing sheriffs, not accountability

Nowels called the law enforcement accountability argument from supporters a fiction. This is merely about removing sheriffs from office, he said.

ADVERTISEMENT

“That is 100% the reason for this legislation,” he explained. “It has nothing to do with modernizing anything. We are already accountable to the citizens. We are accountable to the Criminal Justice Training Commission in the sense that we have to maintain a peace officer certification, and we have had to since the 70s. So this is going to be used to weaponize the legislation and an elected sheriff’s office to control him or her and what they say and what they do.”

He pointed to language buried in the bill and in the Criminal Justice Training Commission‘s (CJTC) certification standards that could allow the board to remove a sheriff for something as subjective as speaking to a group it labels extremist, with no definition of the term anywhere in the statute.

“We could be removed from office without a vote of the people for exercising our First Amendment rights and to speak out against some of the things our legislature or our governor or our Attorney General might do, which is part of the balance of powers that we have between the executive, legislative and judicial branch,” Nowels continued. “They’re trying to silence elected sheriffs because we’re the last group of elected officials who can protect the people from the government and also from other citizens that might want to violate their liberties. And that’s the kind of power an elected sheriff has, and the legislature doesn’t like anyone to speak out against what they do in the politics they want.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Why only four sheriffs filed the SB 5974 lawsuit — and why others support it

The small number of plaintiffs drew questions from some Washingtonians, with critics suggesting limited support among the state’s sheriffs. Nowels pushed back on that framing.

“We do have broad support from the vast majority of the elected sheriffs in the state,” he said. “Frankly, to get an attorney hired, to have every single prosecuting attorney in a county agree to allow the sheriff to file a lawsuit, to get that done with a large number of sheriffs was very, very complicated, so myself and these eastern Washington sheriffs figured we could move quickly. We could move decisively. And we do have the support from a majority of the sheriffs in the state of Washington.”

Beyond the political will, Nowels noted that three conditions have to align before any county can join the suit, and the financial reality alone is a barrier for many.

ADVERTISEMENT

“You of course have to have a sheriff who wants to be a plaintiff. You have to have a prosecuting attorney that will allow them to become part of the suit. But you also have to have the financial resources,” he explained. “This isn’t free. These attorneys are not doing this pro bono. It’s going to cost taxpayer money to overturn this unconstitutional legislation, and we just happen to have all three of those things with these eastern Washington sheriffs.”

The First Amendment and Washington Constitution case against SB 5974

On the legal merits, Nowels outlined a challenge rooted in both the Washington State Constitution and the First Amendment.

“The power in government is given to us by the people, and it places restrictions on who gets to decide who can run for sheriff. It also places restrictions on what sheriffs can say if we don’t swear an oath to the state constitution as interpreted by the Washington State Supreme Court and swear an oath, for a lack of a better term, to the Washington State Criminal Justice Training Commission, which isn’t required of anybody and not expressly expressed in the Constitution,” he argued. “And then again, probably the most egregious part, and the part that will become political, is it allows an unelected body of people put in place by the governor to remove an elected sheriff from office without any voice of the people who put him in place.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Nowels acknowledged the lawsuit could make him a marked man but said he has no intention of standing down.

“I think there are certain sheriffs that they have in mind that I think they would like to come after first, but we’ll see how it plays out,” he noted. “I’m not worried. I’ll make my case to the public. I have maintained a peace officer certification for 28 and a half years here in the state of Washington. I don’t know that they’re going to be able to kick me out now.”

The lawsuit is being handled by the law firm Carney Badley Spellman.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

0 Comments