ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Fired judge reinstated after claiming criticism of her abusive personality was racism

Washington Supreme Court overturned removal of Judge Tracy Flood despite stipulated misconduct, citing race and bias claims while staff fled her courtroom.

The Washington State Supreme Court came to the rescue of Judge Tracy Flood, effectively agreeing th...

The Washington State Supreme Court came to the rescue of Judge Tracy Flood, effectively agreeing that if you criticize a black female judge, you're a racist. (Screengrab: Commission on Judicial Conduct)

(Screengrab: Commission on Judicial Conduct)

The Washington Commission on Judicial Conduct did something rare and serious when it recommended removing a sitting judge from office. That alone should tell you how bad things were inside Bremerton Municipal Court under Judge Tracy Flood.

This discipline was about repeated misconduct, and a court collapsing under the weight of its own dysfunction, according to the allegations. The judge was reportedly so abusive that the Commission said that one of her staff member was nearly driven to “self-harm.” And yet the Washington Supreme Court stepped in and rescued Flood’s career merely because, according to the court, race and gender needed to be factored into whether she should be held fully accountable.

This decision makes a mockery of the judicial system and it has some local judges fuming.

The record of misconduct is devastating

Judge Flood stipulated to violating multiple provisions of the Code of Judicial Conduct. She admitted she failed to treat staff and attorneys with patience, dignity, and respect, according to the record. She admitted to discourteous, harsh, and condescending behavior. The Supreme Court itself acknowledged that she engaged in conduct that was “rude, condescending, or harsh toward staff and litigants” and that her behavior caused serious harm inside the court.

This wasn’t a one-off personality clash, either. The Supreme Court noted corroborated testimony of staff being reduced to tears, developing anxiety, depression, and distress because of their interactions with Flood. One employee increased anxiety medication dosage. Others testified they felt humiliated, belittled, and afraid to ask clarifying questions.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Multiple people who worked at the court were humiliated and personally and professionally undermined in ways that impacted their physical and emotional health to the point that more than one person contemplated self-harm,” the Commission noted. “People who had worked in the court system for decades and were dedicated to the work took cuts in pay and forewent benefits to which they were entitled to escape Respondent’s abuse. No court can operate without a competent staff consistently and promptly serving the public on a daily basis.”

The result was mass attrition. The Supreme Court stated that “a total of 19 staff members left the court” during Flood’s tenure, including people she herself hired to replace those who fled. That’s not normal turnover.

Claiming racism

Flood effectively defended her conduct by claiming she was merely a victim of racism.

“Respondent believed some staff did not like being told what to do by a Black woman,” Flood’s lawyers claimed in a document, before saying she was subject to racist “tone policing.”

ADVERTISEMENT

“Tone policing predominantly happens to Black women,” Flood’s lawyers claim. “They are asked to remove any emotion as they speak, make a suggestion, or recommendation in a meeting. Black women are asked to tailor their message, so the recipient is ‘able’ to hear them and what they are trying to say. Tone policing is a microaggression against Black women that propagates the ‘angry Black woman’ stereotype.'”

Yet, the Commission noted, Flood’s “misconduct began almost immediately upon the judge attaining her position and has continued throughout her tenure.”

Commission didn’t buy the racism claims, but the Washington State Supreme Court did

The Commission concluded the damage was so severe, and Flood so resistant to correction, that removal was warranted. That recommendation triggered her suspension from the bench.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Until the first day of the hearing, Respondent’s posture toward this case has been that it was an illegitimate and corrupt proceeding borne out of unfair and racist allegations,” the Commission concluded. “On the first day of the hearing, she stipulated to violation of all but one of the charges, purportedly to take responsibility, but in her own testimony she consistently denied responsibility for any aspect of her troubles at Bremerton Municipal Court.”

Flood was beyond reforming her behavior. Perhaps she assumed the far-left, identity-focused Washington State Supreme Court would reverse the punishment. She was right.

The court repeatedly emphasized Flood’s identity. The justices wrote that she was operating in a “predominantly white environment” and that “some staff were consciously or unconsciously resistant toward change in court administration and critical of her leadership as a Black woman.” Was there any credible evidence of this? No. But they wouldn’t dare question Flood’s claims because she’s a black woman.

ADVERTISEMENT

The opinion went further, saying it would “neither deny the role of racism in our justice system and workplace dynamics nor disregard the power dynamics at play.” That framing matters, because it fundamentally changes the accountability standard.

Ignoring the facts of the case

While Flood claimed that criticism of her tone amounted to racism, tone policing wasn’t the actual issue. Behavior was. Repeated, documented behavior that caused people to quit, the court to malfunction, restitution to go undistributed, warrants to be mishandled, and defendants to be wrongly detained.

The Supreme Court acknowledged all of that. It confirmed violations not just of decorum rules, but of the duty to competently manage a court. It cited failures to disburse restitution, delayed warrants, mislabeling dockets, and operational chaos that harmed victims and defendants alike.

And yet, the court rejected removal anyway, explicitly disagreeing with the Commission’s conclusion that Flood was not amenable to improvement.

ADVERTISEMENT

“The court does not share the commission’s unmitigated pessimism for improvement by Judge Flood,” Justice Stephens wrote.

That’s remarkable, given that Flood’s misconduct continued even after coaching began, and even after staff departures mounted. Perhaps the Court missed the documentation detailing how Flood’s own “coach” was critical of the work she was doing. They likely just ignored it.

Flood seemed untrainable

Flood engaged in coaching and training with an expert of her own choosing, both before and after being urged by Commission staff to do so. She also sought help from LaTricia Kinlow, a highly respected black court administrator with decades of experience, telling her that race was a factor in the problems she was experiencing.

Kinlow, taking the allegation seriously, recruited another experienced court administrator, Jennefer Johnson, who also identifies as a woman of color, and together they conducted on-site assessments and provided extensive hands-on assistance to the court over several months.

ADVERTISEMENT

Despite expecting to find evidence of racial or institutional bias, Kinlow testified that she did not observe macro- or micro-aggressions or other indicators of workplace racism. Instead, she found a court in administrative disarray, staffed largely by inexperienced employees struggling to manage basic functions such as accounting, document processing, and docketing. Kinlow and others repeatedly witnessed Judge Flood treating staff harshly, including yelling at a new employee until she was reduced to tears, dismissing staff input, rejecting operational recommendations, and cutting off questions in meetings.

“Before a new court administrator was hired, Ms. Kinlow testified she was present to assist in Bremerton almost every other day,” the Commission said. “For a length of time, Ms. Kinlow received permission from her presiding judge to loan Bremerton two clerks to assist Respondent’s court. Those clerks were made uncomfortable by Respondent’s demeanor in court towards attorneys and asked permission to no longer assist (that permission was granted).”

ADVERTISEMENT

Race-based judgment

The uncomfortable truth is that no other judge would get this kind of leniency after stipulating to misconduct that drove nearly 20 employees out the door and crippled court operations. The Supreme Court didn’t just reinstate Flood’s eligibility to serve again. It created a two-track system of judicial discipline, where identity can soften consequences that would otherwise end a career.

If contrived “tone policing” is racism, then accountability disappears. If employees must tolerate being demeaned because the judge belongs to a protected class, the rule of law gives way to identity politics. And when that happens, public trust in the judiciary collapses.

This wasn’t justice. It was special treatment. Flood’s ultimate punishment was changed to 30 days without compensation. She’ll soon return to the bench to play victim and mistreat people because she got the green light from the Washington Supreme Court.

ADVERTISEMENT

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

17 Comments

M
Mark Justmark 11 months ago

Ferguson and Brown are probably huddling to determine where "Judge" Flood can be appointed/promoted in order to do the most damage to honest citizens from majority demographics.

And yet another data point to suggest WSSC is bought.

J
Jason Pantz 11 months ago

How are these people left in charge? If this is how she thinks, getting fired was the right move. She’s obviously not qualified nor does she have any grasp on what it means to be accountable. The opposite qualities anyone should want in a judge.

B
Big Dog 11 months ago

I found where Judge Flood was elected in 2021. That means she gets to run for reelection at some point. The good people of Bremerton can send her packing soon! I’m guessIng she ends up working for AG, Nick Brown.