ADVERTISEMENT

TAXES

Rep. Jim Walsh lays out three-pronged lawsuit against Washington’s new income tax

Rep. Jim Walsh outlines a three-pronged legal attack — including an Article VII constitutional challenge — to overturn Washington's SB 6346 income tax.

Lawsuit challenges Washington’s unconstitutional graduated income tax. (Photo: Getty Images)...

Lawsuit challenges Washington’s unconstitutional graduated income tax. (Photo: Getty Images)

(Photo: Getty Images)

The legal fight to overturn Washington’s SB 6346 — a 9.9% income tax on household income above $1 million signed by Gov. Bob Ferguson — is underway, with State Representative and state GOP Chairman Jim Walsh promising a “three-prong attack.” Walsh’s primary strategy is a constitutional challenge under Article VII of the Washington State Constitution, which has required tax uniformity since the 1933 Supreme Court ruling in Culliton v. Chase. Former state Attorney General Rob McKenna has separately announced he will also file suit.

“The lawsuit approach, three prong attack the lawsuit approach, challenge the constitutionality of the bill,” Walsh told The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM. “It is in violation of article seven, section one of the State Constitution.”

The core of the legal strategy relies on the state’s requirement that taxes be applied fairly to everyone. Walsh pointed out that the current version of the tax fails to meet that standard because it targets only a small group of residents.

“What it says in section one there is this kind of tax has to be uniform,” Walsh said. “So if you’re going to have the tax, it has to be the same rate applied evenly to all families, all households in Washington. And clearly, the governor’s version of this does not do that.”

Why Walsh says this income tax is a threat to all Washington families

While Governor Bob Ferguson’s income tax is currently aimed at high earners, Walsh warned that the legal structure of the bill makes it easy for the government to eventually tax all working families. He noted that once the precedent is set, it only takes a small change to the law to expand it.

ADVERTISEMENT

“The truth is, mechanically, structurally, the bill is a state income tax and then there’s one little paragraph, one little section in it that says, Well, there’s a threshold for household incomes,” Walsh said. “You strike that one little paragraph out, and this is a 9.9% state income tax on all working Washingtonians, and that’s their long term play.”

Former Attorney General Rob McKenna has offered similar criticisms of the unconstitutional income tax.

The federal fallback: Walsh’s Dormant Commerce Clause theory

While the case will likely start in state courts, Walsh mentioned a secondary strategy to move the fight to the federal level.

“There is what’s called the Dormant Commerce Clause theory, and it’s a reading of the Commerce Clause in the US Constitution that could apply,” Walsh said. “The idea is, if a policy is so bad in a state that it affects other states around it, or interstate commerce, sometimes you can get the federal courts to agree to have a look at it.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jasneet Gill Content Editor

Jasneet Gill is a content editor and writer for Seattle Red. She is a Washington native, born and raised in the state, and a graduate of the University of Washington with a bachelor's degree in Communications. Her passion for soccer led her to play… Read more

Comments

2 Comments

D
Doug Spittler 8 months ago

Dem politicians obviously are aware of the uniformity requirement in the Constitution. Was it their scheme all along to get the courts to demand the new tax be applied to all Washingtonians? That certainly sounds like a typically Machiavellian Progressive bit of taxpayer money extraction. (All while pitifully lamenting the "affordability" crisis...)

S
Shawn m 8 months ago

Wouldn't it be fun if Bezos, Narayana Nadella, Robert Kelly Ortberg and Howard Schultz bombarded the air waves with spots supporting the upcoming anti-income tax initiative? Gotta be quick about it though, the legislature was working on a bill that would make such an act illegal --while infusing mighty grim consequences for lawbreakers. We'll see what happens next session.