ADVERTISEMENT

CULTURE

Sandpoint City Council repeals anti-discrimination ordinance following locker room privacy outcry

Sandpoint City Council repeals anti-discrimination ordinance following YMCA locker room privacy outcry.

The Sandpoint City Council moved to protect women in the trans bathroom debate. (Screengrab: Sandpo...

The Sandpoint City Council moved to protect women in the trans bathroom debate. (Screengrab: Sandpoint City Council)

(Screengrab: Sandpoint City Council)

The Sandpoint City Council in Idaho voted last week to repeal the city’s 14-year-old nondiscrimination ordinance (NDO), following three hours of emotional public testimony sparked by an incident involving a biological male reportedly using the women’s locker room at a local YMCA.

Mayor Jeremy Grimm cast the tie-breaking vote to adopt a new ordinance that removes the city’s local protections for gender identity, effectively deferring complex social issues back to state and federal law. The decision comes amidst heated public outcry centered on women’s safety and privacy.

Women’s safety over policy

The public debate was triggered by an October 15 incident at the Litehouse YMCA.

According to a Facebook post by Bonner County Republican Party Chairman Scott Herndon, a lifeguard encountered an apparent transgender woman in the women’s locker room. Both YMCA management and a Sandpoint police officer informed the lifeguard that no laws or company policies were violated, as the facility adheres to code allowing use of facilities corresponding to gender identity.

This lack of action under the old NDO fueled the drive for repeal. Councilman Rick Howarth argued that the council’s responsibility was to protect biological women, questioning why the rights of transgender woman should be prioritized over the safety of others.

“We must stand up for the rights of women,” adding that keeping the original code would allow “predators” into women’s bathrooms, placing the blame squarely on the council if something “bad” happened,” Howarth told The Spokesman-Review.

ADVERTISEMENT

Mayor Grimm, who drafted the new ordinance, echoed concerns that the old policy created unacceptable privacy risks.

“Any woman, including school-aged girls like my own daughter, do not feel comfortable showering or changing alongside a biological male. … Protecting those spaces is not about rejecting anyone’s humanity. It’s about recognizing that women’s privacy needs are real, valid and worthy of protection,” Grimm told The Spokesman-Review.

Public fear and local overreach

The council chambers were packed with dozens of residents speaking overwhelmingly in favor of repealing the 2011 ordinance. Testimony was dominated by fear and emotion with sexual assault victims fighting back tears while voicing anxiety about biological men in women’s private spaces.

“If you have been assaulted, you would understand our fear,” one woman told The Spokesman-Review.

Many residents along with Bonner County Sheriff Daryl Wheeler and Herndon argued that state and federal laws already provide adequate protection against discrimination making the city’s local ordinance unnecessary overreach. Grimm questioned whether a small municipal government should have the authority to decide who enters private changing rooms.

ADVERTISEMENT

“These are complex civil rights questions that, in my opinion, belong to the state or federal law, not to local ordinance or enforcement by a politically appointed review board,” he told The Spokesman-Review.

The new ordinance eliminates the previous local Human Relations Review Board and complaint process, funneling all future discrimination claims to state and federal agencies. Grimm argued this move prevents litigation risk and reduces community division caused by local policy debate.

Decision pushed despite opposition

The vote followed the failure of two motions designed to stall the decision which were to table the ordinance until January and another to push the decision to the voters. Councilmen Joel Aispuro, Justin Dick, and Howarth voted for the new ordinance. Council members Pam Duquette, Kyle Schreiber, and Deb Ruehle voted against it.

Duquette criticized Grimm for ignoring the 80 businesses and numerous community members who supported the original NDO calling the issue an “emotionally charged” and “religious” one that was “dividing our community unnecessarily.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Grimm responded directly, stating he was not ignoring the thousands of businesses that did not respond.

“I’m not ignoring the most important thing, which is my conscience,” Grimm told The Spokesman-Review.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Jasneet Gill Content Editor

Jasneet Gill is a content editor and writer for Seattle Red. She is a Washington native, born and raised in the state, and a graduate of the University of Washington with a bachelor's degree in Communications. Her passion for soccer led her to play… Read more

Comments

2 Comments

S
Shawn m 12 months ago

Right-headed thinking in action is beautiful to see!

C
Candis Gauvin 12 months ago

Now we need to do this in Washington State 💯