ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Olympia ignored the data and just raised your plastic bag fees anyway

Washington is hiking plastic bag fees even after its own study showed the ban increased plastic waste. Jason Rantz breaks down the failure.

Thanks to Democrats ignoring the data, your plastic bag fees are now up. (Photo by Kevork Djansezia...

Thanks to Democrats ignoring the data, your plastic bag fees are now up. (Photo by Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images)

(Photo by Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images)

Washington Democrats love telling you to follow the science. Until the science embarrasses them. Then it gets buried, dismissed, or conveniently labeled inconclusive, right before lawmakers double down anyway. That is exactly what just happened with the state’s plastic bag policy.

Washington shoppers will now pay a higher fee for reusable plastic bags, jumping from eight cents to 12 cents per bag, plus sales tax. The fee hike comes despite the state’s own commissioned research showing the policy is doing the opposite of what lawmakers promised.

This is the state ignoring its own data because the results were politically inconvenient.

Ignoring the data

Washington hired researchers at Washington State University to evaluate whether the 2021 plastic bag ban was working. The answer came back loud and clear. While the number of plastic bags distributed dropped by about half, total plastic use by weight increased by roughly 17 percent. In other words, shoppers used fewer bags, but far more plastic overall.

The reason is painfully obvious. Olympia outlawed thin single-use bags and forced retailers to switch to thick, heavy plastic bags marketed as reusable. Those bags weigh roughly four times as much as the ones they replaced. Fewer bags does not mean less plastic. It means heavier plastic.

That outcome alone should have triggered an immediate course correction. Instead, state agencies did something remarkable. After receiving the WSU report, the Departments of Commerce and Ecology published it with a multi-page rebuttal arguing against the findings of the study they paid for, as reported by KIRO Newsradio’s Charlie Harger.

ADVERTISEMENT

They didn’t produce competing data. They didn’t dispute the math. They simply labeled the conclusions inconclusive and complained the research failed to account for broader social and environmental considerations, a familiar bureaucratic dodge that signals ideology has replaced evidence.

Despite all of this, lawmakers are now raising the bag fee anyway.

An eco-performance

The fee increase isn’t about reducing plastic waste. If it were, policymakers would follow the researchers’ recommendation to eliminate the thickness requirement and allow thin bags with a modest pass-through charge. That approach would actually reduce plastic by weight. Instead, the state is preserving the very mandate that caused plastic use to spike.

This is environmental policy as performance art.

The real-world consequences go beyond environmental hypocrisy. Retailers are getting crushed. Grocery stores and small businesses are forced to charge a fee that often doesn’t cover the actual cost of the bags they are legally required to provide. Consumers are paying more at checkout while businesses eat the rest of the expense.

ADVERTISEMENT

Don’t fall for the spin

And no, consumers are not reusing these bags enough to justify the environmental tradeoff. Independent studies cited in the state’s own analysis show thick plastic bags must be reused many times just to break even environmentally. The research found only a minority of Washington shoppers consistently reuse them. Most end up tossed, stuffed under sinks, or thrown away after a few uses.

Even recycling hasn’t improved. Very few jurisdictions offer curbside recycling for plastic carryout bags, meaning most of these heavier bags end up in landfills or the environment, where they last longer and do more damage than their thinner predecessors.

So what did Washington do with all this information? It raised the fee.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

3 Comments

P
Pablo Abo 11 months ago

Typical Washington Democrat virtue signaling. They're 100% consistent in their arbitrary use of science to craft policy and 100% consistent in ignoring data when inconvenient.
Bags, straws, carbon tax...

S
Shawn m 11 months ago

Let's not forget the use of science fiction, too.

S
scotty icicle 11 months ago

virtue signaling is truly a sport for the low IQ....unreal...simpletons..