ADVERTISEMENT

POLITICS

From CHAZ to taxes: the Left’s problem with truth in Washington

A voter’s question prompts an examination of lies, framing, and hypocrisy in Washington’s political landscape.

A voter’s question sparks analysis of political untruths. (Photo by Nathan Howard/Getty Images)...

A voter’s question sparks analysis of political untruths. (Photo by Nathan Howard/Getty Images)

(Photo by Nathan Howard/Getty Images)

Recently, a Seattle voter who’s evolving politically from left-of-center to libertarian-right has been sending me a series of thoughtful questions about politics. Most of her questions are connected to specific policy points. But some are more philosophical. This one is the most interesting so far:

“My progressive friends call Republicans, and especially you, ‘liars.’ When I say all politicians lie, they get angry and say that Democrats don’t lie and ‘Trump is a felon.’ Which I know is technically not true, because his convictions were overturned. But still. You talk about the ‘Big Truth.’ So, do all politicians lie? Or is it more like politicians shade the truth?”

What follows is a shortened version of my answer to her. In politics, there are three types of untruth: outright lies (less common than you might think), rhetorical framing (far more common) and hypocrisy (most common). Here in Washington, the left-wing politicians indulge in all three because the state’s mainstream media doesn’t challenge them on any of it. That’s why I believe in the line attributed to George Orwell: “The further a society drifts from truth, the more it will hate those who speak it.”

When politicians get caught in a lie

Let’s consider recent examples of each untruth.

In the summer of 2020, then-Gov. Jay Inslee was asked by media about the left-wing insurrection in Seattle known as CHAZ/CHOP. He said: “That’s news to me…. I have not heard anything about that.”

This was a bald-faced lie. Public documents showed that Inslee had been briefed on CHAZ/CHOP and was lying when asked about it. A few local TV stations noted what they called his “inconsistencies.” Print media ignored his lies altogether.

ADVERTISEMENT

More recently, State Sen. Jamie Pedersen made his notorious “Pie Crust Promise” remark to what he assumed was a “friendly” National Public Radio reporter, saying that his support of a ban on a state income tax in 2024 was a promise “easily made, easily broken.”

To his apparent surprise, the reporter reported it. A hopeful sign for the rest of us.
Still, outright lies like these are relatively rare, even in politics.

Using fancy words to hide the truth

Rhetorical framing or “shading” is much more common. We see examples of that all the time. We’re living through a big one right now: The current governor’s state income tax scheme.

When I spoke with the current governor on the Opening Day of the current legislative session, I asked him directly which of several state tax hike proposals he preferred: 1) the state income tax; 2) the “wealth” tax/expansion of the state capital gains tax; 3) the increase in state payroll tax; or 4) the increase in property tax.

ADVERTISEMENT

He answered directly: “the millionaires tax.”

Now that’s not a lie, exactly. But it is framing—and misleading. He knows his state income tax proposal isn’t going to be limited to “millionaires.” That’s unconstitutional. And ineffective. It will end up applying to most Washington families. Still, he clings anxiously to the frame.

Changing the name of a tax to suit the plan

State Sen. Pedersen gives us another example of mendacious rhetorical framing. It also involves tax policy. Interesting that there’s so much deceit around taxes.
Several years ago, Pedersen and his comrades in Olympia passed a state capital gain tax into law.

This was controversial because capital gains taxes are universally considered a type of income tax. And the Washington State Constitution in Article VII, Section 1, restricts how income tax can work in this state. The new tax was challenged on constitutional grounds and the Washington State Supreme Court came up with a bizarre opinion that allowed the tax to stay in place.

ADVERTISEMENT

It ruled that the capital gains tax is not an income tax but an excise tax (a tax on an activity). This opinion was universally ridiculed in judicial circles. Nevertheless, Washington Democrats clung to the bizarre fiction that a capital gain tax is an excise tax. Just a week ago (February 4),

Pedersen wrote in a Seattle Times opinion column: “That’s why Democrats passed the state’s first-ever capital gains excise tax.”

Over the next few days, something changed. Washington Democrats no longer say the state’s capital gains tax is an excise tax. Now, they admit what everyone else in world knows: It’s an income tax.

On February 8, 2026, Pedersen sent this written statement to the Lynnwood Times: “the only time in the last 15 years that Washington voters have weighed in on an income tax (I-2109 in 2024), they approved it by an almost 2/3 margin.”

The problem with saying one thing and doing another

I-2109 would have repealed the state capital gains tax. So, why is Pedersen now calling the capital gains tax “an income tax”? Because the rhetorical frame needs to move. Ferguson, Pedersen and other left-wing politicians in Olympia need to normalize a state income tax.

ADVERTISEMENT

To make their gullible supporters believe it’s always been in place and popular.
Oceana has always been as war with EastAsia. Even more commonplace in politics than lying or rhetorical framing is hypocrisy. What I call “intellectual dishonesty.”

Perhaps the most hypocritical, intellectually dishonest politician in Washington these days is State Attorney General Nick Brown. At his numerous press conferences, he has called the Trump Administration “authoritarian” and “dictatorial.”

He’s used taxpayer money to sue the Trump Administration about once a week, with many of those lawsuits dismissed on technical grounds or rejected on their merits. So, even if he’s not a very good lawyer, Brown dislikes “authoritarian” or “dictatorial” behavior. Right?

Pushing for more control over the public

Wrong. Only if the authoritarian is someone else. For himself, he loves authoritarian power. In the last year alone, he has requested or supported bills in Olympia that would allow him to:
• Weaponize “civil investigative demands,” warrants his office issues to itself (HB 2161)
• Expand the powers of his office’s investigators to parallel the State Patrol, etc. (HB 2156)
• Order his office’s investigators to operate secretly (HB 2096)
• Investigate and prosecute “environmental crimes” as felonies (SB 5360)
• Prosecute County Auditors for cooperating with federal agencies (SB 5892)

ADVERTISEMENT

Sounds pretty “dictatorial” and “authoritarian. And hypocritical. And, sadly, most common.

Jim Walsh is a Republican state representative from Aberdeen who serves as chairman of the Washington State Republican Party, where he has focused on rebuilding party infrastructure, candidate recruitment, and grassroots engagement.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

1 Comments

M
Mark Mad 9 months ago

OMG, the site is letting me start a thread!

Spot on. I can deal with the half truths of unrealistic campaign promises. The rest of the lies are getting worse the more we turn to only one party