Idaho governor pulls human rights commissioner after anti-ICE social media posts spark backlash
Idaho governor removes longtime human rights commissioner after senators review her controversial social media posts.
The Idaho State Capitol in Boise. (Photo: State of Idaho Facebook)
(Photo: State of Idaho Facebook)
After serving on the Idaho Human Rights Commission for over 30 years, Estella Zamora was removed from her position for social media posts critical of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
Governor Brad Little rescinded Zamora’s reappointment suddenly, shortly after she had a hearing with state senators. This decision came after conservative bloggers and social media users began criticizing posts Zamora made on Facebook.
New rules for state leaders
The governor’s office has already warned state agency leaders to be careful about their political activities this year. An email sent out in January told leaders they must check with the Governor’s office before attending political events or taking public stands on hot-button issues, according to Idaho Capital Sun.
The administration believes that because these officials represent the Governor, their public actions must be coordinated with his office.
Zamora says she was never told about these specific rules and felt she couldn’t stay silent about civil rights concerns.
The social media post in question
During a Senate hearing, several of Zamora’s past social media posts were brought to light by online critics.
One post featured a sign asking why members of groups like the Proud Boys and the Klan weren’t being deported to El Salvador if gang affiliation is illegal. Another post she shared called for the removal of federal immigration agents from certain cities following reports of violence during arrests.
Senate leaders stated that they were not going to move forward with her appointment because they felt her personal beliefs might interfere with her job. They argued that anyone on the Human Rights Commission must be fully committed to following the law without letting their own opinions get in the way.
What this means for the future
While Zamora says she is at peace with leaving the commission, she is worried about who will replace her.
She noted that the commission is losing multiple members all at once, and she hopes the new picks will represent the community fairly.
The Governor has not yet commented on the specific reason for her removal or who he plans to pick next. For now, the commission will have to wait for new leadership to be appointed and confirmed by the state Senate.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
2 Comments
As much as I disagree with her position, I support the 1st Amendment more. The article is unclear if the posts were made in her official capacity or private; all public employees should be free to exercise their right to free speech as private citizens without fear of reprisal from their coworkers or superiors.
The Governor requiring appointees to check in before exercising their rights or attending events is a gross overreach of power and spits on the Constitution imho.
While I agree with you where the problem occurs, for me, in that these "public servants" have become too comfortable in their elected and or appointed positions and in turn use their platforms for those agendas they choose to subscribe too. A little neutrality, even if in appearance only, isn't always such a bad thing. One guys $.02