ADVERTISEMENT

MEDIA BIAS

Pierce County Sheriff Swank says the News Tribune’s use-of-force racial disparity story omitted the stat that wrecks its own narrative

Pierce County Sheriff Keith Swank tells the Jason Rantz Show that the Tacoma News Tribune's use-of-force racial disparity report omits the one stat that disproves its own narrative.

Pierce County Sheriff's Office patrol vehicle with department badge on door...

A Pierce County Sheriff's Office vehicle. (Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)

(Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)

A Tacoma News Tribune story published Monday claims Pierce County deputies used force against Black people and Native Americans at more than three times the rate they did against white people in 2024, framing the numbers as proof of a persistent racial problem inside the Sheriff’s Office. Sheriff Keith Swank says the story is missing the one piece of context that changes the entire picture.

Swank told The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM that the data predates his tenure as sheriff and that the Tribune’s methodology contains a fundamental flaw it never adequately addresses.

The report, produced by the county’s Finance Department and presented to the County Council’s Public Safety Committee in February, found that deputies used force against Black people and Native Americans at more than three times the per-capita rate they did against white people in 2024. The framing strongly implies racial bias as the driver.

What the story buries is a number sitting inside its own data. Deputies used force against white people in 63 percent of all incidents in 2024, while white residents make up 66 percent of the population in areas the Sheriff’s Office patrols. The article never grapples with what that near-parallel actually means for the racial-disparity narrative it is pushing.

The report’s own limitations section acknowledges that the data lacks any context for why force was used in each incident and makes no determination about whether any specific use of force was lawful. It also does not include data on how use-of-force incidents compare to total police contacts or arrest rates by demographic, leaving the per-capita framing without the one variable that would actually explain it.

ADVERTISEMENT

Sheriff Swank challenges the per-capita use-of-force methodology

Swank said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM that he had not yet had the chance to review the full dataset. He said the story’s core assumption, that force should be distributed according to population share, does not reflect how policing actually works.

“Our deadly force encounters are down since I become the sheriff, and that’s a good thing,” Swank explained. “I want them to be down to zero.”

Swank said his office has been focused on training, leadership, and supervision since he took office, and he is planning to review the complete numbers before responding formally.

“I’m hoping that the use of force has gone down not because I had to do anything specifically, but just because of training and leadership and supervision,” Swank said on The Jason Rantz Show.

ADVERTISEMENT

Use-of-force incidents up 57% since 2021, but staffing shortages and pursuit law changes explain the increase

The report itself notes that use-of-force incidents remain below pre-pandemic levels despite a 57 percent rise since 2021. The Finance Department’s own analysis flagged several factors behind that increase, including a pandemic-era drop in arrests, significant staffing shortages inside the Sheriff’s Office, and changes to vehicle pursuit laws.

The report does not break down force data by call type, crime category, or suspect behavior, making it impossible to determine from the numbers alone whether any disparity is a product of bias or of where the most serious criminal activity is occurring.

Pierce County Sheriff’s Office spokesperson Carly Cappetto told the Tribune that the accuracy of use-of-force data can be significantly affected by where the data originates, particularly when disparities in enforcement practices are being examined.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Understanding these limitations of data collection is crucial when interpreting such data and drawing conclusions about fairness and accountability in law enforcement,” Cappetto said.

Swank said he intends to meet with Pierce County Executive Ryan Mello to go through the numbers together before drawing any conclusions.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

1 Comments

M
Michael Rovech 5 months ago

The substance of your reports are well researched and informative, however one issue in this article which is present in many that discuss issues of race is that the term "black" is always capitalized while the term "white" is all lower case. That seems like an awfully politically correct action that I would expect from a left-wing article, but not from this publication. Either capitalize both or capitalize neither.