Rantz: Democrats want to ban talk therapy but mandate puberty blockers. The Supreme Court noticed in Colorado conversion case
The Supreme Court ruled 8-1 in Chiles v. Salazar that Colorado's conversion therapy ban is unconstitutional. Jason Rantz breaks down the ruling.
Firefighters fight for religious rights at United States Supreme Court. (Photo by Roberto Schmidt/Getty Images)
(Photo by Roberto Schmidt/Getty Images)
Conversion therapy can be a bad idea. The notion that a counselor can talk a gay teenager into “becoming straight” strikes me as dangerously naive. But activists on the Radical Left losing their minds over Tuesday’s Supreme Court ruling are the same activists and politicians who think the government should stay out of the room when a doctor puts a 12-year-old on puberty blockers over a parent’s objection. They want to ban a conversation between a trained adult and a child confused by leftist adults about his or her gender. They want to mandate a medical intervention. And they’d like you not to notice the contradiction.
The court noticed. Eight to one.
Here’s what the Supreme Court said about Colorado’s conversion therapy law
In Chiles v. Salazar, the court sided with Christian counselor Kaley Chiles in her free speech challenge to Colorado’s ban on counselors attempting to talk through a minor’s sexual orientation or gender identity confusion. To the Radical Left, unless you immediately affirm a biological girl identifying as a boy, you are committing a moral sin and child abuse.
But writing for an 8-1 majority, Justice Neil Gorsuch was not subtle about what Colorado had done wrong. The Colorado law, Gorsuch wrote, required far more rigorous review under the First Amendment.
“Colorado may regard its policy as essential to public health and safety,” he noted. “Certainly, censorious governments throughout history have believed the same. But the First Amendment stands as a shield against any effort to enforce orthodoxy in thought or speech in this country.”
Eight justices, including liberals Elena Kagan and Sonia Sotomayor, recognized that what Colorado built was a viewpoint discrimination machine dressed up in the language of public health. After reading excerpts of the law out loud during oral arguments last October, conservative Justice Samuel Alito said the Colorado law “looks like blatant viewpoint discrimination.” He was right then and the ruling proves it now.
Justice Jackson’s dissent: why the lone ‘no’ vote got it wrong
Colorado’s 2019 ban prohibited licensed mental health counselors from engaging in “any practice or treatment” that “attempts or purports to change” a minor’s sexual orientation or gender identity, with violations carrying $5,000 fines and the possibility of suspension or loss of licensure. The Hill That is not regulating medicine. That is regulating a point of view.
The government cannot fine you into ideological compliance and call it healthcare policy.
The lone dissenter, Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, argued that the Constitution does not pose a barrier to reasonable regulation of harmful medical treatments just because substandard care comes via speech instead of scalpel. It’s not-so-clever framing that Gorsuch dismantled.
The dissent, he wrote, “may believe that state-imposed orthodoxies in speech pose few dangers and many benefits in this field (and who knows what others). But their policy is not the First Amendment’s.”
The left’s outrage over the ruling exposes the real agenda
The loudest voices raging against this ruling are the same activists and politicians who have spent years insisting that gender-affirming care for minors is sacrosanct and that any parental objection to it is bigotry. The same movement that wants to chemically and surgically alter children’s bodies, including without a parent’s consent or over their active objection, is now outraged that a Christian counselor might be permitted to have a voluntary conversation with a teenager who sought her out.
They want the government to stop a counselor from talking, and they want the government to get out of the way when a doctor is prescribing puberty blockers to a 12-year-old. That is not a coherent philosophy. That is a political agenda that uses whatever argument is convenient in the moment to expand ideological control over what happens to children.
The irony practically writes itself. The activists treating this ruling like a civil rights catastrophe have no problem with minors being steered toward irreversible medical interventions. They just object to minors being permitted to voluntarily sit with a counselor who holds traditional religious views (and hold an unambiguously mainstream view on the issue of gender). The outrage is not about protecting kids. It is about protecting a preferred ideological outcome.
The First Amendment doesn’t require you to like the speech it protects
You do not have to like conversion therapy to understand that the government cannot ban conversations it dislikes.
Chiles made clear she would engage in faith-informed counseling only when clients sought it out and explicitly disavowed especially controversial practices like the use of electric shock therapy. She wanted to help clients who were looking for help on their own terms. Colorado wanted to make that illegal. The Supreme Court said no, and it was right to do so.
The First Amendment exists, in part, to protect speech the government finds inconvenient or offensive. If you believe in free expression, this ruling is a straightforward win, regardless of how you feel about the underlying therapy. The people unwilling to see that are the ones who only believe in free speech when it says what they want it to say.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
0 Comments