ADVERTISEMENT

EDUCATION

Ninth Circuit Court slaps UW with huge loss for punishing professor over land acknowledgment parody

Ninth Circuit rules University of Washington violated the First Amendment by retaliating against a professor over a parody land acknowledgment in his syllabus.

UW faces civil rights complaint over bathroom policies. (Photo: Karen Ducey, Getty Images)...

UW faces civil rights complaint over bathroom policies. (Photo: Karen Ducey, Getty Images)

(Photo: Karen Ducey, Getty Images)

A federal appeals court has ruled that the University of Washington violated the First Amendment by retaliating against a professor who refused to parrot the school’s preferred political messaging in his syllabus.

In a decision issued Friday, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals sided with University of Washington computer science professor Stuart Reges, finding that university officials unlawfully punished him for including a parody land acknowledgment that challenged the ideological premise behind UW’s recommended statement.

The case stems from a 2021 push by UW’s Paul G. Allen School of Computer Science and Engineering encouraging professors to include land acknowledgments in their syllabi. Reges instead wrote his own, stating that “by the labor theory of property the Coast Salish people can claim historical ownership of almost none of the land currently occupied by the University of Washington.”

University administrators quickly labeled the statement “offensive” and “inappropriate,” launched a disciplinary investigation, removed the statement from his syllabus without consent, and warned Reges against repeating it in the future. The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression sued, arguing the school engaged in viewpoint discrimination.

The Ninth Circuit agreed.

Here’s why the Ninth Circuit sided against UW

Writing for the majority, Circuit Judge Daniel Bress rejected the university’s claim that student discomfort justified retaliation, stating, “Student discomfort with a professor’s views can prompt discussion and disapproval. But this discomfort is not grounds for the university retaliating against the professor.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The court found UW subjected Reges to adverse employment actions, including a prolonged investigation and reprimand, solely because of his protected speech on a matter of public concern. It ruled that the university failed the required First Amendment balancing test and ordered judgment entered in Reges’s favor on both retaliation and viewpoint discrimination claims.

The ruling also revived Reges’s challenge to UW’s nondiscrimination policy, which allows discipline for “any conduct that is deemed unacceptable or inappropriate.” The appeals court found the district court improperly narrowed the policy and sent the issue back for further review, raising broader concerns about vague speech restrictions on campus.

The case now returns to the lower court to determine appropriate relief.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

3 Comments

M
Mark Justmark 11 months ago

Does anyone know if entire UW College of Engineering mandated the 'land acknowledgement'?

I'd like to add it to my list of evidence of Ana Mari Cauce's toxic leftist indoctrination spreading into the STEM majors.

I've tried to converse with incoming UW STEM grads to my company, but this is one I've stayed away from in case the newhire is offended.

D
David Anfinrud 11 months ago

That last paragraph talking about vague rules that can be interpreted in many different ways. Make the rules vague and anyone is guilty of everything.

J
Jason Pantz 11 months ago

Ridiculous embarrassing nonsense “land acknowledgment“. Activists have taken over a once respected school. Now they charge insane money to come be indoctrinated. Indians were conquered. They get special rights and some even get checks. What other country does this? Stop complaining and run your casino chief.