Ninth Circuit smacks down Washington AG Nick Brown for targeting Christian homeless ministry
Ninth Circuit rules Washington violated the First Amendment by targeting Yakima Union Gospel Mission over faith-based hiring policies.
The Yakima Union Gospel Mission is taking its case before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals for the second time. (Photo: Yakima Union Gospel Mission)
(Photo: Yakima Union Gospel Mission)
In a unanimous ruling that sharply rebukes Washington state officials, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed Tuesday that the Yakima Union Gospel Mission has a constitutional right to hire employees who share and live out its Christian faith, even for non-ministerial roles.
The case, Union Gospel Mission of Yakima v. Brown, stemmed from Washington’s attempt to enforce the Washington Law Against Discrimination against the Christian homeless ministry after the state Supreme Court narrowed religious exemptions under state law. The Ninth Circuit ruled that enforcing the law against the Mission violated the First Amendment’s church autonomy doctrine, which protects religious organizations from government interference in internal decisions that affect faith and mission.
“The Religion Clauses of the First Amendment protect religious institutions from government interference over their internal affairs involving faith and doctrine,” Judge Patrick Bumatay wrote for the court, adding that the doctrine “forbids interference with ‘an internal church decision that affects the faith and mission of the church itself.’”
The judge added:
Hiring based on religious criteria may conflict with laws prohibiting employment decisions based on protected characteristics. Ordinarily, even religious institutions must follow generally applicable employment laws. But if state law were to prevent religious institutions from employing only co-religionists, those institutions could be forced to hire employees who openly flout and disagree with their religious principles. This, the First Amendment doesn’t tolerate. Because who a religious organization hires may go to the very character of its religious mission, the church autonomy doctrine protects the decision to hire co-religionists for non-ministerial roles if that decision is based on the organization’s sincerely held religious beliefs.
The court emphasized that the protection extends beyond clergy.
Humiliating loss for Attorney General Nick Brown
The Yakima Union Gospel Mission, a Christian nonprofit that operates homeless shelters, recovery programs, and meal services, requires employees to agree with and live out its Christian beliefs. That includes a requirement of “abstaining from any sexual conduct outside of biblical marriage between one man and one woman,” according to the court record.
Washington officials argued that the Mission should be forced to comply with state nondiscrimination rules for non-ministerial roles. The Ninth Circuit rejected that argument outright, concluding that the Mission’s hiring policies are rooted in sincerely held religious beliefs.
“Because who a religious organization hires may go to the very character of its religious mission, the church autonomy doctrine protects the decision to hire co-religionists for non-ministerial roles if that decision is based on the organization’s sincerely held religious beliefs,” the court ruled.
Alliance Defending Freedom, which represented the Mission, hailed the decision as a clear affirmation of constitutional protections for religious organizations operating in Washington and across the Ninth Circuit. The ruling affirmed a preliminary injunction blocking state enforcement and restores protections religious nonprofits in Washington had enjoyed for decades before the state’s courts narrowed them
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
6 Comments
Thanks to the leadership and passion of Mike Johnson! ( former CEO of Yakima Union Gospel Mission). His foresight about the risks of this law and his willingness to fight for Christian workplace rights led to this win.
This makes him and Sideshow Bob 0-2 on court cases related to religion. This one, and the Sideshow Bob wanting to know what I'm telling my priest in the confessional.
The Democrats believe the first amendment is even more dangerous than the second amendment to their wants to take over the world.
I'm an atheist and generally non-supportive of religious beliefs, but I'm also a huge proponent of limited government and Constitutional protections against government intrusion. This is absolutely the right call from the Ninth (shockingly), it wouldn't have even been a question if the defendant was a Muslim organization that only hired Muslims.