ADVERTISEMENT

SEATTLE RED OPINION

Chris Cargill: Citizens are fleeing bad policy – here’s the proof

New Census data shows a steady domestic migration shift from King County toward interior states.

Washington income tax sparks business exodus. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)...

Washington income tax sparks business exodus. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)

(Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)

The latest Census migration data tell a clear and consistent story: people are voting with their feet. In King County, Washington’s largest population center and economic hub, domestic migration has been negative for years. Between 2023 and 2024 alone, the county lost 12,501 residents to other parts of the United States. The following year, another 9,079 left. Since 2020, the cumulative loss has reached more than 95,000 people.

This is not a one-year anomaly. It is a sustained pattern. At the same time, Idaho’s largest counties are experiencing the opposite trend. Ada County, home to Boise, gained more than 8,500 residents from other states in the most recent year, and nearly 39,000 since 2020. Canyon County added over 5,600 residents last year and nearly 33,000 over the same period. Even Kootenai County in North Idaho—smaller but fast-growing—has gained more than 20,000 residents domestically since 2020.

Montana shows a similar, if smaller-scale, pattern. Yellowstone County, the state’s largest, continues to post steady domestic in-migration gains year after year. Taken together, these data points describe a regional shift: large coastal metro areas are losing residents domestically, while interior states are gaining them.

The question is why?

The impact of cost and policy

Cost of living is an obvious factor. King County remains one of the most expensive places in the country to buy a home or raise a family. Housing supply constraints, regulatory burdens, and land-use policies have combined to drive prices well beyond what many middle-income households can afford.

ADVERTISEMENT

But cost alone does not fully explain the pattern. Policy choices play a significant role.

Washington’s largest counties have layered on higher taxes, stricter regulations, and in some cases public safety challenges that have changed how residents evaluate quality of life. Businesses face higher operating costs. Workers face longer commutes and higher housing expenses. Families face tradeoffs that did not exist a generation ago.

A changing business climate

Meanwhile, Idaho and Montana have taken a different approach. Lower taxes, fewer regulatory barriers, and more flexible housing development policies have made it easier to build, invest, and relocate. These states are not simply benefiting from Washington’s losses—they are offering an alternative model that is attracting residents on its own merits.

The migration data reflect these differences.

Ada, Canyon, and Kootenai counties are not just growing—they are consistently gaining residents from other parts of the United States, year after year. The same is true, at a smaller scale, in Yellowstone County. These are not short-term spikes; they are durable trends.

ADVERTISEMENT

International vs domestic shifts

Importantly, King County is still growing overall—but only because of international migration. Without those inflows, the county’s population would likely stagnate or decline. That distinction matters. It means domestic outmigration is being masked, not reversed. In other words, the region is not standing still—it is being reshaped.

For policymakers, the implications are significant. If current trends continue, Washington risks losing not just population, but also middle-income households, workforce stability, and long-term economic competitiveness.

The data do not suggest that people are leaving for one single reason. But they do suggest that when costs rise, regulations tighten, and quality-of-life concerns increase, residents respond. And increasingly, they are choosing to respond by leaving.

The growth of Idaho and Montana’s largest counties is not happening in isolation. It is part of a broader rebalancing across the West—one driven by policy, affordability, and opportunity. And for now, that movement is heading inland.

ADVERTISEMENT

Chris Cargill is the President of Mountain States Policy Center, an independent free market think tank based in Idaho, Montana, Wyoming and Eastern Washington. Online at mountainstatespolicy.org.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

3 Comments

T
The Watosh 8 months ago

Nice article, but TELL THE ENTIRE STORY. TELL THE TRUTH. SHOUT IT OUT LOUD AND CLEAR.

Do a word search on the article. Absolutely NOWHERE on the page is the word DEMOCRAT.

WHO, WHAT, WHEN, WHERE, WHY AND HOW. The absolute truthful bottom line is that the cause of the decline in WA and the cause of the migration out is DEMOCRATS. No more, no less. No excuses. The WHO is DEMOCRATS, the WHY is DEMOCRAT policies, the HOW is by DEMOCRAT policies. The WHEN is NOW. The WHERE is WA State.

But where do you read that in the article? Nowhere. It's time to tell it like it is. The DEMOCRATS ARE DESTROYING WASHINGTON STATE.

DEMOCRATS. Tell it in plain English. Shout it out. Quit trying to keep it quiet so that no one gets offended. WE ARE OFFENDED AND WE'RE LEAVING BECAUSE OF DEMOCRATS. That is the TRUTH.

G
George Payne 8 months ago

The 2025 rate of increase in people exiting Washington State is 45% over 2023 and 2024. Looking forward this signals a rapid dilution in Washington's tax base, decreasing GDP, inflation increasing at an alarming rate and rising unemployment. Stagflation on the horizon.

J
Johnny Ruger 8 months ago

Boise and Bozeman are being infected as well.