Family sues Edmonds School District over ‘useless’ diploma
A family is suing the Edmonds School District for giving a student a "useless" diploma.
Family sues school district over misleading diploma. (Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)
(Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)
For most students, a high school diploma is a proud achievement, but for Makena Simonsen, it felt like a trap. Makena, a graduate with special needs from the Edmonds School District, finished high school with a nearly perfect GPA. But her family says those grades were misleading because she was still reading at a first-grade level.
Now, they are suing the district, claiming that giving her a diploma actually did more harm than good by cutting off her access to essential financial help for a program she planned to attend.
The high cost of a ‘participation trophy’
The problem started when Makena tried to sign up for a free program that helps special needs students learn how to live independently, according to KING 5.
Since she had already received her diploma, the district told her she was no longer eligible for their free services. Instead, Makena had to enroll in a similar program at Bellevue College, which costs over $40,000 a year. Her lawyers argue that the diploma was treated like a “participation trophy” that effectively locked her out of the support she actually needed.
By the time she graduates, she expects to be $160,000 in debt—money her family believes she wouldn’t owe if the school district hadn’t pushed her to graduate early. The lawsuit calls this “benevolent discrimination,” arguing that the school was trying to be nice but ended up ruining her financial future, per KING 5.
While the Edmonds School District has denied any wrongdoing and refused to comment on the case, Makena says she is determined to move forward, even though her journey to independence turned out to be much harder than her family ever expected.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
4 Comments
I bet this wouldn't have been a problem for an illegal alien student!
What a tragedy!
This young lady has had her future decimated, and her local public school doesn't give a crap!!
Public schools are the enemy of the state, imo.
Blessings to you and continue on towards your journey!!
This was an article about the suit bright against the district, not a dissertation on the state of education. They state that the young woman was graduated early, and it would seem that act disqualified her from a program that would have helped her gain skills she needed post high school.
now I would say, this is an I indictment against the school system as it should be teaching students these important lessons the entire time, but I'm going to limit it to Special Ed here, and assume there was a course that offered this at the ends of the year, which was missed due to the early graduation. They aren't bringing suit against Bellevue Collage, but against the high school program.
pretty cut and dry article to me, you're making more of it than is there. I do personally believe the entire public school system needs to be destroyed, torn out for and branch and the earth salted so nothing ever grows there again, but that's a separate issue.