‘Fiscal suicide’: Wall Street Journal says Washington Democrats are the real threat to democracy, not Trump
WSJ editorial board rips Washington Democrats for passing an unconstitutional income tax while blocking voters.
The WSJ editorial board ripped Washington Democrats for passing an unconstitutional income tax, ignoring 100,000 opponents, and blocking a voter referendum. (Photo by Cate Gillon/Getty Images)
(Photo by Cate Gillon/Getty Images)
The Wall Street Journal editorial board didn’t mince words Wednesday, arguing that Washington state Democrats are bulldozing the state constitution, ignoring more than 100,000 residents who registered opposition, and rigging the rules to make sure voters can’t reverse the damage.
The target is a new 9.9% tax on household income above $1 million annually, which passed the state House 51-46 and is headed back to the state Senate with Democratic Gov. Bob Ferguson ready to sign it.
Democrats dismiss 100,000 Washingtonians
Washington’s constitution prohibits an income tax, and voters have rejected such proposals 10 times. That democratic track record didn’t stop Olympia Democrats, and it didn’t stop them from brushing off the public backlash, either.
According to the Wall Street Journal, more than 100,000 residents registered opposition to the bill by the time it reached the House floor. Senate Deputy Majority Leader Manka Dhingra (D-Redmond) wasn’t moved.
“So we’ll take it with a grain of salt,” Dhingra said at the time.
The fine print that guarantees a middle-class tax
The Journal’s editorial board noted that Democrats buried a so-called necessity clause in the bill, a legislative maneuver that shields the tax from being overturned by a voter referendum. If the tax were as popular as Democrats claim, the clause would be unnecessary.
“Once the state’s constitutional guardrails come off, middle-class Washingtonians know tax-and-spend Democrats will be coming for them next. That’s what happens in every state that has introduced an income tax. Spending soars with the new revenue, and politicians demand even higher taxes. The rate starts low, or at a high level of income, but the rate inevitably gets higher and the income threshold lower. It’s a slow form of fiscal suicide,” the editorial board wrote.
The board also flagged the inflation adjustment, or lack thereof. The House stripped out annual inflation adjustments to the $1 million threshold, replacing them with a biennial adjustment tied to a slower national CPI rather than Seattle’s own consumer price index. House Republicans say the result is a threshold that grows at roughly one-third the real rate of inflation. Year after year, the millionaire tax will drag in earners who were never millionaires when Democrats passed it. That is how a targeted tax becomes a middle-class tax.
WSJ lands the sharpest blow
The Journal’s editorial board closed with a line that should follow every Washington Democrat into their next campaign season.
“Democrats are gambling that they can get away with this because the state Supreme Court is so partisan it will rubber stamp whatever they do. That’s what the court did in 2023 by ruling that a 7% tax on capital-gains income was an excise tax, not a tax on property or income. And Democrats claim Donald Trump is the threat to democracy,” the board wrote.
Washington Democrats spent years warning about threats to democratic norms. They just passed a tax the constitution doesn’t allow, ignored 100,000 constituents, and locked the public out of any vote to undo it.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
6 Comments
The very open disdain and disrespect for voters is shocking. She isn't even hiding her contempt.
They're pulling the same kinds of shiesty male cow fecal matter down here, in Oregon. Awhile back, there was a ballot measure that increased fees at the DMV and the gas tax rate, that Tina Kotax championed as absolutely vital to the well being of the Oregon DOT.
An overwhelming majority of Oregonians voted no on the measure. That should have been the end of it, right? The people spoke - quite loudly - that we didn't want to spend more money. Especially since budget money keeps "getting lost", around here.
What does she do? Creates a new bill that was going to accomplish the same things that we just voted down, and FORCED it through the House and Senate, to get it passed anyway.
Oregonians sprung into action, and within a week, we already had a referendum with more than enough signatures to put it -specific - on the NOVEMBER 2026 ballot, so we could vote THIS one down, as well - on the same ballot that she's going to be on for her re-election campaign. That way, voters would see her shiesty bill at the same time they were voting on our next Governor. November also has way more voters, so we were trying to ensure that enough people would speak loudly enough for her........and she FORCED it to be moved to the May primaries - where there are significantly less voters to oppose her bill, and so that, come November, she is counting on most Oregonians who are mad about it now, to hopefully forget about it, and re-elect her.
“So we’ll take it with a grain of salt,” Dhingra said at the time.
Even the left is rejecting this classy lady, who was captured in a national WSJ cameo, no less.