ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Seattle Times scolds Trump for public ICE raids while celebrating the policies that force them

A critique of the Seattle Times editorial board for denouncing public ICE raids while celebrating sanctuary policies that prevent jails from cooperating with federal agents.

The Seattle Times editorial board has reached a new level of indescribably bad-faith spin that it almost seems like a parody. In one breath, they cheer King County for ignoring ICE detainers. In the next, they clutch their pearls because ICE increasingly relies on public, high-visibility raids instead of jail transfers. This is willful blindness.

“But if jail is where the criminals are, the administration is apparently spending much more effort on community raids and high-profile street arrests,” the Seattle Times editorial board wrote, after noting that the Trump administration hasn’t sought as many detainers in the second term, since they were all ignored in the first term.

They didn’t seem to be able to connect the dots that ignoring the ICE detainers is precisely why the Trump administration must rely on public raids to catch criminal illegal immigrants.

Sanctuary policies have consequences

If Washington weren’t a sanctuary state, with King County and Seattle offering the most aggressive sanctuary rules in the region, federal immigration agents wouldn’t be forced into neighborhoods, workplaces, or parking lots to arrest people who should have been transferred quietly from jail. The Times pretends these two dynamics exist in different universes, never intersecting, never influencing one another. But this is the direct result of local politicians refusing to participate in even the most basic cooperation with federal law enforcement.

The editorial boasts that King County ignored every one of the 1,262 ICE detainer requests filed between 2017 and 2020. It reads like an achievement unlocked. Yet these same ignored detainers often involve suspects charged with serious offenses. They were already in jail, which makes the editorial’s later claim that the Trump administration isn’t targeting the “worst of the worst” even more bad faith.

ADVERTISEMENT

The left routinely reframes these individuals as innocent locals unfairly swept up in anti-immigrant zeal, even when their criminal histories or pending charges suggest otherwise. The public raids the Times now condemns exist precisely because local jails refuse to allow a controlled, safe handoff.

Bad data

The editorial then cites the CATO Institute—an advocacy organization with a long record of campaigning against immigration enforcement.

CATO openly supports dramatically reducing or eliminating immigration restrictions and has published multiple papers arguing that illegal immigration is beneficial to the economy and should not be criminally enforced. Their oft-quoted study on immigrant crime rates has been widely criticized by criminologists for methodological flaws (which I detail at-length in my book “What’s Killing America”), including inappropriate aggregation of data and failure to control for reporting gaps. Researchers at the Center for Immigration Studies, among others, have repeatedly documented its omissions and the fact that CATO’s conclusions are driven by policy preferences, not neutral analysis.

ADVERTISEMENT

Yet the Times treats CATO as an unimpeachable arbiter while dismissing ICE’s own publicly available arrest summaries. They lament that only five percent of detainees have violent convictions, ignoring that many arrests involve suspects with pending charges, prior deportation orders, or cases that have yet to reach adjudication. They treat unadjudicated cases as if they are exonerations.

That is the core dishonesty. They criticize the federal government for the consequences of the sanctuary policies the Times spends every year defending. If King County honored detainers, most arrests would happen inside jails, not in the community. Instead, the Times demands one outcome while championing the exact conditions that make it impossible.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

3 Comments

P
PF George 12 months ago

Let me get this straight: King County arrests someone for being a very bad person, but refuses to turn that person over to ICE authorities when requested to do so. Then when ICE finds that person on the street corner and arrests him for deportation, King County cries because they should have just taken that person from the jail. But it is King County who will refuse any detainers being requested by ICE. And the Seattle Times is highlighting this exact issue as being some kind of moral dilemma?

All because some bleeding hearts don't like it that the president is wanting to uphold Federal immigration laws.

E
Evan Lattimore 12 months ago

Can't be overstated how awful The Ed Murray Times is. The Blethen Family paper has been a stain on the region for far too long now. They need to just disband at this point, they not only offer nothing of value, but actually make things worse.

P
Pablo Abo 12 months ago

Seattle Times equals bad faith reporting