Prof. Reges: UW tried to fire me for having the ‘wrong’ opinion on land acknowledgments
UW professor Stuart Reges says a Ninth Circuit free speech ruling exposed ideological enforcement on campus after administrators punished him for a parody land acknowledgment.
A new FIRE study using campaign giving data finds University of Washington faculty contributors cluster ideologically to the left of even the most progressive members of Congress. (Photo by Karen Ducey/Getty Images)
(Photo by Karen Ducey/Getty Images)
A Ninth Circuit ruling that rebuked the University of Washington for violating the First Amendment is now reverberating across campus culture debates nationwide, as professor Stuart Reges says the case exposed just how far university administrators were willing to go to enforce ideological conformity.
Reges, a longtime computer science professor at UW, joined The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM after the appellate court ruled that the university unconstitutionally retaliated against him for a parody land acknowledgment he included in his syllabus. The court found that UW officials launched a disciplinary investigation, reprimanded Reges, and threatened punishment because they disagreed with his viewpoint.
“It’s been almost four years, a really long time,” Reges said.
How did the controversy erupt?
Reges explained that the controversy began in winter 2022, when UW’s diversity committee encouraged faculty to add land acknowledgments to their syllabi. Professors were told they could write their own. Reges did exactly that, grounding his statement in John Locke’s labor theory of property and disputing the claim that the land occupied by UW was stolen.
“Well, that’s not what you’re supposed to say,” Reges said. “You’re supposed to say it’s stolen land.”
The response from UW was swift. Administrators apologized to students, removed Reges’s syllabus without his consent, created an alternate course section for students to flee into, and opened a disciplinary investigation that dragged on for more than a year.
“They were saying you might be fired for this,” Reges said.
Hypocrisy at UW
The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression backed Reges throughout the lawsuit, which initially failed in district court before being overturned on appeal. The Ninth Circuit ruled that student discomfort was not a valid justification for retaliating against protected speech and ordered judgment entered in Reges’s favor.
Reges also pointed to a broader institutional hypocrisy. While UW tolerated illegal encampments that violated state law, he said administrators aggressively pursued him for speech that offended progressive sensibilities.
“I said something that offended their sensibility about American Indian students, and suddenly the university had to act,” Reges said.
An even bigger win
Since the controversy began, UW has quietly repealed Executive Order 31, a policy that allowed punishment for speech deemed inappropriate even if it did not rise to illegal harassment or discrimination, he said. Reges added that change alone validated the core argument of his case.
“You can’t tell people that if you say inappropriate things, we’ll punish you and then not tell them what inappropriate means,” he said.
As for the future, Reges remains cautious but sees early signs of resistance among faculty to rigid DEI enforcement. “The people who are pushing for that are not in the driver’s seat anymore,” he said.
The case now returns to the lower court to determine remedies, but the ruling has already delivered a clear message: public universities cannot punish professors simply for challenging progressive orthodoxy.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
1 Comments
Dr. Reges is fighting the good fight. 👍