ADVERTISEMENT

TAXES

Portland wants to tax property owners for empty storefronts — even though city policy drove them out

Portland eyes a vacancy fee on empty downtown storefronts, but real estate developers say city leaders — not landlords — caused the crisis.

Oregonians say high taxes and regulations hurt city growth. (Photo by Steve Dykes/Getty Images)...

Oregonians say high taxes and regulations hurt city growth. (Photo by Steve Dykes/Getty Images)

(Photo by Steve Dykes/Getty Images)

Portland is exploring a vacancy fee to punish commercial property owners for empty storefronts downtown. It’s drawing criticism from a Pacific Northwest real estate developer who says the city is trying to tax its way out of a catastrophe its own leaders caused.

The proposal, championed by Portland City Council members Jamie Dunphy and Sameer Kanal, would impose a fee on building owners based on how long their spaces have sat vacant, according to a KGW report. The city has already commissioned a $62,000 study to examine the idea.

Portland’s downtown office vacancy rate sits at roughly 40 percent, and retailers and office tenants have been abandoning the city for years as crime, drug use, and open-air encampments made doing business there increasingly untenable.

Real estate industry fires back at Portland’s vacancy fee plan

Patrick Foley, Co-Founder and Managing Partner at Lake Union Partners, reacted to the proposal on LinkedIn. He was not pleased.

“For those who own and operate commercial real estate in cities around the country, especially on the west coast of the United States and Canada, proposals like this in Portland are ridiculous,” Foley wrote on LinkedIn. “Believe me, building owners would love to have fully occupied thriving retail spaces. However, it’s widely known that crime, drug activity, and camping have driven retailers and office tenants out of the downtowns. And its city council members like Jamie Dunphy and Sameer Kanal who push for tolerance and a light touch on crime that drives retail and office tenants out.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Foley also took aim at the logic underpinning the proposal.

“Portland already has a 40% office vacancy rate and charging building owners who are already struggling to fill space, a penalty tax on vacant space is next-level stupid,” he continued. “Think about it. Cities want to tax/penalize building owners because of a problem they (city governments) created. Vancouver, Seattle, Portland, San Francisco, Los Angeles, San Diego. We have to stop electing people who think like this.”

Evidence suggests the fee won’t work anyway

Market analyst Aaron Kirk Douglas of HFO Investment Real Estate told KOIN 6 News that landlords are already absorbing the cost of incentives, including free rent and free parking, just to attract tenants to a market that is already battered.

“If you own an apartment building, there’s no incentive to have a vacant unit,” Douglas said.

ADVERTISEMENT

One recent study found that vacancy taxes fail to meaningfully reduce empty spaces even under favorable economic conditions. Vancouver’s Empty Homes Tax, launched in 2017 and later raised to 3 percent, generated revenue but left average rents largely unchanged, according to the C.D. Howe Institute.

There’s still time for change

Dunphy acknowledged that no specific policy is finalized.

“We really need to make sure this is the right tool solving the right problem,” he told KGW. Kanal has framed the fee as a mechanism to push commercial rents downward. “When your favorite restaurant goes out of business or moves, very often it’s the rent,” Kanal said. “So, how do we create downward pressure on rent?”

Portland is staring down a $50.7 million budget gap this fiscal year. A city that cannot fund basic services is now looking to micromanage the commercial real estate market by penalizing the investors it desperately needs to attract?

ADVERTISEMENT

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

2 Comments

S
Shawn m 8 months ago

California is now working on a similar vacancy tax. Katie Wilson will surely be remembered for originating a downright cruel tax on property owners who struggle, or can't pay their bills due anti-business policies. But if you're working to throw the gates wide for "Socialism," it makes pretty good sense.

S
SHERRIE Holbrook 8 months ago

I can't believe these people think they're 'working' for the people. They're on the gravy train and can't let go. THIS IS NOT WHAT AMERICA WAS FOUNDED ON.