Patty Murray’s embarrassing voter fraud ‘lightning’ claim doesn’t survive the math | Jason Rantz
Sen. Patty Murray claims voter fraud is as rare as a lightning strike. The math says otherwise — and it's the Democrats who blocked investigations that made the data look clean.
Sen. Patty Murray (D-WA) addresses reporters at the U.S. Capitol. Her post claiming Trump wants to spend half a trillion dollars on a war with Iran drew more than 120 critical replies on X within hours of posting. (Photo: Kayla Bartkowski, Getty Images)
(Photo: Kayla Bartkowski, Getty Images)
Sen. Patty Murray (D-Washington) is moonlighting as a Temu-meteorologist in her attempt to sink the SAVE America Act. And it’s embarrassing.
In a recent social media post, Murray insisted that voter fraud is already illegal, already rare, and that “the average American is more likely to be struck by lightning than to commit it.”
“This isn’t a widespread issue like Republicans want you to think,” she wrote.
If that lightning reference sounds familiar, it’s because virtually every Democrat lawmaker is using it. It’s part of a coordinated, scripted, and focus-grouped talking point. And it badly falls apart the moment anyone does the math — or reads the news.
The problem with measuring voter fraud you refuse to investigate
Let’s start with the foundational flaw. Murray presents fraud statistics as settled science. They are not. You cannot produce a reliable fraud rate when Democrats have spent years blocking the investigations, audits, and citizenship verification systems that would generate that data in the first place. It’s one of the reasons they don’t want to pass the SAVE America Act.
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration estimates roughly 300 Americans are struck by lightning each year. That number is credible because lightning leaves evidence. Bodies. Burn marks. Medical records.
Voter fraud, by contrast, is prosecuted at a fraction of the rate it likely occurs. Fraud that goes unreported, uninvestigated, or unprosecuted never enters the dataset. When you block the investigation, the numbers look clean. That is not evidence of integrity. That is evidence of willful ignorance.
Now do the math on Patty Murray’s voter fraud numbers
Murray chose the lightning analogy, so let us honor it.
NOAA puts lifetime odds of being struck by lightning at roughly 1 in 15,300. Apply that same rate to the 155 million ballots cast in the 2024 presidential election and you arrive at approximately 10,000 fraudulent votes — by her own math, using her own comparison.
Ten thousand fraudulent votes is not a minor rounding error. It is enough to decide congressional races, flip state legislative chambers, and in a close enough cycle, alter an Electoral College outcome. Murray handed conservatives the rebuttal and apparently never ran the numbers herself.
And again — that is the floor. That figure assumes the fraud rate is accurately measured, which it cannot be when Democrats have spent years blocking the investigations that would produce reliable data.
Washington has cases. Real ones.
Here in Washington state, we don’t need to speculate about mail-in ballot fraud. A Lewis County man was convicted of voting in both Washington and Oregon in the same election. A state appeals court later overturned the conviction because Washington law didn’t clearly define what constituted a single election — a loophole so embarrassing that a bipartisan legislature voted 93-0 to close it. When Democrats vote unanimously to fix a noncitizen voting (or ineligible voter) loophole, they are admitting the fraud was real enough to legislate against.
Then there is Pasco, where a 52-year-old apartment complex manager named Esperanza Contreras was charged with multiple felonies after allegedly filling out and submitting ballots for tenants without their knowledge. According to the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office, at least two of those ballots were actually counted. At the federal level, the DOJ recently convicted a Colombian national who voted illegally in the 2024 presidential election using a stolen identity while collecting more than $400,000 in federal benefits.
Lightning doesn’t look like this. Fraud does. And it’s not just happening in Washington state elections.
The gun logic Democrats forgot they use
Here is where Murray’s argument gets genuinely insulting. For years, Democrats have justified sweeping gun legislation with a single moral premise — even if it saves just one life, it is worth it. Entire policy agendas have been constructed on that logic. Red flag laws, magazine restrictions, background check expansions — all sold on the principle that a rare harm still demands a legislative response.
So which is it? Is rare harm worth legislating against, or isn’t it? You cannot argue that one illegal vote is too rare to address and simultaneously argue that one gun death demands immediate federal action. The intellectual standard cannot shift based on which outcome your party prefers.
Murray isn’t arguing in good faith about fraud statistics. She is running interference for a party that has decided election integrity enforcement is a threat to its coalition. The lightning line is a punchline masquerading as a policy argument. Washington voters deserve better than a senator who thinks they can’t do basic division.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
4 Comments
How about this one Patty:
California sheriff seizes 650,000 ballots in defiance of state officials over election count dispute
Story by Anders Hagstrom
FoxNews
3/23/2026
A California sheriff and top Republican candidate for governor seized over 650,000 votes from the state's November (2025) elections this weekend.
Riverside County Sheriff Chad Bianco launched an investigation into the state's November 2025 special election on Proposition 50 after a third-party organization, the Riverside Election Integrity Team, claimed it found roughly 45,000 excess votes. California elections officials have dismissed the team's findings, but Bianco says his office will conduct another count.(Proposition 50 passed by 103 votes)
"This investigation is simple: Physically count the ballots and compare that result with the total votes recorded," Bianco told reporters at a Friday press conference.
Proposition 50 was a key proposal seeking to reform California's congressional districts. It was designed to favor Democrats in response to a similar effort by Republicans in Texas.
BIANCO SAYS ‘DEMOCRAT POLICY IS INDEFENSIBLE’ AS GOP CANDIDATES TOP CALIFORNIA GOVERNOR POLLING
Why should anyone believe an adult that cuts her own hair? She is simply not a serious person.
She must be on something