ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Seattle Times reprints op-ed that treats drug traffickers as misunderstood entrepreneurs

Jason Rantz dismantles an op-ed that excuses drug traffickers, blames addiction victims, and demands endless spending while ignoring the flood of drugs.

A homeless man in a vacant lot in Seattle....

Homeless addicts are taking over vacant lots across Seattle.

The Seattle Times just republished an op-ed that reads like a defense brief for drug traffickers, and somehow thought it passed for serious moral reasoning. In a city drowning in fentanyl deaths, the paper chose to amplify an argument that treats the people flooding our streets with lethal narcotics as misunderstood participants in a supply chain rather than predators who profit off addiction and death.

The piece, written by Hugo Balta, argues that drug traffickers, smugglers, and suppliers should not be treated as villains because they are merely responding to American demand. That demand, readers are told, makes the United States the real engine of the crisis. Latin American drug networks are framed less as predators and more as rational market actors caught in a tragic economic system.

Before getting into the policy failures, it is worth asking a basic question. How did this get printed? Even by the standards of a paper that regularly launders radical activism through its opinion pages, this is a new low.

Treating poison pushers as passive participants

Balta opens by claiming the United States has spent decades condemning Latin American governments while ignoring its own role. The argument is provided in the context of the Trump administration’s decision to target drug smuggling boats in international waters.

The author insists this narrative is a distortion and says the central truth is simple. Americans keep buying drugs and can you really blame drug cartels for meeting the supply? He later states that Mexican criminal groups adapted to meet the market not because Mexico wanted to poison Americans, but because the U.S. market signaled what it was willing to buy.

ADVERTISEMENT

This logic is doing an astonishing amount of work. Drug cartels do not sell sweaters on Etsy. They manufacture and traffic substances designed to addict, degrade, and kill. Fentanyl is not an accidental byproduct of unmet consumer needs. It is a deliberate weaponized poison because it is cheap, potent, and profitable. Calling this basic economics does not make it morally neutral.

Balta briefly claims this is not a moral absolution of cartels. But then proceeds to do exactly that by shifting responsibility away from the people who flood communities with lethal narcotics and onto the people whose lives are destroyed by addiction.

Demand does not absolve supply

The op-ed leans heavily on overdose statistics and rising consumption to argue that supply is not the root of the crisis. Demand is. This framing is fashionable in academic circles and activist nonprofits because it conveniently avoids naming villains who can be punished.

ADVERTISEMENT

Demand does not emerge in a vacuum. Drug addiction is not the same as consumer preference. Addiction is a condition exploited by cartels that intentionally increase potency, availability, and lethality to maximize profit. If there were no flood of fentanyl, there would be fewer fentanyl addicts. If there were no meth labs and trafficking corridors, there would not be neighborhoods hollowed out by meth psychosis.

Supply creates demand just as much as demand attracts supply. This matters because policy follows narrative. If traffickers are merely responding to American appetites, then enforcement becomes suspect and borders become irrelevant. That is precisely the conclusion many on the Radical Left want readers to reach.

The endless money pit problem

Balta’s prescription is predictable. He calls for more money.

“If the U.S. government is serious about reducing the flow of narcotics, it must start by looking inward,” he writes. “That means investing in addiction treatment, regulating pharmaceutical practices, addressing economic despair and confronting the social conditions that make narcotics appealing in the first place. It means acknowledging that the drug trade is a hemispheric system — one in which the United States is not merely the endpoint, but the engine.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Notice what is missing. Any serious effort to stop drugs from entering the country.

We would not need an ever expanding addiction services budget if the previous administration did not allow an unprecedented volume of drugs to pour into American cities. And if we do not stop that flow, militarily if necessary, there will never be enough funding. The need will always outpace the resources because the supply is endless.

Seattle is living proof. Billions spent while overdose deaths hit historic highs, parks and sidewalks overtaken by addicts, and families destroyed. The answer from the same ideological class is always the same. Spend more and ask fewer questions.

Why the Seattle Times loved this

Republishing this op-ed was not an accident. It fits perfectly within the worldview that dominates the Seattle Times editors and news reporters. Criminals are misunderstood. Borders are passé. Personal responsibility is cruel. Systems are always to blame, except the systems run by progressives.

ADVERTISEMENT

Blaming Latin American cartels would require acknowledging evil actors. Blaming addiction itself would require admitting that permissive drug policies failed. It is far easier to blame America in the abstract and scold anyone who demands enforcement as lacking compassion.

The real victims here are not the traffickers Balta works so hard to contextualize. They are the addicts whose lives are shortened, the families left behind, and the communities forced to live with the consequences of elite moral cowardice.

Publishing this was not brave. It was embarrassing.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

1 Comments

H
Hugo Balta 10 months ago

Rantz misrepresents my argument. Pointing out that U.S. demand fuels the hemispheric drug trade is not ‘blaming Americans’ or excusing cartels—it’s acknowledging the basic economics every major study confirms. Enforcement alone has never reduced drug use or overdose deaths. We can hold traffickers accountable while also confronting the domestic conditions that make their business possible. Ignoring demand is why U.S. drug policy keeps failing.