Rantz: Washington wants to erase its failed business climate by rezoning it away for housing
Washington Democrats want to convert empty malls and storefronts into housing — but Jason Rantz warns it masks the policies that drove jobs out.
Idaho zoning reform promotes attainable housing supply. (Photo: Jim WATSON/AFP via Getty Images)
(Photo: Jim WATSON/AFP via Getty Images)
Washington Democrats have a new plan to “solve” the housing crisis, by covering up their business unfriendly policies and attitudes. Instead of fixing the policies that chased jobs and businesses out of our cities, they want to bulldoze the evidence and build tiny apartments on top of it.
That’s the quiet subtext of a new report from the Office of Lieutenant Governor Denny Heck titled Commercial to Residential: A powerful tool to help solve our housing crisis. The proposal urges cities and the state to convert underused commercial land, like vacant malls, empty big-box stores, strip centers, and parking lots, into housing.
On paper, the idea sounds reasonable. And perhaps, in certain circumstances, it would be wise. The report notes Washington needs more than one million new homes in the next two decades and admits “we are not building them nearly fast enough.” It argues that underutilized commercial land offers a way to add housing “without removing as much existing housing or greenspace,” while dramatically increasing tax revenue and density.
But buried in the report is a far more uncomfortable truth: government is the primary reason these projects don’t happen. And that’s not going to change.
A Democrat at least being honest
The report repeatedly concedes that “infrastructure costs, regulatory gridlock, existing private agreements, and difficult financing” stand in the way of housing development. It acknowledges that permitting timelines are still “costly and onerous,” that mandatory ground-floor retail often kills projects, and that affordability mandates can be so aggressive that “projects fail and no housing is built.”
In other words, Olympia created the mess, and now wants credit for proposing a workaround. Kudos for the honesty and not instinctively demonizing developers as Democrats do too often, but this admission shouldn’t be overlooked.
What the report never seriously grapples with is why so much commercial property is sitting empty. These aren’t relics of a bygone economy. They’re casualties of Democrat governance. Businesses didn’t abandon our cities because Washingtonians stopped shopping. They left because theft is tolerated, taxes and labor mandates are crushing them, and public safety is optional.
The report admits that much of this land is “not currently dedicated to a high-value purpose.” That’s only true because state and local policies made operating a business prohibitively expensive.
How is this a solution?
Converting failed commercial space into housing may increase assessed value, but it also risks locking in economic decline. Housing without nearby jobs isn’t revitalization, is it? You end up with “bedroom communities,” longer commutes, and fewer opportunities for working-class residents. Where will the businesses be built or operate if we’re turning business-occupied real estate into apartment complexes?
Even Heck seems to sense this tension, noting that mixed-use projects preserving commercial space are often preferable. Yet the political instinct will be to rezone first and ask questions later.
Washington doesn’t just have a housing shortage. It has a governance problem. Until Democrats fix their own policies that chased employers away, rezoning commercial land into apartments doesn’t seem like the answer.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
4 Comments
What's really missing from this article and the report is the recognition that the majority of this "unused" land is private property. The government wants to rezone and convert but the property isn't theirs and the greed demonstrated is sickening. Heaven forbid anyone suggest cutting government spending to align with actual revenue or reducing red tape and fees to encourage growth.
It's the story of the Democratic Party: Perpetually creating problems so that they can continually "solve" them. This commercial to residential idea is also probably behind Katie Wilson's asinine plan to tax retail vacancies, in that they aren't really interested in commercial spaces being filled, as they are driving down the cost of commercial real estate by forcing those owners to sell to an entity that will then turn it into residential. Marxist Dystopia is already here, and it's going to be a disaster, like it always has been and always will.
State, County, City (WA) government agencies have by design gone from the noble role of "public servants" to "revenuers".